Try to add comments instead of just rates
3x3 Thread
Other urls found in this thread:
cureclover.livejournal.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtu.be
youtube.com
youtube.com
dailymotion.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
twitter.com
k
3x3 threads are almost as bad as pre-2000 threads; the only difference is that the 3x3 threads have a bigger anime pool.
8/8
There's not much to say overall.
This could have been mine, looks like our taste is more or less the same, OP.
>Western media
>And a lot of pretentious western media to top
I bet your coworkers stopped taking lunch with you because you always start rambling about politics and art
Jokes on you, I don't work. Hahaha.
The only reason people haven't put Hyouge Mono on their 3x3s yet is that they haven't watched it yet.
Do you really think aku no hana is good? I'm actually curious why
Hello friends
I like 7 out of the 8 anime I've seen on your 3x3
I like 5 out of the 7 anime I've seen on your 3x3
I like 4 out of the 6 manga I've read on your 3x3
I like 5 out of the 6 anime movies I've seen on your 3x3
I like 2 out of the 6 anime I've seen on your 3x3
It's not on mine because at the rate it's being translated I'll have to wait until 2029 before it's finished
>Try to add comments
Certainly not. Writing something meaningful for every single thing I rate is far too much effort. And writing something meaningless is what trolls do.
Also, why make a new 3x3 thread mere hours after the last one? You only get my 2x2 - you deserve no more.
2/3
Too many: ~70%
0/2
2/4
Nice trick getting around that stupid "comment" thing.
And manga.
Squealer did nothing wrong
I'm retiring
Good, fuck off.
>Retiring
>not Retarded
Mobilefag
Your western comics and games is the equivalent of pic related. Boring basic bitch taste.
I like what I like. Bitch.
Dekalog is a tv show, not a movie.
Not according to the director, so I classify it under movies.
2/4
2/3
It first aired on Polish tv. It's a fucking show. Fuck what the director said.
5/5.
5/5.
Breddy broad and good.
How do I make a 3x3? Is there a template?
>Is there a template?
Yes. The template is called "Guides" in GIMP. You can even decide what sizes you want. Isn't that great?
Not a foot fag, but I can tell right are Bakemonogatari and Aria. What're on the left?
Looks like Your Lie In April and Utakoi, maybe?
MSpaint
0/3
anime 3/3
anime movies 4/6
2/3
4/5
2/2
1/1
1/1
4/6
Anime: 3/5
Characters: 6/5
4/6
Do you like regular Kenshin too or just T&B?
left are Gintama and Gurren Lagann
>Gurren Lagann
Christ, nobody could have gotten that.
6/6
3/3
4/5
I'll miss you, patrician fag
1/7
2/6
2/4
2/5
2/2
1/3
Are you bisexual?
>VN
I don't read that gay shit
>manga
3/6
>western comics
Those are for kids
>anime
1/3
>anime movies
2/6
>tv shows
2/3
>games
Games are for manchildren
>movies
3/7
>books
2/7 - if those are your favorite books, you've horrible taste and you should read more than cheap novels.
EXCEPTIONALLY based/9
another thread so soon
like most of the shows but dont like the grid, source your images better, only one i dont like is ssy and potentially whatever top mid is
i like the leiji and little girls shows, not so much sora no woto and monster
movies are mostly fine but i'm not too fond of shinkai and kiki
i've seen hyouge mono and wasn't particularly taken with it, not too keen on this grid though i am happy to see hana no uta despite thinking it could have been a lot better
probably like your grid in full better
f
i wonder if i've seen all these and just don't remember the feet
this grid looks good, even thouhg you have my least fave ikuhara and kyousougiga which i dont really like
source better images, thunderbolt fantasy is not anime, not fond of most of your shows
need to watch more robots so i can give a judgement on this really
dont really like anything here outside of jinrui and 3-gatsu was fine
i think your taste is too rigid and you should look for the value in other things, also get a better image for natsume
2/4
What's wrong with my Natsume image?
just a lot of jpeg artifacts or whatever
Thanks, bro.
