Tanya isn't a man, because she has adapted to her new female body

Attached: 1484727578946.jpg (400x400, 45K)

She's an ascended being, stop thinking in dualities.

I’m happy to see that Isekai Quartet is getting people to make threads about Tanya again.

This. Existence is body, if the body is female the memories don't matter.

Don't care Tanya is cute and that's all that matters to my dick

Attached: 1548994222288.jpg (600x750, 52K)

If you're not a huge world-war history fan I really don't see the appeal at all about this series

She values order and reason, the only times you'll piss her off is if your some horribly incompetent buffoon that can't even follow orders.

pretty sure a majority of the fanbase isn't a
>huge world-war history fan

>JINGO JUNGLE is a banger because otaku DJs in Japan keep making great remixes

You mind sharing?

Your dicks sounds pretty shallow

There's a significant crossover between /gsg/ and Yea Forums. Probably not a majority, but still significant.

It's literally materialism vs dualism. The former makes her a loli, the latter makes her a man.

i'll start binging the actual LNs if you tell me there ends up being actual romance between Rerugen and Tanya

Attached: Marriage_af0ffb_6241751.jpg (900x1273, 268K)

aoi singing los los los in uniform in front of her loyal followers is as good as it gets for me

Attached: 1488323199819.png (634x857, 324K)

>adapted
what? she is a female because she has a female body, it's irrelevant if she was a man or not she is a biological female.
>Tanya isn't a loli/child
What retard is saying this? of course she is a loli.
~four volumes in and there's no romance in view i fear.

Attached: 10946581_522898311208001_1908261997_n.jpg (480x480, 42K)

Whoever made that image clearly didn't read any of the novels.

Tanya is (you)

So is she.

>primative
>all together
>Facist
probably didn't read many books at all for that matter

>start the series with her as a loli
>she never physically goes through puberty because being a loli is her biggest draw

Having a corporate shark go through puberty again while commanding an army would be a cool premise, it's a pity it's never going to happen

Tanya is a being that has no other purpose than being molested.

I wish

ESL-kun was trying his best, user!

Who cares? I'd fuck it either way.

She never goes through puberty because she's too young. 11 or 12 by Dacia, and only a year or so has passed by the time the commies invade. Also keep in mind she's malnourished thanks to first being a poor orphan and then living off shitty army rations. Not to mention that she's doing combat drugs, that can't be good for a developing kid.
I see were you're coming from, but it's perfectly reasonable that she's not going through puberty yet. Tanyas body might be fucked up enough that she will be smol forever.

Attached: tiny and cute.webm (424x562, 369K)

Tanya is a cute little duck

Attached: 68177432_p0.png (2031x2952, 1.39M)

>Her mind, memories, and mentality has lived for a while and is mature since she had her whole past life to grow up that she never forgot.
>born as a woman in this life and accepts it 100% acts like it, and is 100 percent that.

It's not that hard to get.

>implying
Tanya is a very well educated individual with refined taste

Too much magic and magic drugs during combat. She stays loli sized forever

Who dat in the left?

a cute loli alchemist

Me desu.

Does it matter?
Guy seems like an asexual workaholic.

Can i kiss you?

No, I only kiss cute girls.

Well yes, especially for people that want to fuck her/him.

They have doujins for that.
I don't know if Tanya ever have any romantic interest or any sexual need in the LN though.
Nearest thing is that not Beria guy from not Soviet Russia.

Attached: victory.jpg (460x460, 48K)

GOOD LUCK LITTLE DUCK

i cant wait until she hits puberty and gets railed!

Both.

DOOR STUCK LITTLE FUCK

>Your dicks sounds pretty shallow
Dicks have one mode - fuck something mode.

Attached: 1534149969813.png (374x345, 202K)

GOOD LUCK LITTLE DUCK!

