The BRADDU PREASE meme made me go see this and it was absolutely kino...

Why

>more substance than interstellar
Anything has more substance than interstellar

Attached: 1554861974830.jpg (1079x1338, 76K)

How the fuck did he survive the trip from Neptune to Earth? what did he eat?

There was food on board for the original crew of 3(4?).

he was on his father's ship

No he wasn't, he blew that one up with the nuke.

No he wasn't, he returned to his ship.

Any idea when it's gonna be released? So far only 2 tracks has been released. Or 3, if you count this one youtube.com/watch?v=dIwwjy4slI8 I hope this isn't a situation like the Terror season 1 or the Revenant, where they only release the music that was specifically done for the movie and not the ones that were in the movie but were composed by other composers that had already existed before the movie.

Kinospace
Yep
Mmmhmm

it has a poor audience rating..why?

Interstellar, Gravity, Martian and all other space films this decade BTFO and it's not even close.

It's a character study and an action film. It has good ratings on imdb and letterboxd.

*not an action film

might consider watching it then. my own headphones wont do justice if i wait for bluray

dumb normies thought it was an action movie

The premise was kinda boring, but it was a good experience overall.

>The BRADDU PREASE meme made me go see this
funny thing is he beats up and murders an asian here as well(and splatters a diversity woman on a window)

Some old boomer lady loudly exclaimed how terrible she thought the movie was when we were all leaving after the show. I really liked it myself.

Films women will never understand

True

I love all these reviews that shit on the movie for not being completely scientifically accurate. Half the time they are completely wrong or didn't understand what was going on in the scene. As for the ones who are actually correct, wow you managed to allow minor details to ruin a really good movie for you just so that you could smugly write a blog post on IMBD so you can feel superior to everyone else, congratulations. Why do people go to movies if they don't even want to enjoy them?

>Yea Forums finally appreciating a good film
There is hope after all

James Gray always delivers.

i like this meme on Yea Forums, but it really hit me that ad astra is exactly that with its father-son, solitude, fate and purpose themes

It seems like some people are really just so focused on nitpicking minor details and they even get them wrong since the film explained them at some point. The film sure has some implausible moments but it's definitely not that stupid as some people try to present it. It's really good actually and better than most scifi films. So far my favourite of the year.

Another beautiful film women will never understand

I sat next to a boomer couple in the cinema. The woman gasped during all the tense moments like it was some survival horror and the husband exclaimed afterward that it was 'avarage'

Attached: 1411993386281.png (680x637, 200K)

>Half the time they are completely wrong or didn't understand what was going on in the scene
this is what gets me, all these muh sound in space nitpickers *always* out themselves as complete retards/phone watchers within a few sentences

He didn't travel back on his father's ship but when he was on the Lemur Project Ship he could definitely have stocked up, given the expected size of the crew

Just saw it the ending saved it. Without the ending itd be a mess. The whole physics are so wrong as a physicist this shit was cringe like him going through the neptune ice ring.....

The ending was the worst part. Just spelling out the message to the audience.

Oh sorry I meant the neptune sequence

this

Great movie overall, a solid 8/10 for me. Not a masterpiece but probably the best movie I've seen this year.

Visually stunning too, really liked the mars parts.

>stop at distress call
>26 souls on board, i wonder what happened to them
>MONKEY REEEEEEEE
>did not see a single person
>what happened to them
>oh well i guess we leave now

what happened to the FUCKING PEOPLE

THEY DID NOT SEE A SINGLE FUKCING BODY

WHAT HAPPENED

WHY LEAVE

this movie was so fucking shit - everything was half assed

Would've given it a 8/10 too but due to me having a science degree a lot of the shit drove me insane and I kept going omfg in real life this would never happen so it dropped it to a 7.75 but that's on me. It's my fault for being 31k in debt with a physics degree

here is another reason the movie is shit

>coward second in command duder cant even land a fucking ship
>minutes later he accepts a top secret mission to carry a nuke to the farthest reaches of the solar system to do some ninja jihad supa mission

yeah okay lads sure

shit fucking movie

Ok, bellend.

Maybe because the captain was attacked and they wanted to save him? What the fuck are you even on about you autist.
>incompetent people can't accept missions despite their incompetence

Can you be more specific?

