So God madoka is supposed to be omniscient right? How the fuck did she not see the events of rebellion coming?
Think I just found a massive plothole here lads.
So God madoka is supposed to be omniscient right? How the fuck did she not see the events of rebellion coming?
Christian Hall
Eli Sullivan
Here's a note
Lots of people consider the movies not canon
Connor Lee
Being an eternal existence means that you can observe the future as it unfolds, not necessarily that you have foresight. She tells Homura that they "might" reunite, not that they definitively will, which indicates she does not know.
Ian Cooper
no you didn't
Mason Perez
>So God madoka is supposed to be omniscient right?
No.
She needs to actually look at the future to see it, kind of like how you actually need to look through a telescope to see the stars. She doesn't know absolutely everything all at the same time.
Magia Record creates a metaphor for how it works. Her looking into time is like her playing a record and listening to it, rewinding it and skipping forward. Each universe is like its own record.
Nathaniel Nelson
This
>citing gachashit
Luis Diaz
gachashit is just re-explaining what's already true.
Connor Young
There's no need to re-explain anything. Gacha is not canon and so is not its super-specific "re-explanation".
Ian Mitchell
That's not how omniscience works though. You don't see everything ALL the time. Omniscience is the capacity to see everything, but you still have to look.
Zachary Ward
>You don't see everything ALL the time.
No, that's exactly what omniscience is. Omniscience is knowing absolutely everything at the same time. The past, present, future, everything at the same time.
Andrew Brown
Magireco just presents a metaphor. The "record" part isn't a literal interpretation.
I grant you that Magireco is canon, but magireco isn't what makes that interpretation canon. We can gather as much just from context clues from the anime/rebellion.
Dominic Jackson
>be all knowing god
>distracted by nude homu
Really it could have happened to any of us
Jacob Hughes
>I grant you that Magireco is canon
I meant not canon. Fuck.
Xavier Allen
>How the fuck did she not see the events of rebellion coming?
She did and she let it happen on purpose.
Adrian Green
No, it's having the ABILITY to see everything at the same time, past, present and future. It does not mean it's active all the time.
Caleb Morgan
I have nothing against Madoka but I gotta end the perfect day in the perfect way and that means shitposting.
Also I am ban evading using free council wifi so go on ban this council. Go on hit me! Inconvenience this council!
I am a legendary shitposter.
I am shitposter supreme.
I am shitposting God!!!!
ACK ACK
Post some crack!
ACK ACK
Let's Attack!
ACK ACK
We harass!!!
ACK!!!!!!!
Dylan Turner
Of course Homura was bound to use any chance she got to ram herself through Madoka's plot hole
Justin Morris
The same way Dr Manhattan was tricked by Veidt in Watchman and went to the moon to be an emo despite knowing the future
Just knowing doesn't mean you can change things, you experience time non linearly
Ayden Cruz
>So God madoka is supposed to be omniscient right?
Where did you get that from?
Daniel Johnson
Something something Madoka not being REALLY omniscient because of bullshit reasons
Hunter Gray
>Retards
Easton Brooks
It was never said she was omniscient
Leo Thomas
I think the problem is people misinterpret what was said because it sounds somewhat like capital G God, and also because she's described as a god, so they think she's just like him.
Nolan Fisher
It’s fanservice, don’t think too hard about it
Dominic Torres
>they think she's just like him.
She is, they're both fictional characters.
Jaxson Hill
Nice, that'll bait some dumb Christians.