A woman with memories of having been a man and a loli on the cusp of becoming a young woman. But most importantly absolutely perfect

Attached: 61807376_p0_master1200.jpg (849x1200, 851K)

Does she ever grow up or did the magic permanently stunt her body

Tanya is a woman because of her body, but because Being X did not nerf the mind she is still on a adult mental level

this

She is a female child who has the insight and memories of a male adult who lived out his life until he was in his 30s.

A combination of magic usage, malnutrition, poor sleeping schedule and psychological and physical stress has fucked up her growing process.

gender is based exclusively on your biology

she has too much cognisance and experience to be a child

Cunny

I want to be Tanya.

Attached: youjo senki, tanya.jpg (495x396, 46K)

GOOD
LUCK
LITTLE
DUCK

Attached: A9221DB6-49EE-49D7-BC92-1754FF184D38.jpg (600x345, 41K)

I Want to be dominated by tanya

IDK man. So do I but from what I see she looks like the type who would be into torture/guro.

I'd like to be a cute blond blue eyed girl as long as I didn't have to live in Europe in the early 20th century.
I do wish I had her work ethic and professionalism; my life would be so much better if I weren't such a lazy bastard.

Nah, man; BDSM is very strict with its rules and you know how Tanya is about following rules. Unless she really doesn't like you; then she'd try to fuck you over while still adhering to the rules somehow.

I can't find Tanya sexually attractive knowing she's just a man on the inside.

Attached: 1547160481423.gif (420x725, 199K)

Tanya is a girl because that's a 100% female body that could be impregnated after it reached puberty, and Tanya is also a loli because it's a fucking child.
Where the fuck did you hear such retarded ignorant opinions?

Attached: 1525740046724.jpg (800x1800, 821K)

Here's Lt. Tanya in her first propaganda photoshoot
Say something nice.

Attached: Tanya.jpg (1280x1808, 609K)

Technically she's a girl with knowledge/personality of a past life

Did Tanya ever get captured as a pow?

I fucking love the shows artstyle but the few people I've spoken to about it give it endless shit compared to the LN artstyle
Am I alone in loving the anime's style over the rest?

Attached: Tanya.png (640x360, 205K)

Only faggots are that self-conscious.

she isn't a man on the inside, her body is entirely female

Nah, man, I love the anime's style too. I like how unique it is, and I believe it fits the aesthetic; Tanya is never described as being beautiful in the LN, people always have this lingering feeling that there's something wrong with her on her appearance alone. If they had gone full moe with her that effect would be diminished if not outright gone. The manga overdoes the cuteness in my opinion; the LN has some of the best instances of Tanya looking both attractive as well as extremely creepy, though, so art wise the LN wins. Still like the anime's art a lot, though.

I like the manga art more, the lieutenant looks cuter

>people always have this lingering feeling that there's something wrong with her on her appearance
>so lets make her look like she's constantly doing duckface!
no
if they wanted her to look weird or disturbing, they failed. She just looks like a retard.

I think the LN style is better but I like the anime's style.

Could you give me a better example of how to make a character look off while still adhering to the cuteness that is to be expected of a little girl in anime? Not trying to say it is impossible, I just wish to know how you feel they could have gone around it.

Just don't fucking make her look off. It doesn't matter how hard you try to not let people who like cute things enjoy your show, they will find a way.

It's not about making the show unejoyable to those who like cuteness, it's about the tone. The story conveys how awful war is and the only levity we get is Tanya getting screwed over in ways that seem out of a nightmare. On top of that, a fundamental part of her character is the contrast between her aspect and how she thinks and acts without going the extreme route of having a cute little girl saying "oh, I'm dying to play with my new toys" with sadistic glee. You probably have seen that type before. She is to look unpleasant to reflect the state the war has left her in and how she will continue to deteriorate morally and mentally as the conflict rages on.

And yet she's still a little girl who doesn't look like a duck in the source material.