Attached: longbitch.jpg (975x464, 65K)

Does the movie beat you over the head as hard as Gravity and Interstellar?

Attached: IMG_20190921_164504.jpg (571x319, 22K)

Conservation of momentum if the chimp charged at Brad and he wasn't holding onto anything they would've both gone backwards instead in the movie he holds him off in mid air.

The whole moon rover thing was kinda cool and blue Sunsets on mars were accurate.

Neptune Moon and him going through the ice rings. Bitch u know how wide those rings are and the moment he made first impact his momentum would've slowed down and he wouldn't have made it even a tiny bit through. Bunch of other bullshit

I liked Ad Astra, I hated Gravity and found Interstellar incredibly disappointing. They're space movies but they're quite different. Ad Astra is on the Blade Runner spectrum.

>Crew of three scientists, engineers and/or doctors
>"There is a stowaway"
>"Okay, let's shoot randomly in the hopes that we hittu Pittu"
And this, my friends, makes the movie more similar to Prometheus than to Interstellar.

he was dead, they said hes dead

they just fucking left without finding out what happened to 26 fucking people

it was literally nothing + 2 random ass fucking monkeys when they even said that the distress signal was sent recently

how do 26 people fucking disappear that fucking quickly if it was supposedly some fucking monkeys that somehow managed to murder them all

where is the blood, where are the bodies

why skip it, why show or explain nothing

SPACE PIRATES? WHO WHAT WHERE WHEN WHY

WAR ON THE MOOOOOOOOOOON? WHO WHAT WHERE WHEN HOW WHY

skip skip skip

I was disappointed by this movie, by you are overreacting.
I do think it would have been interesting to see the world in which these characters leave in a little more detail, but your complaints about the derelict ship are exaggerated.
It's not far-fetched to assume that two angry monkeys can defeat 26 scared scientists, who probably were further down the ship than we were shown.
Once the captain got mauled (and his visor fixed with duct-tape, nevermind the glove hole lmao) they had to haul ass back to their own ship. Especially since Pittu never wanted to go down there in the first place.

Interstellar is garbage
They didn't even explore the whole ship, how do you know there were only 2 monkeys? Why would they further risk their lives?
Are you fucking retarded? Do you need everything explained? Are you fucking autistic? Obviously yes. 5 hour cut just for you to explain everything. Maybe even a TV show just for you.
They were having territorial disputes and it was like wild west. Fighting for resources. The whole moon wasn't colonized, they might have been hired by other government too.

Multiple people in my cinema unironically feel asleep and were snoring, but it was pure kino from start to finish

nice fanfic

this movie was basically an example of 1/10 world building, whereas nu-br and fury road would be examples of 10/10 world building

this shit was fucking pathetic

Why do you think it's unrealistic that they would want to take down a guy who sneaked into the rocket after being dismissed for failing the psychology test? Just tell what they should have done, smartass.

Yep, was kinda hoping it ended after the explosion, without us knowing if he survived or not

>>coward second in command duder cant even land a fucking ship
>>minutes later he accepts a top secret mission to carry a nuke to the farthest reaches of the solar system to do some ninja jihad supa mission

Are you retarded? Didn't you understand the whole middle section of the movie? There was literally a voice over telling you about these people

>Interstellar is garbage
It depends on how the core messagee sits with you. The same is true for Ad Astra, which is why I liked the former (and I do admit it has its faults) but didn't really care for the latter.
I think they are opposites that complement each other quite well:
Interstellar
>Humanity is doomed
>The planet is doomed
>We better find someplace else quick
>We can get there by the power of love, which transcends time and space
Ad Astra
>Humanity is doing pretty well
>Interplanetary travel is commonplace
>Let's find extraterrestrial life for the lols
>We are alone in the universe
>So you'd better stay at home and love your daddy

>We are alone in the universe
>So you'd better stay at home and love your daddy

christ you are retarded, this is what I'd expect a woman to take from the movie

It's not the what, it's the how. I think the best course of action would have been diplomacy and isolation rather than overt violence from the get-go, especially when they were still getting out of Mars.
Again, shooting about in a room full of important equipment (was the nuke in that room?) sounds like something a smart person wouldn't do.
It can be chalked up to the rewrites/reshoots some user was mentioning yesterday (original Pitt outright murders the crew).

