Which one was the best?

Which one was the best?

Attached: the-hobbit-series.jpg (1280x720, 114K)

Other urls found in this thread:

youtu.be/RHqh1P6U3Mk?t=163
youtube.com/watch?v=-1YVP3BRtXE
youtube.com/watch?v=r21yvykXVJo
youtube.com/watch?v=1cxSKSHeerI
youtube.com/watch?v=fVobrIVdJfE
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

the first

All of them it takes me back to Peter Jackson's slapstick comedy roots

All of those are posters for the third film.

Fellowship > Two Towers > Return of the King > Unexpected Journey > Desolation of Smaug > Five Armies

Peter Jackson is a hack and HP is better than LOTR

Only fellowship was kino. TTT was nice. Then it went to shit.

First one.
I wish PJ had made this with a couple years of pre-production, reduced to 2 movies, brought back practical effects and shot in 24 fps.

obviously not this movie, which was never supposed to exist and happened while bilbo was asleep. I'd say 2

first one was the best

>ROTK went to shit
I wish this meme ended.

rotk is capeshit of its time. all the subtlety of fellowship is gone.

Rohirrim Charge
le bow to no one

...

all 3 posters are terribad, any poster using the orange blue meme is a 0/10, and green fog on the third is some amateur tier photoshop

Found the redditor. HP had great entries as its third fourth fifth even sixth movie. Meanwhile you get Jackson hobbit tier shit appearing as early are return of the king and then the hobbit was actually even worse

Never attempt to even pretend like you know anything about films. I love Lotr and it's as overrated as can be. The lord of the rings movies are overrated and only fellowship was kino. Meanwhile the hp series is underrated and half the movies at least were kino.

But muh lotr muh precious quipping kill counts

Off yourself

cringe and bluepilled t,b,h,

Triggered the pleb
Back to IMDb

>Rohirrim Charge
Tacky
>le bow to no one
Tacky and cringe.

It's actually the truth you are either underaged or blind as a fucking bat.
"That still only counts as one"
"I'm no man"

First one deviated the least from the books so that one.

for frodo
beacons of gondor

Where did you think you were then?

Rohirrim charge, "I can't carry it for you, but I can carry you", "Here at the end of all things", the eagles rescuing frodo and sam, theoden's death, despair at end of battle and houses of healing, black gate speech and charge, grey havens, sam going back home (final scene)

There really needs to be a huge power gap between the hobbit movies and lotr trilogy.

>the scene with
>the contrarian faggot

Fuck off you fucking piece of nigger. Don't ever compare that woman's story to LOTR.

that deleted scene where Aragorn beheads Daisy Ridley

Hey faggot every single movie was directed by men and they did a better job than Hackson did with his 6 movies. Get fucked and die

>thinks lord of the rings is in any way deep or complicated
>thinks the return of the bing isnt capeshit
>is sexist
So incels really have dogshit taste in cinema and actually project their insecurities

ive seen all of them (lord of the rings and harry potter) many times and imo at their best the HP movies are as good as LOTR and all of them are better than the hobbit movies, but overall imo it goes
LOTR>HP>hobbit
whats your favorite harry potter movie?

>"I'm no man"
this was in the book, you shitter

My favorite potter movies change a lot.
My favorite lotr are Fellowship and TTT
Fav potter are probably 2 3 5 6 7.1

>Likes fucking HP
>Calls others redditors and plebs
Fucking hell, the absolute state of this board after the reddit invasion

>record for most oscars
Get fucked

dilate

All of them.

Attached: 1520636548526.jpg (1995x5184, 3.4M)

That line was staged, delivered and filmed in the most ultimate cringe way possible, we are talking about the movies.

"I'm no man" was Tolkien's jab at Macbeth

Lot of reddit trannies today, what's going on?