I think that most of the girls in the anime are pretty cute actually, including Tanya

Attached: wife.png (1920x1080, 1.28M)

Yes, she is. She definitely looks creepy (as long as you are referring to the LN), in there and I applaud that decision and execution. However, I also believe that the way her eeriness is portrayed in that works due to the fact that the artist is working on still images; that sort of aura only works in pictures that aren't animated. For an animated show they needed to get around it some other way, and I believe that they succeeded in making her look ugly or outright sort of creepy that way.

I mean, her "creepiness" there looks a lot better than just giving her a huge mouth. I'm sure there was a way to convey it better than what they did, even though using something close to the original art in the anime obviously wasn't possible.

WAS a man.

Attached: 015.png (1045x1482, 563K)

Could it have been done better? Possibly, as there's always room for improvement. Still, I believe that the designs they turned in for the anime work pretty well and on different fronts. Tanya may look eerie and not all in there, which works well when they try to show her either as actively deranged or quiet but sinister, but she also lends herself to the kind of comedy the show indulges in. In anime specially, I believe that comedy needs to happen to weird looking characters; style transitions for jokes are common for a reason. I believe that had Tanya looked more conventionally attractive the kind of comedy this show prefers wouldn't work as well; having her being cute leads one to believe the comedy will be more moe, which really isn't the case for Youjo Senki. Instead, Tanya's fuck ups are a not based on slapstick or in getting adorable reactions out of her; they're about driving this already unstable person mad through a insurmountable conspiracy she cannot hope to escape without a vigorous fight. Being X fucking with Tanya can be funny and her design works with that, but it can also be scary or oppressive and her design still works with it. In that regard, they did an excellent job.

She has XX chromosomes, female genitalia and was born and raised as female.
Saying she's a man sounds an awful lot like advocating for trannies.

Attached: mpv-shot0053.jpg (1920x1080, 326K)

Sure if those trannies suddenly say they're actually reborn from another world

Why would you believe a tranny's delusions, user?

I felt the manga had the best approach. Really nice, attractive character designs to suit a highly comedic plot.

I personally think the manga sacrificed the tone and Tanya's character for the aesthetic; I don't like at all how they made Tanya so cute. I like cuteness, and I do think she looks adorable, but it doesn't fit her personality or how people ought to react to her. The manga does too much of its own thing for me to take it seriously.

What sexual orientation is Tanya?
Does s/he like girls since she used to be a horny old man (in the LN), or is s/he attracted to males now?

Also would s/he be considered transgender since it's shown that she finds dressing up in a dress/ doing feminine stuff to be extremely uncomfortable and humiliating?

Attached: pretty-pretty-war-criminal.jpg (1280x720, 167K)

>What sexual orientation is Tanya?
They basically glide over all of that by keeping her prepubescent, so she doesn't display sexual attraction to anyone.

>Also would s/he be considered transgender
His / her own opinion on the matter is still undecided.

I don't recall him ever being horny or old, was he like that?

Any sexual desire for women has probably been lost because of hormones and all but she's too young still to really be lusting for penis.

I thought the tone and character in the manga were appropriate for the humour, which is mainly based on Tanya wanting to live a comfortable life in the back lines, but then failing due to her competence and the constant misinterpretation of her demeanor as keenness for battle.

GOOD LUCK LITTLE DUCK

there is a brief paragraph in the light novel where he considers what her proper orientation should be but it is inconclusive and she decides to not think about and hasn't so far in the light novel again

I believe that Being X called him out on being "lascivious" for thinking about sex. He tried to excuse himself with "well, I am a man" and Being X took this as him implying that if he were a woman he wouldn't be so horny. Of course, salary man makes the very good point that women can also be horny, but Being X doesn't listen; that's the reason why he came back as a girl.

I thought the leather strap was her finger for a second

While Youjo Senki definetly has some comedic elements, I consider it to be first and foremost a war story and for the most part it carries that bleak tone constantly. Most of the levity comes from people overestimating Tanya's cruelness (and even this is played for drama sometimes) or her competency and patriotism. Perhaps the manga is consistently funnier, as I have not read it beyond seeing some of the cutest scenes posted here, but I think that focusing the designs on the more comedic aspects of the story is missing the point. Just my opinion.