And what did you, oh machoest of alpha-males, take from it?

is this the new 2049?

>moon pirates
>space monkeys
>cgi neptune
>brad monologuing for an hour
>Yea Forums thinks this is kino
lmao

>The director on mars
>The military lead (Vogel)
>Both of them being black women

White divorced women should get 3/5ths of a vote.

Attached: 1560331785112.gif (200x200, 2.44M)

>CGI Neptune
To be fair, mate, they can't shoot on location.

We own the night never gets the recognition it deserves and you should check out Blood ties. Another brotherkino

At that point I bet the pussy second in command had no choice in the matter. If he was able to lie his way out of the first situation, there's no way he would have the balls to be like "nah, bros, I'm out."

???
the world building was great, the technology felt advanced, but still realistically clumsy at times (like when he was about to send that message to his ex wife and he had to cancel it twice because the first time his voice didnt register)

and every scene on the moon was amazing, them showing us how commercialized space travel has become with a fucking applebees, $120 blankets and of course petty wars over resources and territory. this all shows us how our problems follow us even when we're off the earth

the world building was there especially showcased in how they handle the deaths of the astronauts (letting them float off into the vacuum of space) tells us that deaths in space are very common and how astronauts in general they're revered as modern day pioneers paving the way for humankind

stop being a dumbass, just because the worldbuilding is subtle doesnt mean it isnt there

>cgi neptune
>credits: NASA images

At least they had proper reference, genius.

When a decent rip comes out it will get shit on by normies like BR2049.

This, I loved all the little aspects of space that felt very real, and not stupid sci-fi futuristic

It's already apparent that the guy already allows emotions to get the better of him in tense situations. He also allowed Pitt to humiliate him and gain a huge advantage over him by keeping that incident a secret. I think the captain of the ship really hates Pitts character at that point it isn't really that weird that he would order his crew to fight the intruder.

Nothing ever confirmed that they were alone, just the fact they couldn't find anything so far and wanted to return back with the research.

>It's already apparent that the guy already allows emotions to get the better of him in tense situations.
Then why allow HIM to man a ship? Of course, Pitt says something like "i won't report this", but I find it hard to believe that a person with such tendencies would only be problematic once.
Also, the feeling I got was that he knew there was a nuke on board and wanted to boycott the project, far-fetched as that sounds.
>Nothing ever confirmed that they were alone
The movie sort of spells that out in monologue. "All these planets. All beautiful surfaces. All empty rocks". If by the line "here's the map to the lake" we are supposed to accept there is water on Mars, it's not a stretch to believe that the aforementioned line implies there is no life in the universe other than on Earth.

nope, it was all halfassed and shit

it had no weight to it like fury road did

anyone can drop a couple of fucking """"""""world building""""""""" hints here and there like a fucking blanket or a shitty CNN news cameo without any effort or thought

this shit was shallow as fuck - absolutely dogshit worldbuilding compared to 2049/her/furyroad

>The moon is overrun by pirates
>Everybody knows this
>The buggies have no kind of protection
>Not even for the military

Attached: Sin título2.jpg (516x470, 34K)

>Then why allow HIM to man a ship? Of course, Pitt says something like "i won't report this", but I find it hard to believe that a person with such tendencies would only be problematic once.

Rewatch the movie, Pitt explains that they are academic types, and can't handle pressure like a military guy he is, but doesn't mean they are not otherwise highly competant

t:retard

the world was built amazingly, do you need flashing neon signs telling you "THIS IS THE FUTURE" for you to accept is as worldbuilding?

>cgi neptune
just film on location brah
just build a neptune in studio brah
what are you, some kinda greenscreen capeshitter?

>Then why allow HIM to man a ship? Of course, Pitt says something like "i won't report this", but I find it hard to believe that a person with such tendencies would only be problematic once.
Just like in real life, there are incompetent people in powerful position because X reason. But then again the guy failed in high stress situations. Roy was an exceptional guy who can stay calm even when shit hits the fan, he's almost like a robot.

