Samurai 8

What did you think about it? I thought it was kinda ok, 4/10.

Attached: 55s.png (932x1300, 355K)

Other urls found in this thread:

mangaplus.shueisha.co.jp/titles/100059
twitter.com/NSFWRedditVideo

It will kill shit like boruto and black clover for sure

Too much exposition and too little art for a first chapter. That's at least how I felt about it.

The good
- 10/10 artstyle, designs, and setting
- soulful
- the black chick is hot
- the dad

The bad
- unlikeable MC
- muh videogame
- power system is too videogame like
- the "chosen one"
- Thanks to the fairy godmother mentor the MC is magically not a cripple anymore by the end of the chapter, in other words, we probably can't expect interesting, rewarding stories in the future of this mango
- muh seppuku

I'm waiting for the official scans because the quality in these makes the art look murky as fuck.

I couldn't even finished because of that messy art, It distracted me while I was reading.

kishimoto has literally forgotten how to draw well

Attached: 07 (1).jpg (684x1100, 93K)

The art is by his former assistant.

See . I'd wait for the Manga+ version
mangaplus.shueisha.co.jp/titles/100059

it honestly looks pretty shit.
It doesn't really do anything new, only interesting thing is the art but it's its almost nonsensical

>MC is introduced as a cripple
>Do away with his incapacity in the first chapter
It's shit just like MHA

>there are some retards saying that they have read the chapter already on Samurai 8's official account on Twitter

deku became a cripple after using his powers tho

Naruto fans aren’t the sharpest tools in the shed

Left: Actual drawings
Right: Scalator abomination

Attached: 1533042670353.png (1814x1300, 804K)

I cant wait to see what retcons Kishi will ruin this series with.

The amount of retcons in Naruto was insane.

looked like shit

kishimoto hasn't written or drawn anything interesting since the mid 2000s

What you want me to tell you? Cliche as fuck, boring, but my real problem is the art, not for me I guess, Is like Oh Great art but without the looking good factor, what the fuck i'm even looking at.

If Studio Pierrot gives the godly Boruto treatment, it easily should. Never underestimate the power of a good anime adaptation.

Damn,Jaimini destroyed

>faggot cripple
>talks shit to people who help him
>he's actually the chosen one and overpowered
>1 shots a seemingly strong antagonist after his power boost
>no longer a cripple and the saviour of the galaxy by the end of the chapter
Yup this is definitely made for nip kids

did you miss the part where Daruma had to knock mr ronin out of his armor mode so Hachi could actually hit him

To be honest that was easy to miss. The action scenes were messy and hard to follow. It was not established that robocat can shoot lasers, if that's what he did, it might have been a sword throw, but one thing for sure it was a ranged attack and it's very unclear why robocat waited so long to use it.

Should i read this?

>- unlikeable MC
I would honestly wait, I still did like the part where he prayed for his dad to come home safely
>- muh videogame
>- power system is too videogame like
>- the "chosen one"
it´s a shounen..I mean sure you are right, but it´s common.
>- Thanks to the fairy godmother mentor the MC is magically not a cripple anymore by the end of the chapter, in other words, we probably can't expect interesting, rewarding stories in the future of this mango
>- muh seppuku
that was actually good. I like the determination thing. One of the reasons why I adore breaker so much.

I really don't like those planet like particle effects. Such an unnecessary detail like why the heck is there mini Saturns floating around him?

No, it's shit

wait at least a few Chapters and we'll get back to you

you really can't judge a manga by it's first Chapter, you have to let it get to chapter 10 and then form an opinion since the artist had months if not years of work and effort poured into Chapter 1, but if he can keep up the quality and pace for the following Chapters is a different question.
Much like the Pilot for a TV show.

Attached: 6.jpg (720x599, 195K)

and got what? seven more ?

Is that a fucking Comics filter ?

What a horrible way of explaining the world in the beginning.

It was alright except for the art. The setting can really go anywhere, too early to judge if the plot is good or not. But the art is really a problem. The artist needs to learn to separate his backgrounds from his characters, essentially just use more tones, vary the line thickness a bit more and utilize empty space better. It's not obvious but using empty space is really important, and it's one of the things that separates the good artists from the best.

