Why are there so few full adaptations?
Why are there so few full adaptations?
Jeremiah Long
Jacob Gray
Expensive
Gabriel Kelly
Made just to push the source material.
Joshua Rogers
Is the industry run by Jews?
Nolan Morales
jews fear the samurai
John Parker
Yes.
Christian Garcia
worse, capitalists
Cooper Russell
Why are you implying there's a difference?
Henry Watson
I wish this got the GOT treatment but I know it wouldn’t work out because of the lack of degeneracy.
Landon Torres
>GOT treatment
>Good
Isaiah Ortiz
wasn't there supposed to be a new LoGH show?
Jaxon Morgan
already happened.
Brandon Sanchez
When's the movie coming out?
Bentley Thomas
oops. Sorry, been out of touch with anime for a couple of years.
is it good?
John Torres
>is it good?
no
Jack Powell
It's fine
Jason Morales
William Anderson
>here's your Rosen Ritter bro
Jordan Gomez
loli fred tho
Lincoln Perez
How do you homogenize character designs this badly?
Jayden Baker
Matthew White
You mean start out strong and slowly devolve into fanfiction which completely loses the spirit of the original?
Its LoGH for a new audience in a new age.
People wouldn't care as much if it was a LoGH inspired Space Opera in space, but when you remake something so iconic and monumental, you really have to ask
>Why?
Ship designs are fucking abysmal and fleets look awful
Character redesigns just do not hold a candle to the ones from the OVA
OP is catchy
Brody Sanchez
WHO ARE THOSE PEOPLE
Christopher Reed
Jaxon Gomez
THAT'S NOT YANG!!!!!
Ian Perez
Gabriel Green
Unless something's extremely popular it's probably not profitable to adapt an entire manga. Especially if it's monthly and you have to wait so long for enough content to animate. Long running adaptations typically have tons of filler or are like One Piece where they adapt half a chapter per episode and are just a complete waste of time to watch unless you're a 10 year old Japanese kid that has nothing better to do before school. I imagine this is especially bad these days. And then once something's finished there's really no reason to adapt it at that point. I'm really surprised that Dorohedoro is getting an anime for instance.
Aiden Roberts
new phezzan
Jayden Baker
Henry Diaz
new phezzani whore
Jaxson Powell
>>here's your Rosen Ritter bro
what a mess. way too turn a unique design into just run of the mill spec-ops guys
Landon Hernandez
>Those bypasses that lead into the river
So did ol' Rube just decide to make a channel there and buldozed everything in the way or what
Henry Russell
cause most manga don't have an ending.
Jose Garcia
Easton Sullivan
lmao who approved of this
Camden Flores
Too true. The single biggest annoyance that anime and manga have is an extremely limited amount of properly finished titles.
Cooper James
How did LotGH even get animated in the first place? It's 110 episodes + 2 movies + 24 Gaiden episodes. Where did all that money come from?
Christian Brown
dumb aristocrats
Isaac Jenkins
why not, just adapt manga that's already complete?
Kevin Russell
>Back on the rocks, Back on the rocks, Kaiser
>You gotta keep your State together
>Back on the rocks, Back on the rocks, Kaiser
>You gotta go and Rule forever
Isaac Scott
it hurts.
Logan Perez
Why don't they just write out the entire story before doing a manga or early on? Adapting to perception always makes a story worse.
Christian Miller
They could just make half the cast black women and show Kircheis fucking Reinhard up the butt. Problem solved.
Blake Williams
what the fuck am I looking at
Lucas Hernandez
copypasta fleet.
Ryan Jenkins
I know that, but what are those ship designs supposed to be? it doesn't have the same aesthetic of any of the fleets from the original
Liam Walker
>Sanctuary
Give me it
I want it
Nathan Wright
pretty certain they're imperial. dunno who's fleet though. the space fights in the new series were a fucking mess. at least i could tell what was going on in the old one.
Nathaniel Sanders
First movie served as the pilot to test the waters
I don't know who exactly who approved it, but it was distributed through VCR tapes send by mail, as a subscription service, I think.