>STILL has Little Prince in his book mosaic
Are you forever going to be a mongoloid?
try to become an actual individual
Based littleprinceposter
TV Anime 8.5/9 ~Monster
Anime Films 6/8 -Haruhi, 5cmps ~Kiki, Belladonna
I like this more than your 3x3. 4/4
3/4 -HxH
See you next thread.
8/8
7/10 -Death Note, Kaiji, Gintama
Is Moetan really one of your favorite anime?
Does it spark joy when you see it on your grid?
Is that jin-roh? Can't tell.
3/5
5/7
gay
2/2
5/7
I liked Grancrest but I don't know about that
6/9
4.5/8
2.5/7
4/7
4.5/6 I stopped watching yka what makes it stand out to you?
>Figure 17
Mah nigga
>KEY shit
>Is Moetan really one of your favorite anime?
keiichirou kawaguchi has a pretty good understanding of how to make use of a lot of moe tropes and combined with the stellar character designs of POP i found moetan really enjoyable, i think having braine damage is a prerequisite for enjoying moetan but there is a lot of value wrapped up in that show imo
i like stories about sexual liberation and im a sucker for ikuhara's presentation, i also love brightly coloured anime so it hit every note for me really
of course
I probably should have went with LB instead but nah
It felt like a re-hashing of themes that were previously done better by him and it was very on the nose I think that's put me off
*I think that's what put me off
>real taste is watching things for/about little girls
When will this reddit meme die?
He's a mentally ill yurifag. No point in trying to reason with those inferior beings.
He means his real taste. Nice reading comprehension, burger.
>He means his real taste
No, he spaced out the word like a YouTube vaporwave video and compared it to some meme grid. Nice retardation, spic.
>reddit meme
Who you trying to fool here faggot?
>yuri
Keep talking out of your ass. Oh I see you saw the picture I posted and based all your interpretation off of that without even having seen the show, you're that stupid.
If you don't spoonfeed these brainlets, they get easily confused.
Left: 4/9
Right: 5/9
0/4
1/4
3/5
>he spaced out the word like a YouTube vaporwave video
I have no idea what you're talking about. Maybe you should go back there.
Not fooling anyone.
>t. memethinking burger whose mind is so poisoned by the culture of other sites that it's all he sees
>memethinking
>from someone whose grid is literally a meme
>poisoned by the culture of other sites
>from someone who has posted the reddit logo in this very thread
Just stop humiliating yourself, idiot.
I'm not the guy who posted the grid. Are you perchance the HxH poster by the way? Only asking because you haven't been avatarfagging.
>posted the reddit logo
>yea no one can post the reddit logo on Yea Forums
Ask me how I know you're a retarded newfag
Then you're defending that retard, making you just as retarded. If you need avatars or screen names or whatever go back to YouTube.
>calls me a retard
>can't detect basic sarcasm
>posts shitty image with reddit logo and YouTube memes
>claims others are obsessed for bringing up other sites/knowing about them
>gets called out
>hurr, here is my off topic /pol9k/ reaction image, you are le newfag
getting desperate for (you)s at this point
You are both fucking retards, stop using greentext like you're on Yea Forums or Yea Forums.
Wow, nice smug anime girl. You sure showed me.
>desperate for (you)s
That would be the faggot who can't post his 3x3 grid without attaching reddit bait memes.
>greentext is particular to one board
Trying real hard.
You were the one who was upset enough to reply in the first place. If the shoe fits I guess.
>Doesn't even know that having the reddit logo in your anti-reddit pics is a common thing
>you are le newfag
>le
Looks like reddit is your d.na
>upset enough to reply
I mean, I found the image annoying, but if you only want people with positive opinions to reply then post them on your discord or whatever.
>still going on about how much he loves posting about reddit
Just go back there.
Memetexting is particular to the newfag boards and newfucks who like le ebin memetext stories, yes. Stop being a fucking retard.
Well, if your purpose was to derail the thread, congrats. Your "real taste" is shit by the way. Most of those shows make poor to no use of the medium, beyond having uguu kawaii girls.
Uh oh, you can't use "le" even sarcisatically now, according to your fellow "oldfag" friend You must be reddit too.