That doesn't make it any better.

user lotr is literally /r/ovies favorite series which is why this board acts like they are the I lynch great blockbusters. Shut the fuck up you dumb cuck, Cuaron is a way better director than Hackson and the latter potters btfo hobbit movies billions of times

no fuck off you are looking at it retroactively as if it were done in today's YAAASS KWEEEN over feminism antics. It's not. It was translated from a literary piece to a visual medium that plays on the whole point of the quibble

The only kino moments in Harry Potter were DEH, that scene in the third movie with the black kid who looks like Biggie Smalls and can't act, the scene where Dumbledore puts his wand to his throat and yells "NIIIIGGGGGEEEEEERRRRRSSS" and that scene from the first movie where the head comes out of the book and does a onions face.

>Oscar's
Black panther just won 3 Oscar's and was nominated for best picture. Guess that means it's great too. Wait no it doesn't

You're so fucking NPC you had to bring up the Oscar's. The worst lotr movie won the most Oscar's they mean nothing. Who the fuck do you think you are, shilling jewish awards? The lord of the rings was produced by Ggarvey and bob weinstein no shit they won oscars

>produce LOTR
>completely broke the fantasy genre by setting the bar too fucking high in which ALL fantasy movies are compared to LOTR and fail in comparison
>but muhh lotr is bad durr
Just stfu

>Knowing what reddit likes
Go back, and take your shitty reddit movies with you

>the only kino thing is this shit numale meme from cuckchan
Thanks for proving that hp filters plebs like you

Oscars lost its legitimately in the last 5 or 6 years, not 16 years ago

>muh lotr muh lotr muh lotr
Fucking as overrated as star wars at this point
Just stop even trying Jackson is a confirmed hack

>>thinks lord of the rings is in any way deep or complicated
explain to me in a short paragraph what you think lotr is about

Shut up, you lost, it's alright trannie

This is almost verbatim what it was supposed to be, but Del Taco dropped out at the last minute and the studio heavily pressured Jackson to make another trilogy

The Oscar's have been dogshit for 30 years or more you absolutely retard.
You're actually bluepilled and a fucking cuck

The one where you see Galadriel's bare feet up close.

Crash was over a decade ago and saving private ryan lost to Shakespeare in weinstein over 2 decades ago

Studio should have hold their horses and gave PJ what he needed.

Sorry you're so new you haven't realized this board is full of redditors posting about lord of the rings star wars and capeshit and pretending to not be plebs.

Reddit are bookfags, get some common sense paco

Prisoner of azkaban is pound for pound better than ttt or rotk

>ONE, NOTHING WRONG WITH ME

Attached: maxresdefault.jpg (1280x720, 80K)

They should remaster those movies by improving the CG and removing the dumb scenes

This. Chamber of Secrets was mesmerizing. Prisoner of Azkaban was great. Goblet of Fire was good except for the cringe Yule Ball scenes. Order of the Phoenix was great. Etc.

In all installments the OST was unbelievably great:
>youtu.be/RHqh1P6U3Mk?t=163
HP1: Where they first meet McGonagall
>youtube.com/watch?v=-1YVP3BRtXE
HP1: The invisibility cloak
>youtube.com/watch?v=r21yvykXVJo
HP2: Following the spiders
>youtube.com/watch?v=1cxSKSHeerI
HP3: Dementor in train
>youtube.com/watch?v=fVobrIVdJfE

I could go on.

LOTR did not have shit on that.

>for frodo
Absolute shit scene. And unfathomably bad acting.
>beacons of gondor
I agree and I did name that as the only good and immersive scene post Fellowship see
But that's the only good scene. And it was it Two Towers, not ROTK. ROTK had no good scene.

>Where did you think you were then?
In a cinema, watching a mediocre installment of a formerly promising film adaption.

