Who is the GOAT action star?
Stallone or Arnold
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
twitter.com
Arnold, no question
arnie
A R N I E
Arnold because he had a better agent.
Although I feel like Stallone understands movies better, he just does too many cash ins. I would have liked him to write/direct more.
Arnold marketed himself better.
Stallone went the more family friendly route and his movies are more wholesome on an average. But as the better -action star- there's noone better than Ahnold.
would cliffhanger had been better with arnie? probably
>Stallone went the more family friendly route and his movies are more wholesome on an average.
wtf, stallone is incapable of doing comedy while schwarzy made plenty of those: twins, junior, jingle all the way, true lies etc
you left out Kindergarten Cop
Yeah, this. Stallone’s main attempt at action comedy was Stop! Or My Mom Will Shoot and that was a total misfire compared to Arnold’s comedy successes.
He was ok in Death Race 2000.
Arnold.
Stallone is great, but he can't compete with Arnold.
Arnold Schwarzenegger is an extremely strange person.
Stallone, mainly because he didn't turn into a fucking cuck.
As a action star Arnold has more charisma but Stallone is a better actor I think although I think Arnold is underrated too. People say he is a horrible actor but I don't think that is accurate. Look at the comedies that he did. Classic movies all of them.
Rambo: First Blood Part 2 is totally underappreciated in the modern age and was a total blast for me to watch in 2019.
The part after the Viets kill her girlfriend when he comes back to their camp to kill all of them and rescue the POWs is one of the best action fragments ever.
Dunno, they both made some really good films and they both became irrelevant for mainstream audiences around the same time.
In the 80s and 90s I'd say Arnold.
In the last 20 years though it's Stallone because he's had The Expendables and the Rambo films.
I do think Stallone has made more "good" films overall though.
Fuck yeah. Parts of this movie are like snorting a fat rail of testosterone.
Based on the 90's alone probably Arnold
Now if we compare their latest work
Terminator: Dark Fate vs Rambo
It'd be Stallone
Arnie is a better action star with some good ideas, but Stallone seems to have a better knack at making movies overall
Stallone got an Oscar. He was always better at more serious films/scenes, Arnold was better when comedy was involved, hell even Terminator 2 has some seriously funny scenes.
Dzeki
It's sub par really, compare it to Predator
Arnold's star burned brighter at it's peak. He was the undesputed biggest actor in Hollywood for a time.
Stallone has him beat for longevity though.
arnold, though he has lower lows he has several higher highs.
i cannot stand predator or conan the barbarian and nobody will be able to make me see it the way they see it, but i also hate rocky 2 and rambo 2
>People say he is a horrible actor
They are wrong. Schwarzenegger is a great actor. Arguably, you could make Dolph Lindgren play Terminator in T1 and it wouldn't make much difference since he's supposed to be a menacing bulking brute and nothing more.
But to sell a killer cyborg from the future who learns humanity and bonds with a boy in a way which doesn't come off as ridiculous you need a real talent.
Predator is its own thing as a Sci-Fi movie clothed as a machismo action film. Arnold is great in Predator but he couldn't sell the emotion, the raw anger Stallone has for Murdock.
youtube.com
youtube.com
>i cannot stand predator
HE DOESN'T LIKE PREDATOR LADIES AND GENTLEMAN.
HE
DOESN'T
LIKE
FUCKING
PREDATOR
One of the most perfect action movies ever made.
Who is the GOAT action star?
Agreed, Stallone definitely is the better actor but he appears in a lot of low tier garbage
Commando is the quintessential action movie, so Arnold
Jackie's movies are way better, and they also have great action scenes
The ending is kino just like in the first movie
stallone is not as likable as arnold.
everyone talks about the action but besides the action,
arnold can play a caring father or a funny uncle. arnold can be soft, friendly and cheerful, arnold can be comfy,
arnold is a guy you enjoy talking to thats easy going and chill. arnold is charming
stallone is edgy and moody, has a brooding personality, hes not that funny or that charming in any movie, even in his comedies.
he would be a great punisher, but he cant be charming or silly like arnold can
arnold can be stabbing a guy and he can make you smile with his charisma
even terminator 2 he has charm without saying a word.
pic related
How did he, a robot, know to smile while holding a gun? Surely he would be programmed to think that humans are scared of guns of that size
It's hard to call. Stallone usually played heroic roles, although in Rambo 2 he did burn down a farming village full of innocent women and children for no reason. Whereas Arnold in the 80s spent most of his movies eradicating the Hispanic population. It's a shame John Matrix and John Rambo never teamed up to go on safari in Chicago or Tel Aviv.
I think he was wistfully hoping that John would let him go on a killing spree. They were on the Mexican border and 1) the T-800's natural programming is to slaughter humans, and 2) Arnold's natural programming is to slaughter (or impregnate) Hispanics.
for the first half. the second half is full retard
i'd love it if Arnold lost to the intergalactic warrior who picked off Arnold + his team, but for some reason Arnold - his team = Arnold wins
Between Arnold and Stallone? Arnold.
Overall? Jackie Chan.