GLuck LilDuck

Poor Tanya, condemned to be gay no matter who she fucks.

GOOD LUCK LITTLE DUCK

>Also would s/he be considered
No, shut the fuck up about that already holy shit and learn the differences between genderbending (an entirely fictional thing that's completely impossible in reality due to being a complete change) and whatever you think it's related to.

Shrödingers Loli(Man)

Attached: [HorribleSubs] Juuni Taisen - 11 [1080p].mkv_snapshot_17.21_[2017.12.12_21.50.14].jpg (1920x1080, 216K)

How does Tanya really feel about Visha exactly?

Attached: 61846548_p0_master1200.jpg (656x922, 423K)

I just wish the anime designs were more inline with the LN's

Attached: Tanya the Evil LN Vol.2 inside jacket.jpg (990x1800, 499K)

Indeed...

Attached: 1544134120272.jpg (1800x1357, 709K)

I really like how attractive and masculine Tanya used to look in her past life, as portrayed by the manga.

Attached: 1536672822932.jpg (870x1249, 183K)

I don't think any other artist has ever come close to displaying the absolute exhaustion Tanya suffers through daily and how it has eaten away at her sanity through months and months of battle.

Attached: 1536677617727.png (1346x2000, 2.15M)

Tanya is a spiritual homo.

I can't help but picture Tanya (if not for her probably remaining a womanlet for the rest of her life) growing into Balalaika from Black Lagoon.

Attached: tgpSSSx.jpg (800x1129, 163K)

War stories can be comedic and bleak: Generation Kill, Slaughterhouse Five, Catch-22. The YS Manga specifically feels like Catch-22 with an isekai loli (male). Using cute designs and goofy faces creates a strong ironic contrast with firebombings and brutal, senseless war imo.

Plus, I love the little cartoon animal dudes.

Yeah, although I have to admit I am fond of any art Kawacy does for Tanya.

GOOD LUCK LITTLE DUCK

Good luck little duck
Now where is this good coffee at?

It takes place in a half-way between WW1 and WW2, but the important thing is that in this alternate war, Germany is autocratic and not fascist.

QUACK

Would you a Tanya?

Attached: psychololi.png (1098x1646, 2.13M)

Yes, I would pet her.

tanya is a loli but it's not wrong to fugg her because she is mentally developed

if you bein tanya position would you like girls and go yuri or will go for dicks?
not counting you masturbating in the mirror

Yes.

Yuri.

Would it be at all gay for Tanya to fuck a woman who was reborn as a man?

In a heartbeat. Then again, one could easily end up killed by her the moment one's actions don't match up to her expectations. Sure seems like a scary situation.

Attached: 1487001543190.jpg (1080x1550, 281K)

Actually, I'm pretty sure on the inside Tanya is warm and fertile, if a bit tight. Being a pragmatist, it would also probably be relatively easy to get her to embrace living as your woman (albeit a self-serving, gold-digging one).

Does Tanya pee sitting down?

Attached: 1512357167057.jpg (569x604, 270K)

Any day. I don't care about the old man mind, murderous tendencies, risk of being pecked or anything else.

Tanya would need a funnel to do it any other way

>Tanya isn't a man, because she has adapted to her new female body
No you idiot. There is no such thing as "adapted". Tanya is a girl because she is a girl. If her DNA and her brain is that of a girl, then she is a girl no matter what sex she was in her previous life. Remembering your past life does not mean you are that person anymore, it is just memories... delusions if you will.

The soul is not male or female as suggested in the LN. A soul is just a clump of consciousness, a fetus of energy that can be recycled at any time.

someone post the hug

Let's be honest, it's an extremely likely outcome.

I would say it's more of a WWI situation transferring into WW2 aside from the politics which for the Empire are closer to WWI obviously.

QUACK

Good luck, little duck~

Anybody knows how far into the novels the movie covers?

