Edgy Magical Girls

>Good? Bad?
>Do we need more of them?
>Do you prefer more magical girls or more edge?
>Why is every edgy magical girl show filled with dykes and/or Yuri undertones, typically without any male love interests?

Attached: 1553099595428.jpg (1200x675, 99K)

Other urls found in this thread:

is2.Yea
blog-imgs-101.fc2.com/t/e/s/tesuto93/Mx9b8kl.jpg
hotima.blogspot.com/2012/03/blog-post_7542.html
twitter.com/horikoshiko/status/762575285191532544
pixiv.navirank.com/user/5302938/
komikid.com/manga/boku-no-hero-academia/137/15
twitter.com/kurosep?lang=ja
twitter.com/watariwataru/status/435115910156677120
twitter.com/watariwataru/status/564212175640596481
twitter.com/sankakuhead/status/962876167907766272
twitter.com/sankakuhead/status/1085915444702138369
twitter.com/_saburouta/status/711452477686546432
twitter.com/tokutaro/status/227311959731740672
twitter.com/tokutaro/status/554066780721672192
twitter.com/tokutaro/status/1009267169916407808
twitter.com/tokutaro/status/1107060880393396224
vndb.org/v20847
twitter.com/AnonBabble

Some people in the industry realised that magical girls getting beat up is more entertaining than expected at first. Essentially you get to watch them get hurt from a sadist angle but it's ok because they're magic so they can take it.

Really depends on the degree of edge for me. Killing off characters all willy nilly is a huge turn off, but mental and physical scars are a-okay. I never though I would enjoy military x magical girls so much.

Attached: when your friend confesses she's guilty of defending your freedoms.png (484x472, 184K)

Animuh or mango?

when the fuck is Liden announcing season 2 bros

>>Why is every edgy magical girl show filled with dykes and/or Yuri undertones, typically without any male love interests?
fuck off trying to start /u/ and anti-/u/ shit faggot

I wouldn't expect S2 announcement anytime soon.
First season went through 6 volumes of manga (ending with a required big battle).
There's just not enough source material out yet.

It jumped the shark as a trope after Madoka. Now everything feels derivative of that but with boobies. Personally, I think a deconstruction of the edgy magical girl is in order.

Magical girls have been suffering for generations.

Attached: [Cleo]Magic_Knight_Rayearth_-_20_(Dual Audio_10bit_BD1080p_x265).mkv_snapshot_21.38_[2019.05.15_00.4 (1440x1080, 228K)

>Now everything feels derivative of that
Can you elaborate on that?
How's OP derivative of Madoka for example.
And what about the 'but with boobies' part?
Half the Madoka threads were already about Mami's mamies.

I need more

Attached: 1553291455522.jpg (1280x720, 217K)

>Can you elaborate on that?
He can't.
Anyone who brings up Madoka in these threads is just talking out of their ass.

>I think a deconstruction of the edgy magical girl is in order.
Read Machimaho it's a bout a prim and proper Ojusama whos actually a chain smoking, energy drink swilling, foul mouthed yankee getting turned into a magical girl and fighting evil it takes the piss out of the edge of a lot of these series the main girl is 10/10, the second girl is also 10/10 and the male love interest/punching bag is some how both based and a goddamn joke in the best way

Attached: 000_1550207405.jpg (1437x2048, 647K)

I’m pretty sure there are more edgy magical girls than magical girls played straight at this point.

you mean when is klab announcing the mobage

please, there's like 30 seasons of Precure alone.

I dig them, wish there was a decent one every season. I'd really like to get the shocking twist that all is not as it should be again. I went into Madoka as it aired knowing nothing other than that it was made by shaft and had a few cute girly nonsense ads run during Arakawa Under The Bridge.
Thank the good lord for whichever encoder left the commercials in during that season.

Attached: 1410821879463.jpg (1920x1080, 494K)

>Why is every edgy magical girl show filled with dykes and/or Yuri undertones
purityfag-waifufag-yurifag unholy alliance.

Purityfag allows no male interaction but might be less offended by girl-girl (if it's not too heavy, kissing is too much since pfag is autistic and can't imagine humans touching).
Waifufag is close to purityfag but might be OK with a male self-insert romance, he's not OK with girl-girl going too far either since it's HIS waifu.
Yurifag is happy with any girl-girl he can get but not too happy about things never crossing the subtext line. Loathes male interaction.

>Why is every edgy magical girl show filled with dykes and/or Yuri undertones, typically without any male love interests?
The simple answer is because 90% of the cast is female. It's hardly exclusive to edgy magical girls.

