How does _H.P. Lovecraft: A Life_ compare to _I Am Providence: The Life and Times of H.P. Lovecraft_?

How does _H.P. Lovecraft: A Life_ compare to _I Am Providence: The Life and Times of H.P. Lovecraft_?

Is the "restored" content worthwhile?

Attached: iap.gif (317x227, 59K)

Other urls found in this thread:

stjoshi.org/review_barron.html
stjoshi.org/news.html
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

>adds a whole chapter on how The Statement of Randolph Carter is actually based on a true story
>adds a whole chapter on Lovecraft's fetishes and his newly discovered erotic writings
>adds a whole chapter complaining about the SJWs changing the World Fantasy Award trophy
>adds a whole chapter complaining about Stephen King and his son Joe Hill
>adds a whole chapter talking about the time he kicked Laird Barron ass

S. T. Joshi went insane desu

I have no idea, but I've read I Am Providence and I thoroughly enjoyed it.

what's going on here

Attached: Snapshot_20140330_1.jpg (640x480, 49K)

R.I.P. W. H. Pugmire.

Pugmire and joshi talking about clark ashton smith

Must know more about joshi vs. Laird

>>adds a whole chapter on Lovecraft's fetishes and his newly discovered erotic writings
this actually sounds interesting desu

basically Joshi doesn't buy into the cult of personality surrounding Barron

stjoshi.org/review_barron.html

I argee, can someone post a brief summary?

You are a shitty novelist

He liked to eat ass

Joshi is godlike

Doesn't Barron also have beef with Ligotti?

Isn't this the N word guy? Why isn't everyone bring it up. You know what he called his cat right?

>Say the line, Bart!

YOU BETTER NOT SAY IT

He's not serious.

Attached: gibson_lovecraft.jpg (920x980, 167K)

The great thing about Lovecraft is that anybody denying that his cosmology is fundamentally racialist automatically outs him or herself as a moron

Literally a great champion of literature for the work he has done for fantasy and weird fiction

Kinda. In his story "More Dark" he very blatantly shits on Ligotti.

pugmire is kill? wew

Died at the end of March. You can read about it on Joshi's blog: stjoshi.org/news.html

i would have loved getting stoned with lovecraft and talk about history or stuff. the man is my hero

to bad he would call you a nigger loving degenerate for smoking weed

Yeah, Joshi should stick to non-fiction.

Never read his stuff I know he's supposed to be good, but I refuse to read it because he's such a weird looking blob entity

>But the saddest story of the lot is “More Dark,” the one tale not set in the Pacific Northwest. Instead, New York City is the locus, and we are treated to a dismayingly nasty and mean-spirited caricature of Thomas Ligotti (poorly disguised as “Tom L”). Barron’s protagonist states

>My impression of L’s work was lukewarm as I found his glib pooh-poohing of the master Robert Aickman as a formative influence of his disingenuous considering their artistic similarities, and L’s reduction of human characters to ciphers a trifle off-putting.…His gloom and groan regarding the Infernal Bureaucracy wasn’t my cup of tea, yet it possessed a certain resonance among the self-loathing, chronically inebriated, perpetually persecuted set. (252)

>There is much more of this, not to mention cameo appearances of Ellen Datlow, Mark Samuels, Michael Cisco, Gordon Van Gelder, and many others (including myself). What possible reason Barron could have had for writing this story is beyond my understanding; it would probably prove entirely incomprehensible to those who don’t know the characters involved, and unseemly for those who do. I fervently hope Barron doesn’t write anything like this again.

What the fuck is his fucking problem?