Let me explain it in terms that might be easier for you to understand. That image gets posted often and it’s usually just met with laughs or people pointing out the Fate: Historical/Toradora: Shoujo jokes. The only reason for someone to reply to that image with a genuine argument is if they feel what's depicted in the image truly applies to them and that they need to defend themselves.
>Discord
Stop projecting. You're the only person mentioning these sites.
>no u are the reddit ignore all the evidence
posted that says otherwise
This is how npcs argue
I don't like most shows on either side of your stupid grid. My point was that you're no better than the people you're putting down. Your "deep cuts" and "real taste" are not much better than the entry level "polished turds" you're mocking. You're just acting hipster because they're less popular.
You really think Escaflowne is measurably better than Eva? What a fucking joke.
>make poor to no use of the medium
I don't even think that his grid is good but you quite clearly can't seen more than half of them. The only ones this might fly for are Kalaido Star and Keyshit. And the only reason Kaleido Star "doesn't make use of the medium" is because of its terribad animation paired with uninspired visual directing.
>NPCs
Thank you for outing yourself. Go back to Yea Forums and take your retarded bait 3x3 with you.
>You really think Escaflowne is measurably better than Eva? What a fucking joke.
Never said anything of the sort, I like Kawamori but still prefer Anno for the most part. You seem to be running out of arguments.
>your stupid grid
Wrong person again. I know it's hard but try to keep up.
Please tell me about how Azumanga Daioh and Figure 17 are better than Tatami Galaxy or Gurren Lagann. They're all good shows, but visually it's no comparison.
>Wrong person again. I know it's hard but try to keep up.
You keep up idiot, what do you think we've been discussing? You're defending it too, so it's your shitty grid now too. Congrats idiot.
Reddit is Yea Forums's boogeyman, it should have been obvious from the start they were Yea Forumsirmin. Everyone knows Yea Forums is Yea Forums's boogeyman.
So you moved the goalpost from
>make no use of the medium
to
>they make less use of the medium than these two shows
Really, next time you want people to call you peabrained subhuman, just ask. No need to for this pitiful display of retardation.
>no u
Apply yourself. You're not "discussing" anything, just attacking your (incorrect) perception of my identity.
>I don't like most shows on either side of your stupid grid
You're talking to someone else. It's hilarious you don't even recognize Rah Xephon if you were going to claim I was being a contrarian hipster against Eva. And Escaflowne is a very popular well known show, after all even a dunderhead like you can recognize it.
Ah poor triggered little npc you going to refute the evidence yet?
>you don't even recognize Rah Xephon
What? Yes, I recognize all of your entry level baby shows.
Yeah no one's used the term "Yea Forumseddit" before. How many more retarded posts are you going to make here
>I-I recognize all of your entry level baby shows
>Mentions Escaflowne as a contrarian hipster option instead of the far more apt Rah Xephon
Nope not buying it, anyways I mostly picked well known shows but your hyperbole in attacking my chart gives you away like a little kid in hard denial after he got caught redddit Name the other shows then
Congratulations, you played yourselves by shitting up the thread.
Came here to ask how people still like Mirai Nikki, I personally don't get how anyone enjoys it outside of "BLOOD BOOBY SPOOKY YANDERE GIRL"
Anyone that isn't a shitposter with Mirai Nikki on their 3x3 is less than a person in my book. A sentient tumour at best.
He probably mentioned Escaflowne because the script is fucking abysmal.
rahxephon seems like the better show to compare to eva is the point
You are correct.
I've seen it many times still amazes me there are people who love 1001 nights and Future Diary at the same time. I don't mean this in a bad way of course. Admittedly havent seen anything else aside from Desu note which I still really like.
1/3 not much to say about it. I loved Kyousougiga's ending with the family themes but honestly the middle was pretty uninteresting to me.
2/3 guruguru was actually too much fun every week
Love hate relationship with Ergo Proxy. Also gankutsuou cg armor battle was most likely the worst thing I've seen in a great show.
4/5 but not a big fan of some of them.
6/6 good stuff friend perhaps 7/7 but don't recognise the middle right gundam, prob have seen it.