This is not as bad as Predator 2. In the first one, the thing gets worn down hunting and fighting spic soldiers and a CIA death squad for like a week, and Arnold has to Home Alone him to even stand a chance at finishing a very wounded Predator. In 2, a Predator happily slaughters spics, niggers, white trash punk rockers, cops, and CIA agents, only to get killed by fat retard Danny Glover.
Jackie by a country mile. Come on now. Segal's early films are honestly underrated but how the fuck can you compare those to something like Police Story or Drunken Master.
Fuck it here's the mall fight from Police Story:
>youtube.com
Depends. Arnold choose way better directors to work with.
Sly had a massive ego and largely choose director puppets where he could ghost direct the movies. All of the Rambo movies are basically directed by Sly himself according to the staff and especially Cosmatos only did minor directing for First Blood Part 2 and Cobra.
But I think people give Stallone more shit than he deserves, aside from Cobra who was on par with Commando in terms of depth, all of his action movies deal with deeper themes than Arnis action movies aside from Terminator 1 and 2. Rambo 1 and 2 are partly character dramas.
But overall I must say Arni, he was smart enough to let the director be the decision maker and don't put 100% of his ego into the productions, Sly always interfered into script and directing, which is why barely anyone of the big 80s and 90s directors worked with him.
Jackie's hard to top because of a lot of things he does for his action. Even having a dedicated crew of his own stuntmen. Not to mention Jackie's knack for timing and comedy.
Arnie OTOH has got to be among the top, and seems to have a somewhat similar ethic with Jackie. He improved his english, and went beyond acting.
No one can compete with Arnie, but it says a lot about Stallone that we even have threads like this. He had a great career too.
>stallone is edgy and moody, has a brooding personality, hes not that funny or that charming in any movie
You're saying this about the man who played Rocky Balboa.
Rocky is a good point. Stallone did the "noble retard" decades before Forrest Gump.
Why do the good threads here die? This thread drops, while faggots post about gay shit like Ezra Miller or friends. This place should be gassed.
and he rapes his Adrian rather than letting her go out and get AIDS and making him raise her bastard
There are thousands of forums in the internet. You can go to other place that you like more at any time.
He didn't rape her, but yeah.
Fuck off, faggot. Maybe this place should work on straightening up a little.
no this place is the one place we can do this
if you want "discussion" on the two most popular actors of all time you have many avenues
Do what? Shouldn't the gay shit be contained on /lgbt/? You have your own containment board, why do you freaks always want to push your perversions into the view of real people?
>gooks
>innocent
>underappreciated
lol it had a massive cultural impact and was parodied by everyone
He fell in love with a Vietnamese woman he knew for like ten minutes and avenges by wiping out the nearest village, probably where her family lived, lol
I feel sorry for you. I used to be like this. Let me give you an advice: you are not going to change anything raging about it and making posts like this because the mods doesn't care about you and the admin cares less about how the boards function. Also, the weeb-lgtb mafia is much more powerful than you and even the majority of people in this site is like them or don't see them as the degenerates that they certainly are. So you are wasting your energy and time complaining about this because nothing is going to change. Another advice: hide all of that crap, don't browse boards like /qa/, /bant/ or /r9k/, just go there to make a thread and leave intimidatingly. They are lost boards. Good luck my friend, I'm with you.
I watched the movie two days ago, square pants. They had it coming for even existing
The big fella. Arnold is once in a lifetime.
Definitely Arnold with his ability to pick 10/10 films. Stallone might have him beat in quantity of solid movies though especially in his later years.
Arnold had a better run of better movies. To nitpick, I also would have a hard time considering Rocky or Rocky II action movies.
Nonetheless the cultural impact of Rocky and Rambo are massive. First Blood and Rocky 1 are excellent films, both of which are possibly better movies than anything Arnie starred in.
>Predator would be better if the predator just slaughtered Arnie like everyone else.
I can tell you're a talented writer.
>tfw no Berserk kino with prime Stallone as Guts, the killer from Dirty Harry as Griffith, and Arnold nosferatu Zodd.
arnold was just lucky because he got covered in mud,if it wasn't for that he would have been killed like everyone else
guts is like 6'4'' while stallone is a 5'6'' manlet
>he doesn't know
Rambo 4, Rocky 6 and Last Blood I would say are much better than any of the Terminators with Arnold after T2
>last stallone rambo movie features mexicans
>last arnie terminator movie features mexicans
What's up with this?
the perfect Guts
dora the explorer too
just movies dealing with current themes
No matter which one you prefer I recommend all of you faggots listen to whichever of their movies have audio commentary, they are both entertaining as fuck to listen to.
Jackie by fucking far, mate, not even a discussion.
bad endings > happy endings.
its not exciting or interesting to have the good guy win, there's no tension, I knew Arnold would win so its just waiting for the movie to be over.
retard
you didnt know in which order or how the rest of the characters will die,so there was plenty of tension in that alone
im sorry that your strong belief in a retarded opinion has robbed you of enjoying a true kino
Oscar was funnier than anything Arnie ever did