I just want more MGRP. It's utterly fascinating from a "how much more can Snow White suffer before she finally blooms and destroys everything" perspective.

magical girls?
is2.Yea Forums.org/wsg/1557404158212.webm
is2.Yea Forums.org/wsg/1557399146455.webm
is2.Yea Forums.org/wsg/1557400831163.webm
is2.Yea Forums.org/wsg/1557534606386.webm
is2.Yea Forums.org/wsg/1557547412818.webm
is2.Yea Forums.org/wsg/1557408935939.webm

This is JUMP
is2.Yea Forums.org/wsg/1557461240753.webm
is2.Yea Forums.org/wsg/1557463216448.webm
is2.Yea Forums.org/wsg/1557455440892.webm
is2.Yea Forums.org/wsg/1557458658836.webm
is2.Yea Forums.org/wsg/1557460192987.webm
is2.Yea Forums.org/wsg/1557542624911.webm
is2.Yea Forums.org/wsg/1557527814273.webm
is2.Yea Forums.org/wsg/1557530622183.webm

For a while I thought there were too many edgy magical girl shows but I've learned to enjoy the edge and also the ryona

Attached: 1551900372855.png (1920x1882, 2.5M)

Machimaho is the goddamned best.

When or where is the new chapter?

Precure is fucking awful.

Precure is great for the doujins.
I especially love the ones where they overdose on drugs, but still live as they are much tougher than normal human.

Give it next week we should get raw scans coming from there.

KURUMI BTFO

You are right.
Precure makes many cartoonists unable to extricate themselves.

blog-imgs-101.fc2.com/t/e/s/tesuto93/Mx9b8kl.jpg
Comic author of ONE PIECE sees PreCure as a competitor


hotima.blogspot.com/2012/03/blog-post_7542.html
Gen Urobuchi likes to watch PreCure
He also wants to write a script for PreCure.
Part of Madoka's creative inspiration may come from HeartCatch PreCure!


twitter.com/horikoshiko/status/762575285191532544
pixiv.navirank.com/user/5302938/
komikid.com/manga/boku-no-hero-academia/137/15
The comic author of My Hero Academia likes to watch PreCure
Also helped PreCure draw a lot of Doujin
My Hero Academia mentioned PreCure

twitter.com/kurosep?lang=ja
Comic author of Goblin Slayer likes to watch PreCure
He painted a lot of PreCure Doujin


twitter.com/watariwataru/status/435115910156677120
twitter.com/watariwataru/status/564212175640596481
The novelist of My Youth Romantic Comedy Is Wrong also likes to watch PreCure


twitter.com/sankakuhead/status/962876167907766272
twitter.com/sankakuhead/status/1085915444702138369
Himouto! Umaru-chan's comic author likes to watch PreCure


twitter.com/_saburouta/status/711452477686546432
Comic author of citrus likes to watch PreCure


twitter.com/tokutaro/status/227311959731740672
twitter.com/tokutaro/status/554066780721672192
twitter.com/tokutaro/status/1009267169916407808
twitter.com/tokutaro/status/1107060880393396224
The author of NEW GAME! also likes PreCure very much.

Attached: 1544519081448.gif (498x360, 1.9M)

Edgy mahou shoujo shows are among my favorite genres, though that's mostly just a subset of (possibly edgy) action CGDCT. Always need more of them, of course.

It's good.
Also, she got the most breedable girl of the season award.

Attached: 1551478992127.jpg (1920x2565, 1.47M)

>her fight was cut out

Attached: 1553027571331.png (1318x1132, 1004K)

>edgy: controversial
>also controversial: homosexuality

Attached: 1531533497800.png (516x565, 293K)

Was this an edgy magical girl show!

Attached: 1556960522341.jpg (2894x4093, 1.12M)

Because "magical girls played straight" is Precure's territory and Precure is airing all year, every year. Compare that to dark/"edgy" mahou shoujo, where there are seasons without a single one of them, or there's only one show in a given season.

Needs more Kurumi being a sandbag.

I hate it when they turn into torture porn, like Asuka and Site.
there are only like five dark mahou shoujo that aired this decade.

Asides from that, Precure also serves as a useful baseline standard to measure other shows by, even though it was perceived to be unconventional at the time of its debut.

Deconstruction of edgy things is always welcome. People forget that deconstruction is more than just edgy take of something.
However I still prefer edgy magical girls than regular.

Who are you quoting?

Attached: [Soldado]_Shamanic_Princess_01v3_[DVD][10F97877]_00:00:33_01.png (704x528, 429K)

Mahou Shoujo: The Line

Madoka people tried and failed miserably to make a more realistic down to earth version of the magical girl then went full SO DEEP SO DARK by ripping off that one toku show.