8/8 perfect kino taste. Millenium Actress is such a work of art, I wish we had more of Kon to fanboy over, his editing in the final running sequence of that movie blows my fucking mind.
Only recognise Aria and Monogatari feet but 2/2 depending on which part. I do prefer the manga of aria over the anime though. top 3 manga easily.
posting my manga one, haven't read that much though. It would surely be very different if I had the time to check out all the shit I still want to read.
Rahxephon is just a cheap Eva clone. Eureka 7 was way better.
I seriously hope the guy who calls Escaflowne's script abysmal isn't this clown . Would that be a sham if it was.
Wow, why are you dragging unrelated people into your shitpost fest?
implying that in any universe Kyousougiga would even come close to the Tatami Galaxy.
No, retard, that's not me. I don't have anything against Escaflowne's writing. Fuck off with your baseless accusations, shithead.
I don't disagree, but there's a larger difference in quality between Escaflowne and NGE than RahXephon and NGE even if they are more similar to one another, which is probably what they wanted to highlight.
No that's not me. Not sure why that's relevant.
Add Houseki no Kuni to this 3x3 pls
Still makes no sense, the most likely reason is he only recognized Escaflowne because it's more popular. And I've been re-watching Escaflowne people's criticisms of it don't stand up.
i like all three of them of the bunch i think eva is the best and eureka seven is my fave but rahxephon is fine too
perhaps, there's lots of factors that go into being someones fave though, even though i didn't feel much for escaflowne overall there were a lot of elements i liked particularly that maaya op shes so lovely
Ergo Proxy is a very complex anime thanks to its allegorical story overarching tendency for existential ponderings and questions with the heavy use of subtle symbolism and vivid imagery. If you want, I can link you to a really good and detailed analysis that explains it very well, so you'll be able to understand it during a re-watch.
I actually got most of it, my problems with it are more so that I think Re-l is a shit character and Vincent while well written is painfully uncharismatic and boring. Same with its direction and production, both inconsistent.
I found the overarching story and how I could piece things together near the end, pretty satisfying. But I had to rewatch bits to get the full picture and in the end I didn't found it just didn't really click with me
sure l'll happily read some articles or pieces about it. I'm sure I missed quite a bit. I was planning to rewatch it soon anyway.
re-l may be a shit character but she is sexy
Yeah, one single viewing is not enough to understand it. I had to watch it 3 times to fully get all the picture. I don't think Re-L is a shit character, she behaves very realistically if you try to see things from her perspective. There are a lot of philosophical concepts in this anime that explain why certain characters act the way they do, like Vincent, he's mostly nihilistic, but there is a very good reason for that. He was created to be that way, that's why he might seem boring at firs.
Here is a very good analysis:
cureclover.livejournal.com
thanks dude, I'll give it a read
>umineko
10/10, don't even need to look at the rest
bad post
So hard to keep track of good OPs. Bet I missed a lot because the shows were terrible and I simply erased them from my mind.
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtu.be
youtube.com
youtube.com
dailymotion.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
Not sure how to feel about the most thoroughly constructed TV animation in existence being on this cringe grid.
4/9 +Rara, Kyouso, Escaflowne ~17, Kaleido
1/4 +Michi; my guess is you wanted to put different directors on this but then I still don't understand the Okamoto and Kawamoto picks since those are probably some of their most abysmal works. I am also inclined to believe that Matsugae wo Musubi actually topped Michi.
3.5/9 +Mononoke, FLCL, Guru ~Kuma; I guess Part 4 at least was better than Part 5. Still shit.
3/9 +Shimashita, KLK ~3Gatsu, Kaiji
2.5/9 +NGE, Thunderbolt first season ~Kaiji
I don't rate mixed grids and not only do you have manga on this, you also have Thunderbolt Fantasy, which isn't even animation. You get a cookie for genki Phos, though.
7/9 -Omoide, UtenaTV
2/4 +TTGL, Aria
>The only reason people haven't put Hyouge Mono
Or because it looks like shit. Woudl be my guess.
4/8 +Hyouge, Kizu, Bebop, Quartet or whatever the name was; never seen Jojo and doubt I ever will at this point.