I guess Gaidens just show how popular LoGH was
Thomas Flores
They are imperial and by the looks of it all completely the same.
Old one had Destroyers, Cruisers, Battleships and variations on most
Nolan Hill
Because that is not how any kind of serialized entertainment works. You really don't know how long your manga will last till it gets axed, or in the small chance it takes off big you don't know how long the wave of popularity will last. Serialized media does not go well with good endings since the vast majority of the time it ends when publishers/producers think the money well has dried up, which usually is a result of the show/manga going to shit.
Jackson Perry
Please don't say such rude things about my wife (mistress).
Adam Roberts
3 movies, although nobody watched the third one except for me.
And 52 Gaiden episodes.
Gabriel Clark
>Because that is not how any kind of serialized entertainment works.
With books like this, you have a lot more freedom to plan things out though and make an effectively connected story instead of only thinking a few events ahead with some vague idea for an ending.
Tyler Howard
I wish it was honestly
James Lopez
Manga works far more like TV, usually a chapter is written and released every week (or month) in a magazine. Therefore, while planning does take place and a good mangaka usually has an idea on where to take his series, his actual writing time is very limited once the series gets past his first few chapters. On top of that any plan the mangaka has probably is based on how long they think their series will last, but really they can't predict that. The length of the series is determined by economic reasons in most cases, which is just the reality of how business is done in entertainment. So any plans they have may be invalidated because now the length of their story is drastically different than what the originally envisioned. Also, this makes writing out a ending beyond some vague ideas a bad idea since the story is gonna evolve and deviate from the original plan. So when this ending is inevitably used its just gonna cause backlash. An example of this is with the western TV show How I Met Your Mother, where the ending was filmed during its 1st season in 2005/2006 and then used in the final season in 2014. It really did not fit at all with the characters and plot as they were in 2014 and felt a lot more like what would have happened if the show got cancelled in season 2 or 3. This was done simply because there were child actors that played an important role in season 1 as the main character's kids and they had a significant part in the ending, and their parts were filmed in 2006 since when the show inevitably ended they would be too old. In manga this issue with child actors would not happen of course, but it's exactly why an ending can't be hard planned years before a series ends.
Brandon Perry
So the problem comes down to the medium itself then? Why does something like a book have lots of content in a few bursts compared to a show with bits of content over a long period of time? Is it all just for a bigger profit?
Angel Miller
Most mangakas write manga hoping they could keep writing them for long periods of time.
Starting a new manga from 0 in a non established world or genre is crazy, and usually mangakas want to keep writing more and more even after the manga is finished to keep the hype and the world that's popular.
Anime adaptations tend to come out when a manga gets very popular. It's usually done to boost the popularity of the manga as well so its usually done before the manga is finished.
At a certain point, the manga becomes to long to ever get a finished series.
It's trouble from all angles.
Aaron Peterson
They don't have an ending because most manga are meant to be long running while most anime these days are hit and run jobs of 13 or 26 episodes. And if they're doing adaptations they want to do them while the manga is running and not after it already has an ending. I'm not defending manga for the way it's serialized but anime companies are at fault too because their way of business is completely different. Look at the new CCS anime. They started so early that half of the 22 episode adaptation had to be filler. And I don't know if there's going to be another anime for it because 22 episodes is already more than enough for most anime studios for a single property. Manga's goal is to be long running. Anime's goal is to shit something out with 13 episodes and move onto something else.
Jose Kelly
Asians are worse jews than jews.
Julian Martinez
Yup, which is why I said what I said here: It's messy business, although the tldr is
why are they so few full adaptations?
cause there are few full mangas.
Elijah Campbell
That's not really true. Unless you're calling something not full because you didn't like the ending or something. But a lot of finished manga aren't popular enough, and weren't popular enough while they were running, to get a full adaptation. Let alone when they've been over for over a year. Anime companies clearly don't give a shit about having endings either because they keep making 13 episode adaptations of long running manga and LNs. It's just whatever makes money and manga with endings don't make money except under extremely narrow circumstances.
Jose Green
the japanese are the jews of the east, prove me wrong