Every show after that has been desperately trying to mimic the deep dark magical girl thing and failing.
Also the yuri shit is because lesbians and people who wish to push women into lesbianism to turn them into permanent debt slaves and brood mares who have no ability to interact with men or have children once they realize that they aren't gay just retarded and all fucked up and have a big powerblock and control over media.

Also Toei just runs shit when it comes to magical girls adn every attempt at bringing back tho old school orignals have failed miserably because they have no goddamend clue as to how to make them work with normal 2D and are resorting to crappy as fuck 3D crap and are not being true to the anime source material. Yes we all know about the manga but that shit doesn't fly well.

Yeah and DBS was shounen played straight till OPM came in and dickslapped their shit and put out a superior product.

The problem is that they're terrified of TOEI coming down on them and don't have the motherfucking talent or love of the genre and audience to make a good magical girl series.
That's why.

So they go for the easy stand by of SUBVERSION. You know, what hacks do.

This is your brain on /pol/

>Madoka
>more realistic down to earth version of the magical girl
Talking out of ass, as said. Nice /pol/ rant, by the way. Go back.

new chapter when?

Tell me about Asuka, why did her show flop so hard?

curse of gardinella

It looked like shit. And the writing and directing were garbage.

Would it have done better if their eyes weren't so weird?

Who is the most popular Magical Girls

Magical Girls porn comics statistics

1、Nanoha 8303
2、Precure 8103
3、Madoka 6407
4、Sailor Moon 4717
5、Card Captor Sakura 1740

Attached: 1525347439326.jpg (791x698, 131K)

Who is the most profitable Magical Girls

Magical Girls market size ranking

1、Precure
PreCure's annual revenue is 44.8 billion yen (2004-2018, 14 years, revenue 627.8 billion yen, Earn 76 billion yen in 2010)

2、Sailor Moon
Sailor Moon earns 35.7 billion yen a year (1992-2006, 14 years, revenue 500 billion yen)

3、Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Puella Magi Madoka Magica's three-year revenue of 40 billion yen (2011-2013)

4、Doremi
Doremi earned 10.5 billion yen in 2000 and 29.8 billion yen in 2001.

5、Card Captor Sakura
Card Captor Sakura has a revenue of 7.2 billion yen a year (1999.4 to 2000.3)

Explain then, Slime not flopping (gets S2)
Explain SAO not flopping (Gets S2, spinoff animated, filler movie and 4 fucking cours S3)
Explain Sympogear not flopping (Got 4 new seasons. S4 and S5 were even announced simultaneously, that's how sucessful it is)
All 3 have at least one of the problems you mentioned

But that's the best part

SAO and slime looked good and were well animated, plus they were isekai with a gimmick, not as niche as mahou shoujo which has a more limited audience to start with.
Symphogear is a special case, it relies heavily on its cast of seiyuus and concert tickets, s1 didn't do particularly well on its own.
Each of them has many flaws but has at least one thing that helps them stand out and makes them more appealing.

The genre picked with Madoka

vndb.org/v20847

def need more, but this one was shit

Maho shoujo as a genre needs a 'reconstruction' really. Precure is too mediocre to pull off anything like that.

And what makes you think you know anything about the mahou shoujo genre?

What are you even implying with this shit.

Madoka is a reconstruction.

>and failing.
YuYuYu did pretty well imo

It made the audience care for the girls(certainly more than what Madoka did), and then slowly pushed them to hell.

>it relies heavily on its cast of seiyuus and concert tickets
And its huge music sales.

Its basically what Macross does. They sell music, and they do it really, really well. Its the Macross studio behind Symphogear after all.

>It made the audience care for the girls
The only thing I remember from that show was the music.

YuYuYu was the only successful one after Madoka.
And it did it by being more lighthearted, not just suffering non stop.

>by ripping off that one toku show.
Stopped reading right there.
Retarded meme slinging will only get you so far.

>And the writing and directing were garbage.
You forgot to mention 'pacing' for longer but still empty post.

>deconstruction
>reconstruction
Why do people still use these world when they talk about the genre?

Because they're retads acting like they know more about the genre than they really do.

Empty words that make you sound smarter are pretty common.

Precure's target audience is not looking for anything meta in the show at all.

Precure can make the audience forget the troubles of life
Instead of the dark type like Madoka increases the audience's troubles
Precure is to give viewers a relaxed and enjoyable viewing experience

Site is the best

>check 'em trips
What site is this? This isn't panda.

panda's porn comics are simply not complete

I like edge, so yes (Fuck me)

This.