6.5/9 ~LoGH -UtenaTV, Aiji
>my guess is you wanted to put different directors
Yeah
>I still don't understand the Okamoto and Kawamoto picks since those are probably some of their most abysmal works
Difference of opinion. I would've put Book of the Dead, but it felt out of place with the short films. I though Briar Rose was a great spin on a classic narrative. It felt like a commentary on the mysterious roots of folk tales and fairy stories. Also, I think Okamotois too sentimental and didactic in general, but Niji ni Mukatte was overall pretty pleasant for me. I like the soft music and the story is sweet without being as preachy and incoherent as Praise be to Small Ills or Mochi Mochi no Ki for instance. Also, he does a lot of cutouts, and I wanted to use 3d models.
>I am also inclined to believe that Matsugae wo Musubi actually topped Michi.
I still haven't seen it, but from his recent work and the trailer I watched, I'm skeptical of that claim.
Also, just made these so I'm going to post them here too.
>Briar Rose
What made it stand out compared to all the other works that are atmospherically way above it on all fronts? In the other thread you said that you care for visual storytelling, but Dojoji, Kataku, Branches and probably even Oni are more apt in that department. So was it just the different approach to a story you already knew?
>I'm skeptical of that claim
It's on AB. As far as I am concerned it does most things Michi does just as well. I'd probably put them as equals, but only because Indigo Road is better than the other entries. The short certainly has way more detail and multilayered metaphorical meaning shoved into it.
You're gonna get a lot of flack from the C O M P O S I T I O N posters for these.
>You're gonna get a lot of flack from the C O M P O S I T I O N posters for these.
Let them come.
Do you unironically enjoy watching this kind of gay shit?
>What made it stand out compared to all the other works that are atmospherically way above it on all fronts?
I think the ones you mentioned are just as sound on that front, but I liked seeing him step out of that Kabuki/Sumi-e influenced style and do something with a Western feel, while also interacting with the source material in a very novel and critical manner. As far as visuals, the detail in the actual models and sets is probably the best in his catalogue of 3D stop motion.
Fair enough. Pretty unfortunate that Japanese stop motion and cutout animation are kinda abysmal compared to Europe's. Not even Shisha no Sho looks all that great. It's merely aesthetically stunning. Would be even better if he'd gotten rid of that shitty overlay that pops up everytime something supernatural happens. Already annoyed the living hell out of me in Oni.
>Japanese stop motion and cutout animation are kinda abysmal compared to Europe's
Mostly French and Russian, but yes agreed. It's not even on par with the best Hollywood stuff.
>Already annoyed the living hell out of me in Oni.
You're living my life.
Here's my 8x3
>connoisseur
>only pre-90s show is Versailles no Bara
Whoever made this probably has a very active twitter account.
>pre-90s
>"terrible writing"-the era
>connoisseur
The chart might be bait, but so is this post.
>pre-90s
>"terrible writing"-the era
For TV anime? No, 70s was the peak of dramatic writing. Stuff like Ashita no Joe, Gundam 0079, Akage no Anne, or Uchuu Kaizoku Harlocka re still among the best to this day. 80s Tv shows are mostly either bullshit, sequels of 70s shows, or episodic comedies, 90s and onwards is 12 episode wannabe movies with 4 episodes of filler.
>K-ON under normalfaggot
I gotta expand the chart, you are right.
I have a hard time taking you seriously. Filler no Joe is a joke compared to the manga, especially the first season which is the only part of that franchise that actually is from the 70s. 0079 is an abysmal abominiation that made it clear very early just how incompetent Tomino is as a director with his inconsistent storytelling approach that showed how he didn't even understand what sort of character image he wanted to sell to his audience. Akage no Anne is about a million times worse than Heidi, and not even Heidi is particularly good given how much it stretches the source material. I am not even gonna acknowledge Harlock. That part has to be bait.
You barely even like anime anymore, so who cares? Do you think the crap on that image is substantially better? Black Lagoon or Nodame Cantabile are more interesting to you than Harlock or Anne? Be honest.
Kill yourself, boomer.