The moondust part (and the chase) was kino. I think 90% of the viewers didnt think about it

it was complete garbage, no surprise the redditors here are eating it up
about as "realistic" as star wars

>seeing movie because of a meme
>instead of actual based brad
you're a trend-following tool

YEAH dude, in 20+ years in an optimistic future society we'll be able to have the technology to scan every fucking rock in the universe for signs of life.
His monologue was heavily biased due to his prolonged isolation as well as loss of his father.

I believe you are providing contradictory evidence, mate. If they are academic types, why are they in control of a ship? Wouldn't it make more logistical sense to have an engineer or a pilot at the control seat, just in case?
From what I understand, the autopilot takes care of those things, and the ship had just been struck by the radiation, which is not all that uncommon IRL.
Again, my two main qualms are
>Hot-headed academic type in control of a ship
>Hot-headed academic type shooting inside a ship without provocation

And yet he's not allowed to proceed with his mission because he's a little bit more nervous than usual. I assume he is under a different organization, but still.
Also, why didn't he record the message on Earth?

Calm down, incels.

its not about being realistic, retard

The neptune sequence saved the horrible moon and mars bits

yeah because the father son story was so much better with him going all the way to neptune just for his dad to tell him he hates him and then kill himself. KINO

By "Academic types" Pitt probably meant the personality. Some of them already had piloting training, which seems like mandatory for having a career in space

My point exactly.
>OMG so sad, nothing even mattress
>TFW alone
>TFW alone in the universe 5ever

they are skilled pilots in the academic sense, as in pass all their tests successfully, but have never had to deal with real stressful situations.

Also, just how many deep space pilots do you imagine their are in this universe? Doesn't seem like many. flawed people exist and this movie is full of them

>It depends on how the core messagee sits with you. The same is true for Ad Astra, which is why I liked the former (and I do admit it has its faults) but didn't really care for the latter.
I disagreed with the core message of Ad Astra but it's much better than Interstellar. Interstellar is overtly sentimental trash pandering to complete retards. The hard sci fi mixed with muh love transcendents time was ridiculous. Ad Astra is not subtle in its message but the delivery is much better than in Interstellar. Also Interstellar has the book shelf scene which was fucking terrible. Nolan is not a good director, he should go back to making mid budget thrillers and stop making hyper stupid blockbusters.

>many deep space pilots do you imagine their are in this universe?
>Doesn't seem like many.
You are posing yet another problem. In a universe where space travel seems to be commonplace, the interest in space careers would also be commonplace, making "space piloting" as common as business management in career choice.
I'll take your point about flawed people. But it doesn't stop me from calling a scientist a moron for shooting inside his own goddamn ship.

>And yet he's not allowed to proceed with his mission because he's a little bit more nervous than usual. I assume he is under a different organization, but still.
They figured he didn't pass the test, the crew memebers did but they are on different missions, he was on a secret mission where he basically has to kill his dad. They aren't on the same level of pressure. I think it's an important moment in the film because the moment Roy starts acting like a human, they immediately relieved him from his mission. So basically all his life he was like a robiot because he had no choice.

>Interstellar is overtly sentimental trash pandering to complete retards.
user, that is your opinion. Because I feel a similar way about Ad Astra. Both movies are "daddy issues: IN SPACE". Also, the delivery is not much better if it needs voice over to literally spell things out for the audience.

Agreed, but it still feels weird.

>A botched military space operation is somehow just as ridiculous as DUDE JUST TRAVEL INTO A BLACK HOLE TO GO TO THE FOURTH DIMENSION TO WRITE HEXADECIMALS IN THE FUCKING DUST TO YOUR DAUGHTER LMAO

stop speaking in autistic hyperboles you sperg, this wasnt the best movie, but to say the world building was "dogshit" and "shallow" is blatantly untrue and really shows how much of a brainlet you really are

you unironically make me feel embarrassed to like 2049 and her knowing that aspie contrarian fucks like you exist

You see, reductionism work both ways.
>A dying species needs to find new colonies to establish themselves is just as ridiculous as DUDE ANTIMATTER ENGINE IS FUCKED UP SO TRAVEL MILLIONS OF MILES TO SAY HELLO TO YOUR PAPA AND ALSO GO THROUGH SOME ROCKS WITH A SHIELD

Interstellar is absolutely retarded film, i don't even know how you can compare it with Ad Astra. The voice over explains Pitt's emotional state, he is a stoic character so it pulls the audience closer to him. Was it necessary? Probably not. Was it bad? No.

