I would have gone with you to the end. Into the very fires of Mordor

>I would have gone with you to the end. Into the very fires of Mordor
Fellowship was a perfect movie

Attached: aragorn fotr.jpg (1920x1080, 183K)

except for pipeweed being transformed into cannabis and gimli being made comic relief and the distractingly obvious miniatures and the shit tier cave troll cg

Attached: 1545256206829.png (720x888, 938K)

Fellowship is definitely my favorite of the 3.

Attached: Sam&Frodo.jpg (716x423, 37K)

>distractingly obvious miniatures

Attached: 1563575506813.jpg (502x417, 15K)

>I wish the ring had never come to me
>I wish none of this had happened

everything good about it came from tolkien, nothing fran and peter added or changed was good. oh and nice job removing the scouring of the shire from rotk you new zealand faggots

We know this already, but it was still overall a very well executed adaptation

Attached: The Fellowship.jpg (1021x514, 209K)

Beta

Fellowship is the only one where I prefer the extended version. The rest drag on for far too long.

Well no, they managed to make Tolkien’s autistic and boring story for virgin nerds into something adventurous and exciting with a broad appeal.

>except for pipeweed being transformed into cannabis
that's how it was in the book.

>and nice job removing the scouring of the shire
the movie already has like five endings, we really didn't need a sixth

fucking this

read the books, then watch the movies, and then realise how they butchered the movies

nicotiana, appendix, faggot

You're baiting way too hard

>pipeweed transformed into cannabis
What happens in the movie to suggest this? It's not like Merry and Pippin are spaced out all the time and have the munchies. It's treated like regular tobacco smoking in the early 20th century.

They didn't butcher them. They adapted them. You can't copy every autistic detail Tolkien put in the books, and expect a good movie to come out.

It's not a 1:1 adaptation, but Fellowship is straight 10/10 as a film.

If you compare how the LOTR trilogy was executed compared to that of the Hobbit trilogy, you'll have a much larger appreciation for the LOTR films.

Don't call Tolkien an autist lmfao, the man was a genius

>I would have gone with you to the end. To ensure my taxes were met

i came away with a larger appreciation for jrr tolkien, since so far the only thing anyone's cited as good is dialogue from the books and they just did their own thing with the hobbit (which has atrocious dialogue, obviously penned by people who don't care about language, compared to, you know, a master philologist)

He was, I love his books, but there was a lot of things in the books that you can't translate to film.

Attached: tomBombandilTier.jpg (1075x823, 442K)

adding boromir's death to the climax of fellowship instead of the beginning of two towers was away better u fag

This movie is so nostalgic comfy. I never get bored watching it and it’s an adventure from beginning to end. Can’t say the same for Two Towers or RotK, or any of the Harry Potter films, each have points where I zone out and don’t care, but will say that the ending fight scene in Two Towers is best scene in the series