I think that image is abysmal and doens't even make any sense. I hate Tatami Galaxy but that sure as hell doesn't belong in the shitter tier when Bebop, Trigun, Golden Boy, FMP and like 80% of the rest of in the connoisseur one. This isn't about the chart being good or bad, it's about how the writing in pre-90s shows was abysmal. Focus is an art, and that's something almost all of them lack. Imagine something like Layzner or Votoms with 25 instead of 35+ episodes? Maybe they could have been less trash and formulaic. Pre-90s TV has it's aesthetics and a few gems that simply didn't age terribly. From a narrative standpoint the 80s were downright laughable, and the 70s unoriginal and often insults to the source material they adapted. I still like plenty of 70s shows, but I sure as hell wouldn't call them well written.
Writing has always been the weakest link in anime, but during the 80s and 70s that was arguably more true than ever since.
If your sole focus is on focus (pardon the wording), then I can understand your point, but the actual thematic exploration, characterization, narrative scope/weight, and general novelty was a lot higher in 70s Dezaki/Matsumoto/WMT stuff than the average TV anime. Filler is a detractor, but you also have to see works as a product of their time.
>was a lot higher in 70s Dezaki/Matsumoto/WMT stuff than the average TV anime
That's not really what matters, now does it? What matters is the average. If we were going by the heights of an era, then none of Dezakis works would ever be able to stand up to the most thematically "deep" entries of the 90s. In fact, a show like IM@S has more social commentary and valuable cultural subtext than any 70s show ever created. Most of them merely use social issues as narrative tools without ever truly exploring them, especially not beyond the source material's intension. The WMT is an insult to western literature. It has like 3-4 good shows, and that's already stretching it. The shit they turned Peter Pan into is almost physically painful.
The characterization also was nothing but filler because it was repeated ad nauseam, as if the audience had the brain of a fish. Harlock being the best example. One doesn't even need to look at the TV show for this. You can simply look at the movies, like Arcadia of my Youth. Instead of simply mentioning Harlock honorable nature once, and leaving the audience with it, it's mentioned and repeated like 5 times throughout the film, something that provided virtually no value whatsoever unless you happened to suffer from memoryloss mid movie. It's a perfect representation of what 70s/80s characterization generally looked like.
As far as narrative scope goes: There's more of it in something like Moribito than you'll find in any padded shit like Dougram, Zeta, Votoms or the likes. Granted, that might not be fair since it was written by Uehashi, but still. You don't watch Texhnolyze or Katangatari and conclude that the world lacks in scale. That's probably a feeling you'll very much have after finishing Dougram despite its 70+ episodes. Gamba probably does world building and scale better than 99% of all pre-90s anime, and that show went for 26episodes. The 50episode format was a fucking meme.
I totally agree with you. The pic was bait actually. A lot of the shit I put in the connoisseur tier were random. If I were to remake the pic (still for baiting but at least improving it) something like Lupin the third or Alps no shojo Heidi, or Harlock wouldn't miss for sure. I just made that as fast as I could.
Can someone please explain why every other 3x3 thread lately devolves into retards arguing about shit?
Hopefully because people realized that these threads are awful unless posters make an effort to talk to eachother. The girds looks terrible, share entries all the time, barely anyone responds if you ask why they like X, next to none of them have the balls to actually + or - individual entries so you can react to their ratings etc.
>The girds [sic] looks terrible
There's 4 or 5 that look pretty nice in this thread.
>talk to eachother
People could talk without all that shitposting though. What we most often get is someone baiting someone else in the most aggressive way possible, resulting in two people screaming their opinions at one another as if they had any objective value.
But they don't, that's the thing. They post their grid, attach some superficial ratings to it, and go mia. And then all that happens is you being busy bumping the thread for 20hrs because noone actually says a thing.
I implore you! Please! Open your web browser (any works) and find a site called "Reddit" (yes it sounds like read it) there you will find many like-minded people who want to engage in deep and thought-provoking conversations of anything anime and manga related, without the toxic environment that Yea Forums creates, see you there my friend!
Oh, so if you don't want trolls to ruin threads, you are a redditor nowadays? Gotcha.
What is this? It looks incredible?
1/1
1/1
2/2
1/2
filename
0/1
Too many: ~65%
2/5
1/5