Attached: 1486528276907.jpg (907x1200, 98K)

Body determines gender soul doesn't matter.

I mean, even without "magic Drugs" you have crystal meth, which was invented in 1919 in Japan and widely used by the second world war (crystal meth is just methamphetamine salts that are pure enough to form crystals. All methamphetamine is crystalline in its solid state.)

I mean first of all she does kind of tweak out now and then, and second, you can't reasonably expect someone to stay alert and awake for days on end without some sort of pick-me-up. shit stunts your growth and suppresses appetite.

GOOD LUCK LITTLE DUCK

It would be very painful.

The two conflicts should really be considered a single war with a brief armistice anyway.
Anglo-French Alliance conspiring against the rest of Europe to retain hegemony in the face of an industrialized Germany.

>implying I have a problem fucking a child with the memories of an old man
it's like you think I'm some sort of pleb or something OP

All quiet in the western front

Yeah I'd agree with that especially since not one piece of Entente lead ever landed on German soil in WWI.

Attached: 1546585773259.jpg (1024x1608, 362K)

Good luck little duck

GOOD LUCK LITTLE DUCK

Attached: 1484816834696.jpg (960x540, 70K)

Good fuck little duck

>tfw Tanya will never train you to be a maximum oper8tor

Attached: 1539710492873.jpg (989x564, 144K)

Tanya is cute and funny

Neither. She is a duck.

Read the novels.

Tanya is a girl, and a loli. The Salaryman is a dude. The Salaryman controls Tanya's actions, but sees himself as a different entity. However, the more he uses the blessed/cursed stone, the more he loses his personality and becomes the girl entirely.

Also, I disgust myself, because I moved and have no proper net now, so I'm being a filthy phoneposter. Clover's proper nice tho.

And now you're a blogposter.

Being X really is a cunt, if he did that to man with such aspirations. He just played the game as best he saw fit.

>t. tranny

gay

Post more cute Tanya.

Attached: 795316.jpg (1920x1200, 1.79M)

Binged like 14 chapters of the manga yesterday. Maybe at the this point I'm wearing out and starting to speedread, but what is Tanya's deal? She's a genocidal murder machine, but she does it to be sent to the back lines while claiming she's a pacifist. What the fuck? That's not how fucking pacifism works. And you're not going to be sent away from the front by showing how delightful killing enemies is to you.

I recommend learning to read

Anime only but I think her entire point was to distinguish herself to the point where she's put in a comfy officer position where she just shoves pieces around on a map next to a cozy fireplace.

I think that sculpture looks great and I wouldn't mind owning it, but I wouldn't want to be mistaken for a pedo either.

Tanya slowly going mad because she has to take care of newbies in vol 5 was hilarious.

Yes she is very sexy

Loria, pls.

Tanya's only sexual interest is drowning herself in coffee.

GOOD LUCK LITTLE DUCK

She could just pee standing up in the shower.

Where's Mary Sue in this thread?

How can the reich even compete?

Attached: 69112228_p0.png (1600x2400, 3.26M)

Too busy being a triggered frogposter to form coherent sentences.

Trannies are soulless atheist hedonists

she is really bad at understanding other people values

I want to see the genderbent edgelord in quipao and garterbelts.

It was just my first time phoneposting, so I had to wash the bad flavor by being even more cancerous.

But yeah, fucking read the novels, faggots. I'd go as far as to say it's the best series currently in serialization. Also, I really wanna read Yakitori.

Tanya is a professional. She's objective, practical and direct.
She also doesn't respond very emotionally to things, but yet still acts on grudges in ways that can't be noticed or traceable.

Seduction and romance would be wasted efforts, and any coercive methods would be boring and lead to serious repercussions in ways that would be unsatisfactorally distant from the act.

Go for her sidekick.

Attached: visha moomin.jpg (320x350, 21K)

Indeed; that guy really knows how to capture her essence rather well. I think he's fantastic at doing her look menacing when smiling, but other less solemn moments look a bit lacking. Overall, however, he's fantastic.