Are there any Marxist films that aren't pretentious garbage? An actor reads some obscurantist Marxist text while looking into the camera and it uses terrible Brechtian techniques so the audience knows they are capitalist scum while also boring them to death. Are there any Marxist films that are not like this and of actual quality?
Are there any Marxist films that aren't pretentious garbage...
Jordan Gray
Other urls found in this thread:
en.wikipedia.org
twitter.com
Hunter Adams
No. Those movies are made rhat way because Marxism is a joke.
Chase Rogers
>mfw a central committee decrees how many toilets get made each year
Cameron Jackson
This. I think company CEO is right guy do this kinda big decisions
Alexander Jenkins
yes
Caleb Kelly
>gommies good
Lucas Stewart
Snowpiercer
Thomas Roberts
Marxism isn't a joke just the movies.
David Rogers
That's not Marxism that's Stalinism.
Xavier King
bump. when the art house general people gonna get in here
Lincoln Carter
Any movie about throwing commies from helicopters?
Jose Parker
Marxists ACTUALLY believe that all human behavior is purely the result of ECONOMIC FORCES.
They completely deny human biological instincts and believe they can change humanity completely simply by changing the economic system or "mode of production."
It's ridiculous word salad pseudoscience and these people are cultists.
Lucas Hughes
Wait so capitalism is biological then?
Alexander Price
You haven't read any marx have you
Xavier Gray
No that would be mean.
Austin Nguyen
no
Alexander Adams
No, but trading with people is a result of human biological instincts.
EVERY SINGLE FUCKING MARXISTS says this when you debunk their retarded ideology.
What I said is exactly what marx and marxists believe.
Easton Evans
Do you even know what dialectical materialism is?
but they aren't people
Easton Price
I'm not a Marxist tho, have you read any marx? Maybe you get told that often because you have no idea what you are talking about?
Joseph Williams
>What I said is exactly what marx and marxists believe.
Not only have you not read Marx, you haven't even read his fucking wikipedia page.
Capitalism =/= Markets =/= Trade. Capitalism is particular socio-economic system that only became hegemonic in the 17th-18th centuries.
Cooper Stewart
I don't even know what Marxism means anymore
John Jenkins
Anyone seen pic related? It's unintentionally hilarious because it's written as if every hippie socialist fantasy were true, so you get this sort of dissonance between reality and movie.
Jayden Sanchez
why do marxists hate jesus but worship every word marx wrote like it's holy gospel?
Ryan Martinez
>have you read any marx?
yes, plenty and I have debated with many marxists
they believe everything I just said, unironically
>Maybe you get told that often because you have no idea what you are talking about?
you are a marxist, aren't you?
>Capitalism =/= Markets =/= Trade. Capitalism is particular socio-economic system that only became hegemonic in the 17th-18th centuries.
No shit you gigantic brainlet.
This is according to the retard marx anyway.
All capitalism is in reality is simply an extension of humans trading with each other and owning property, which they have done for hundreds of thousands of years
even in tribal caves people had property
when larger communities formed, the division of labor and trade became necessary
its a religious cult
Xavier Williams
i dont think you are a person
Matthew Bailey
There are a lot of Christian communists including Jesus himself.
Elijah Anderson
but im not a commie,
therefore I am a person
Liam Morales
no you arent
Isaiah Walker
no u
Mason Stewart
>yes, plenty and I have debated with many marxists
You obviously haven't retard. I can tell your gonna give the fox news arguments against communism. You probably think Communism is state ownership. Give some arguments.
Zachary Williams
>owning property,
This is the distinction of what makes something capitalism and not. Private property and personal property are different things my friend.
Josiah Nelson
>You obviously haven't retard. I can tell your gonna give the fox news arguments against communism.
So far I've brought up dialectical materialism, the mode of production, and the marxist denial of biological instincts.
Awww, you were hoping I was going to give the typical "hitler was a socialist" and "the ussr was communism" arguments weren't you?
>You probably think Communism is state ownership.
According to the marxist religion, communism is the stage
after socialism and is stateless.
>Give some arguments.
Marxists ACTUALLY believe that all human behavior is purely the result of ECONOMIC FORCES. They completely deny human biological instincts and believe they can change humanity completely simply by changing the economic system or "mode of production."
They're wrong about this.
Marxists believe the capitalists are taking surplus value from the working class but they completely ignore the fact that taking over the means of production will not benefit the working class whatsoever because they already consume virtually all of the end product of economic production(consumer goods).
Taking over the factories won't increase the supply of goods they get to consume, prices would simply rise to adjust to this fact leaving them exactly where they are before.
Also marxists need to be oppressed by the state and banned from running for office.
Liam Butler
>Private property and personal property
retarded overly complex arbitrary property norms that nobody gives a shit about
I'm DESCRIBING human nature and you're PRESCRIBING an economic system for humans.
Dylan Cruz
Jack Adams
Zachary Hall
like i said fox news tier arguments. i only argue with people who show knowledge of the text. i am here to debate not explain.
Michael Thompson
>like i said fox news tier arguments
OH BOY
Look at this WEAK cop out.
What a fucking vagina.
You couldn't refute shit so you ran away with your tail between your legs.
Just close the tab.
Gabriel Wright
i don't know how i know this but en.wikipedia.org
ps. marxism is bad
Carter Cook
employees are now paid in stock instead of cash and have equal ownership of the business
walmart employees, which there are two million of, now hold 3.3 million shares of walmart equally distributed over 2 million people
now what
Henry Ortiz
literally anyone who reads your text will know you have no understanding. the only people who won't are the people who also don't know anything. i don't need to please you.