If you don't know how Interstellar and Ad Astra relate, I'd recommend watching both again.
Also, as a general rule, even on the chanz, try not to define things as "absolutely retarded" if you want your opinions taken seriously.

>character study
And a bone chilling slow burn

>If you don't know how Interstellar and Ad Astra relate, I'd recommend watching both again.
They relate because spaceship. seriously these movies are much different.

Attached: 1569029224829.jpg (480x262, 12K)

Parent and child separated for decades.

reddit actually hates it but ok. i'm going to see it again in theaters before joker comes out.

Why did the father's mission take 16 years without no return ticket when Brad could get there in only 78 days? You'd think they'd sent other missions there after original crew dissapeared.

that's just a plot point, thematically very different

>Why go on.
>I will deal with him. I will deal with my father.
>*grabs a fucking piece of metal and jumps through Neptune's ring using it as a shield*
It was KINO

Really? Ad Astra has more in common with Apocalypse Now than Interstellar.

So one anti-matter generator can destroy the whole solar system? Are these generators common, or do only certain space ships have them? What if a terrorist gets their hands on one?

Watch the movie again, it's literally explained in detail during the exposition
I appreciated the pace compared to capeshit

that's probably my only criticism of the movie, that part felt a bit retarded

It was clear that was the original ending. It would have been a kino way to end, but ofc u gotta spell it out for the audience so the studio made him add those dumbass scenes after

JUST TURN YOUR BRAIN OFF BRO
STOP ASKING QUESTIONS BRO

They specifically mention that they abandonned this technology because of the unstability.

They did mention that they sent drones but couldn't find them but why didn't Brad had same difficulties finding them?

I'm not gonna pay to see good but ultinately rather mediocre film again. If you can't answer other than "watch it again" it's clear that you don't have answer. Probably becayse while there is lot of good about it, there is lots of unintended absurdity in the plot.

Like Brad's actions cause dead of 3 astronauts when he sneaks in but somehow he is just drinking coffee as free man when film ends.

>I appreciated the pace compared to capeshit
Same. While watching it, I enjoyed the first half more than the second half, but after reflecting on it, the third act might be my favourite part of the movie. It's very simple and there is no stupid convoluted mind bender twist that people usually like to put in space movies. And I'm not saying this in a Rian Johnson "absolutely subverted" kind of way, I'm saying this because I genuinely liked the direction the film went in the finale the more I think about it. It just works for a film like this. And I'm starting to think the movie had too much action. The space monkey could have been cut out, and that would remove that weird mini subplot about the captain's incompetence as well. Pretty comfy my dude.

Attached: Ad Astra moon.png (732x301, 130K)

>Why yes I did like the part with Moon pirates.

Attached: 80CE4A51-78E2-4A4A-B991-678E16C883FF.jpg (400x400, 30K)

I don't know who you're quoting but the people who say the moon pirates were the best part of the movie are plebs who wanted the rest of the movie to be like that.

It was alright, didn't ruin the film. The best was where be said i'm alone and then the montage in space.

Why did space pirates attack convoy that didn't have any cargo to steal? What's the point?

There were lots of nonsensical things like that and most of suspense/action scenes felt like they were just added there to sell this philosophical introspective film to wide audience and didn't really fit the film. But I liked the message and how it basically debunked the whole space hype that ironically makes films like these commercially viable.

Like why are people so crazy about going to Mars? We already know that there is nothing but rocks and sand. Even the whole safeguarding humanity argument is quite dubious because Mars is so inhospitable that even after worst catastrophe on earth like nuclear war, earth would probably still be easier place to live than Mars. I'm not against space travel and I hope it continues to develop but unless there is warp drive or something like that I don't see anything cool about. It's basically impossible to get outside solar system with traditional space travel and there are not much grand mysteries about solar system. Which makes Brad's father's mission even more absurd. Going to Neptune to find Alien civilization is like going one meter into the ocean to find whales instead of just doing it from shore.

it wasn’t very good and i’m pretty sure editing fucked it up. The tone felt all over the place and a lotta plot elements don’t actually go anywhere. The film does show how maddening the isolation of space can be but that’s all it did well. Ending is completely horseshit, they might as well have had him fucking space skateboard to the ship.