>Rohirrim charge, "I can't carry it for you, but I can carry you", "Here at the end of all things", the eagles rescuing frodo and sam, theoden's death, despair at end of battle and houses of healing, black gate speech and charge, grey havens, sam going back home (final scene)

Ok gonna disagree with all of that. I found all of these scenes tacky, shitty, or plain bad.

second one

But people love Fellowship and that deviated from the books more than any of the hobbit ones

everything after 3 was shit, and at the 3rd it started to get iffy

and the amount of cut content in each movie made them unbearable for the me

1>2>3

also, extendeds are pleb choice

Attached: confusius.jpg (500x607, 52K)

>lord of the rings
>reddit
There's too many white people in it, reddit would absolutely hate it

Great post
You have such shit meme taste. Every movie after 3 is better than all series blockbuster this decade.

>he doesn't know
Try googling /r/movies 2017 poll

These OSTs fucking suck lmao, I seriously hope you guys don't actually think this shit sounds good

Fuck no, I'm not a redditor like you.

>bookfag
>complains about cut "content" that is nothing more than exposition or bloated storylines
Film isnt for you. The movies and books are great.

You're on this reddit board you fucking retard. You weren't even here two years ago apparently. Yea Forumss favorite movies from 2017 were identical to /r/movies

Stop thinking this place is somehow patrician

You eternal pleb, those OSTs are god tier

>Knows what reddit likes and obsesses over their polls
>Thinks he has the right to call anyone out on being reddit
Just go back, retard. HP sucks

>no retort
HP is great and filters the utter mouthbreatung retards like you who watch john wick tier shit and then only think lotr is a great blockbuster fuck off and die you utter mong

I know LOTR's OST is god tier, I am talking about hairy pooper's

I don't need to hear your redditor rage, go back to your home site and sip some more onions you faggot.

Do you like sounding NPC. You're a fucking loser dude. I've played both soundracks in orchestra and HP is better

Hackson is a shit director and lucked out early, go watch your kill count quipping and cliche monologues and call it keeno

The first movie is the best but the best moments happen to be in the 2nd and 3rd ones, it's just a shame they're bogged down by so much garbage.

>He likes HP, the literal fucking capeshit of it's time, a bunch of soulless corperate flicks thrown together for the sole purpose to make money off of a profitable book series
>Calls others NPCs
The absolute delusions of you soulless husks

Ask any director, critic, anyone with taste really if they think HP is better than LOTR, they'd laugh in your face. Your franchise is a fucking joke, people barely renember it because it fucking sucks. No matter how shit you think Jackson is, he is objectively more talented and skilled than anyone who ever worked on hairy pooper, obviously you are an NPC so you will deny this simple fact.

Holy fuck you project so much its unreal
The movies deviated from the books and every entry has it's own directors stamp on it. Every single fucking movie is made with more love and care than any other blockbuster this century besides lotr you elitist prick

Enjoy Jackson's stamp on those hobbit movies

You're a fucking plebshitter

Hey faggot you are NPC
8 good/great movies are better than 2 good/great movies

You're a fucking literal /r/movies cuck to critics and everyone else's NPC opinion

Lotr is overrated hp is vastly underrated

The fan cut

I like lord of the rings but holy shit you are actually an asshole. The series is remembered a ton and Alfonso Cuaron is way more talented than Hackson. Children of Men and Prisoner of Azkaban blow the fuck out of his directing style.

Ask anyone that isnt a fart sniffing incel like you and they will say the lord of the rings movies were way more boring and worse overall than the 8 Harry Potter movies that actually progressed in tone and filmmaking. Enjoy your walking movies.

The hobbit movies make return of the king worse than it already was. It's sad but true.

What we've learned about lotrfag
>when they can't defend Hackson they cite the old Oscars and critics as their only arguments
>if it isnt lotr its shit

upvoted fellow potterhead!

the first, as there was still some charm to it. With the exception of the last part with the white orc and the tree.

nice reddit tier post faggot

They have more soul than 99.9% of blockbusters, you must have sex

A reddit tier post would be circlejerking over MUH LOTR
Try again

the book

The irony of the lotrfag calling anything but lotr "soulless products" is that Christopher Tolkien thought the lotr movies were action flicks for 14 year olds and completely butchered the material

who?

Tolkien's son. The one other than the pedo preist

>Oscars
>mattering