Wait until mangaplus releases. Scanlation fucks the artstyle completly up.

Attached: fanart #9.jpg (2220x1800, 378K)

While the originals appear to be much better based on , the problem is still that there’s too much stuff on the panels and foreground and background blends together, making characters stand less out and everything gets lost in too many details.

Compare this to the scanlation one. I just think we should wait until we judge.

Also why are western fans so fucking stupid? Literally writing under the official tweets, how they read stolen redrawn versions.

Attached: A3E88AF0-B0B0-4FDF-B6FF-C4D6CA079EA6.jpg (1125x1781, 529K)

I thought he just returned the laser he was shot with.

Attached: 44[1].png (930x1300, 431K)

Attached: Cute.jpg (1781x2048, 294K)

why is there so little hype for this series among youtubers and tumblr?

did people wanted more Naruto?

Attached: 1426700447338.png (524x541, 235K)

There are lots of YouTube videos about it though

>Tumblr
Unironically yes. They don't care for Kishimoto's works, they're literally just a bunch of mentally ill retards who call him a homophobic misogynist on a daily basis but continue to keep up with Boruto
>YouTube
Most e-celebs likely wont know that it exists until it gets an anime. I know forneverworld (lol) and YonkouProd know about it, but they haven't done any videos on the first chapter yet. Other than that, its mostly small reaction channels making vids for it right now.

There's also quite a lot of postive reactions and fanart for it on Twitter from the western audience despite only having one chapter. Leddit has similar criticisms of the chapter that Yea Forums did, but the sub made for it is quickly gaining viewers. Its at 1,800, and for reference, JJK (one of the hyped up new WSJ series) is only at 1.2k with 50 something chapters out, and Chainsaw Man which has had great appeal in the west is also at 1.8k, but with a higher amount of chapters than S8.

What really matters is how the Japanese react on the official release day.

of course they did, that's why these threads are full of contrarians
that and also the fact that YouTube is a home for anime onlies

>Leddit has similar criticisms of the chapter that Yea Forums did
Any criticism were downvoted and drowned out by praise

there's only like 5 videos from "big" reviewers, the rest are from literallywhos and brazilians.

Guess I didn't view the thread long enough. That means its more liked than I thought if those who disliked it are already being silenced.

So when does the official chapter drop?

tomorrow 4:00pm EST

5/10 if the art is better in the official scans, the MC is kind of an asshole but im in for the world building and space gods

Attached: 7cc3bbc5622381eba48cf29fcf5bf9ef.jpg (538x692, 121K)

Is this from the one shot? Is it canon to the first chapter or a completely separate thing?

Just a small preview. There are no story elements or whatever. Just 4pages nothing special

is the second Hokage kill or will he come back later?

Attached: Tobirama Samurai.jpg (441x535, 125K)

Looks cute

its canon
it has the MC and Hayataro wish on a shooting star. MC wishes for a bunch of shit like not eating liquid meals, not needing a life support device, being able to walk without a cane, more video games, etc before settling on just wishing to become a Samurai
the shooting star he wished on might become important later

Thanks

He will come back for sure, his design and style is fucking good and he had a lot of development just to be a minor villain

He reverted to the ball-key state, so he's probably dead. Although we didn't see Daruma or Hachi take his key.

He was instakilled by cripple and robocat, RIP Tobirama.

Honestly if we ever get an anime they should adapt both this and the arts they posted on the official twitter showing how the Daruma arrived there, the chapter alone felt rushed and thpse things would provide a good set up

How is the MC "kind of an asshole"? He's a gd bubble boy with a phobic fear of needles. If anything once you separate him from the reactionary behaviors that are very clearly attributable to his living situation he becomes almost too perfect.

could a 45 minute first ep do it? the preview and countdown comics should only take like 5-10, but 72 pages might need 2 episodes.

It's just dumb speedreaders. He's bratty but not an asshole. He yells at his father but when it counts he risks his life for him.

The way he treated his father was just too tsun and the whole "oh i actually love you dad" was not enough for me, his father legit though he despised him after all he did for him

No opening or ending im the first episode should be enough to fit them imo

His dad didn't think he hated him; he was using the kid's outbursts as an excuse to try and trick him into not killing himself for him because he's his gd child and he doesn't want him to die.