Going to Mars is a milestone in space exploration. we know there's nothing, but landing there isn't trivial, let alone building a settlement. But those who actually want to find life outside Earth are refusing to recognize the exceptional situation we are in. They want to believe it's an accident and there must be others to prove that it's not that uncommon.

they're both family/interpersonal movies wrapped into a spaceship aesthetic

>film mentions a million times how strict the qualifications are for space missions
>a team of fucking retards got approved to go to Neptune for a hugely important mission

But even if you want to find life outside earth, manned space flights are completely useless. It's like trying to search oceans by swimming 10 meters from beach. Distances in space are just too big for travel outside something very scifi like warp drive or wormholes.

Based film. The audience score kinda surprises me, the normally retard Louisiana normies in my imax screening seemed pretty unbored by it

Uh, so what was with the focus on religion among the astronauts? I guess it's thematically appropriate or whatever if you look at it a certain way but it felt really awkward

Dealing with adults who believe in fairy tales is awkward in any context.

Half-assed abandoned plot idea thrown in to make the film seem smarter.

I noticed it too. The talk about traitors and “burials at sea” in space theme, plus there actually being a space-based military branch and the moon being a patchwork of lawless zones made me think maybe something happened and the world’s governments aren’t quite the same as they are in our time, and religion ended up becoming more prominent or something.

I mean, I'd get if there were religious astronauts in the context of the movie since it deals a lot with dealing with isolation, but multiple characters talk about space exploration as a religious duty and even have a funeral that makes it seem like religion is protocol.

Gave me some serious Starship Troopers vibes and I honestly thought there would be some plot point regarding it or at least elaborated on in the worldbuilding

I guess that's why we haven't been to Mars

This

Attached: 4eb30f9b1517821d8cdb6c4a8cddc744753958aa.jpg (1119x1600, 295K)

The Immigrant is James Gray's masterpiece

Attached: bf3c26fff4cda546ce0272f184348b2e.jpg (300x412, 33K)

my friend is convinced that brad was screaming at the end when his father was floating away, but i keep telling him it was tommy lee jones screaming. am i right or is my dumb friend right?

best film of 2019.

>None of my pleb friends liked the movie
>I had to listen to them talk shit about it for 2 hours afterwards

Attached: sad fitzjames.jpg (790x830, 39K)

>he didn't put his friends on Yea Forums and Yea Forums
>he doesn't have indepth discussions on kinos with them
i feel bad for anyone that doesn't know this feel

why so much shilling this movie? It was written by an idiot, wildly and unnecessarily unrealistic.

Your friend is right. It was BRADDU scremingu.
If you can't deal with differing opinions on things you like, you need to grow up.

I think it was the daddy removing his helmet

Holy shit how can you be so retarded
It was the uncle diddling Uranus

>best film of 2019
So far...

Attached: 1568482570559.jpg (797x574, 137K)

>If you can't deal with differing opinions on things you like, you need to grow up.
We're Yea Forums, retard. Outside of this website, we deal with differing opinions all our lives. How about you take your shit advice and give it to the normies?

I'd rather give it to retards. It's like social working, but I can call you retard, retard.

>BRADDU PREASE meme made me go see this
A retarded meme spammed by white incels, spics, and niggers forced you out of the house? Wow, I guess that stupid shit is actually good for you permavirgins LMAO

Attached: yao_lol.jpg (407x428, 19K)

It's about Love, something your thick womanly head will never comprehend.

t. woman

Your friend.
As the scream was fading the scene cut back to Brad with his mouth open, clearly distressed.

Just came from the cinema.

Beautiful visuals, great soundtrack, good premise but the story fell on it’s face HARD. It’s like they couldn’t decide what genre of film they are going for, they could have gotten so much more out of the ending. Not to mention that the entire film Felt like the director tried to copy the visual and audio direction of Interstellar a bit too hard.

Also what the fuck was the point of the space monkies?

Attached: 2160E729-350C-4C58-8298-466BFE488058.png (473x393, 292K)

The moon pirates was completely and utterly retarded

An excuse to get rid of the only other competent person on the craft other than McBride.

>moon pirates

do they steal braaapps

yeah exactly if feminists complain about this film then that's bizarre.

It was a good film but a lot of things were strange and impractical, and usually thats ok with films but with space films you expect some level of consideration for science and engineering that goes behind everything.

Why would they assign such an elderly astronaut to be his backup who ended up failing due to heart problems?
Why would trained astronauts unbuckle themselves during take off to fire guns in a compression tank?
How did he fly with that door and seemed to maneuver in open space with little to no complications?

Attached: naruto-run.jpg (1036x691, 46K)

What’s with all the pointless bullshit criticism this movie is receiving when way shittier movies get a pass?

Capeshit loving retards can't stand flawed but kino films taking up space on their precious board.

It really wasn’t, the setting didn’t make sense. The mission itself didn’t make sense. The people didn’t make sense. The ending didn’t make sense.

The film is beautiful but that’s it.

Please tell me what was “kino” about it

if you can't come to your own conclusion off it, then you won't understand even if it's painstakingly explained to you. you either get kino or you don't. it's as simple as that. it's okay if you didn't like this movie, or just didn't get it.

Anyone else get the feeling that the society it was set in was vaguely dystopic?

>filename

Attached: ahhh.gif (218x218, 2.7M)

It was good but it felt like it lacked something to make it great.

>I don’t have any meaningful criticism and I don’t understand it so I’ll just call it a fairy tale

My dad is the smartest person I know and yet,
>did you see Ad Astra
>yes, awful !!!

What happened?

Attached: Screenshot_20190922-123331~2.png (1080x687, 230K)

>Anyone else get the feeling that the society it was set in was vaguely dystopic?
There was a pretty heavy-handed message about "muh commercialisation of space" so it was intended.

I feel that the psychological evaluation tidbits were more to do with Brad spitting out his feelings for you, than the director actually taking a stance that we'll have those in the future. They sound retarded.

clearly he's smarter than you

>admitting to being french
Damn son

Okay so I shouldn't like the movie ? Now I'm insecure about thinking it was alright.

Forget it, Yea Forums will do anything to be contrarian retards for the sake of being contrarian retards.

Wasn’t that the point of the narrating. He knows what’s wrong with him but wont fix it because he’s still bending to his fathers will.

Ton père est donc un plébéien

Attached: 1492813025639.jpg (1017x579, 330K)

Sick question dodge.

Please tell me what was "kino" about it for you then.

>wasn't pretentious garbage
>2 hours of trite philosophy 101 voice over

You do realize it’s criticizing people who just take blind orders right? That’s why they follow their orders so rigorously.

way too many back to back extreme events to highlight how dead inside Brad was to the audience, like every 5 minutes he's under some life or death extreme situation where he has zero emotional reaction just to highlight how detached from reality he is that it became laughable

They hid his actions from the public the same way they did with his pops.

Pitts best performance, great cinematography/score. Tackles it themes in a way that suits the director style. Great ending and the confrontation scene is kino.

>Pitts best performance

Stopped reading. But I like how you basically only mentioned visual/audio and the ending segment, while leaving out 95% of the film.

Attached: 1355051230662.jpg (511x511, 61K)

The most kino moment. The whole movie is kino I just selected one moment that I think is the best. I think it’s Pitts best performance because he captures the feeling of holding back your emotions while they are bumbling under the surface perfectly. Reminded me of Peter Sellers performance in Being There.

from vulture.com
In outline, the film is a Kubrick-like retelling of Apocalypse Now in which the Willard character, Roy McBride (Brad Pitt), is the son of the renegade Kurtz figure, H. Clifford McBride (Tommy Lee Jones), whose ship disappeared many years ago (this is the “near future”) in the vicinity of Neptune while searching for signs of distant life

You are seriously confusing "kino" with "wow that looked/sounded pretty" scenes. As I said before, the visuals and audio were great. I disagree completely on Brad Pitt, it's not really had to portray an "I'm emotionally dead" character; even though the story of Interstellar was a mess, Matthew McConaughey's performance was a thousand times better in the EXACT same "lone astronaut" role.

That said, the movie is so riddled with plotholes, nonsensical scenes (space pirates, space monkey), and completely forgettable sidecharacters that It just ended up being a shiny turd.

Makes sense, I read that in an earlier version of the script Roy was more explicitly said to be on the autism spectrum

No what makes its great isn’t it’s visuals or audio it’s the way it tackles it themes with precision and tells a captivating story. If you think Matthews performance or character was in any way similar to Pitts than I think you need to rewatch both films.

What are some other loneliness kino?

Attached: still-life.jpg (600x848, 67K)

>it’s the way it tackles it themes with precision and tells a captivating story

Oh please. It's essentially "Muh Dad" - The Sci-fi movie. Nothing even remotely original about.

what do you do with your degree

Where did he say that is was an original concept?

Where did I say it’s original? Originality isn’t a determining factor of a great movie. Is First Reformed a bad movie because it’s not original?

whens the best time to go see this movie alone?

this, why can't they have a canopy of some sort.
aerodynamics matter less on the moon right?

November 7th at 7:77 PM

there is nothing more pleb than 'i want to know more about the lore' in a film that is almost entirely about one man. get a little taste of the world and move on, this isn't a cinematic universe and it doesn't need more world building.

Just saw it few hours ago in my local kinoplex, it was very good. Good acting, visual effects, music, tone, tension, etc. I actually don't remember having watched such a good sci-fi movie in the last decade or more.

Another pleb filter ; apparently normies hate it. Sad.

In the morning, there's generally not many people

Also I must say I definitely wasn't fan of Bradu Pittu but he delivered two very solid performances in few months. I think he aging like fine wine, both physically and in acting abilities,.

Attached: __5d3793cece03c.jpg (1800x968, 410K)

Fury Road takes place in a desert the entire movie. They don't even show you the ruins of anything. How is that good world-building?

Dumbest, most pointless scene in the movie.
>hurrdurr look at this dead guy's wife and kid and how unfeeling Bradddu is
Movie beat you over the head too much with such simple motifs.

You do realize he was feeling and has emotions the whole movie right?

Boomer dads won't get it or like it. Doesn't matter how smart they are. Just the way it is.

Boomer dads like modern action films and dislike things that are "too slow" ie. when something isn't constantly happening.

Did you even watch the movie?

Your dad never loved you or your mother.

Did you? He was clearly keeping them under the surface. He was aware of them and often reflected on them.

>wife leaves because he's cold and detached
>heart beat never raises above 60 even in life or death situations
>voice over literally spells out "I should feel something but I don't" for brainlets like you
He only had feelings related to his father and blocked out everything else. That's the entire point of the entire movie. Try to pay attention next time zoomer.

>movie about a detached loner
>don't cast the Goose

Attached: ee1.jpg (580x548, 34K)

Not realizing he’s lying to himself because of that’s what’s expected of him. Not understanding that’s the theme of the movie. You can see his emotions slip out before being reigned in. Please
refrain from criticizing films until you learn how to dissects a films themes.

>”I didn’t want you to go”.
Yeah he’s definitely not suppressing his emotions.

to show that norwegians will never change, even in space they will import monsters into their fragile ecosystems and die every time.

>zoomer
Stopped reading right there

Cuz it's a very average movie, just look how much is being shilled here, it has good moments but in the end is forgettable with nothing that stands out, easily a 5/10, I still recommend it but won't call it kino, god, that word has lost it's meaning.

But that's not the reason why the audience rating is low, and you know it

oh shit

Attached: 1290721923650.jpg (498x423, 118K)

Contact had some pretty big holes...

What did you think of Arraival?

Oh fuck, just read some audience reviews, they are fucking retarded

>Brad Pitt says his latest movie, a space drama, deals heavily with the concept of toxic masculinity.
Hard pass.

And yet, they just let one of these reactors float out in Neptune's orbit with a madman that killed his crew for years on end without attempting to deal with it.

>When the black scientist/astronaut woman smashes her face on the glass and Brad Pitt's character yells out "Take that you darkie bitch!"
I don't know, seemed out of the place considering the rest of the movie's atmosphere.

Attached: 1323956337576.png (199x200, 34K)