Which is the better AI romance

Her, only because it's the main focus of the film. Her is the most accurate depiction of the future I've seen in a film

Her is probably the cringiest cringe movie ever made

Attached: FA5F251C-DD43-4C29-A73F-E9D30F221C77.jpg (960x1440, 228K)

It's funny how BR2049 made a ten times more genuinely emotionally investing romantic story in just a side story of the film compared to Her where that's the entire film.

For most people the actual physical "love" part falls apart completely in Her, especially in any scene where the love part wants to be materialised (the prostitute sex scene, that sex scene where Joaquin just lays and talks to her) which come off as extremely cheesy and "quirky" which in result end up falling completely flat. Funny how there is the exact same concept of the threesome between an AI, a prostitute and a man in Her and literally no one ever talks about it because the execution of the scene is like any standard rom com flick, the AI part is completely secondary. Not to mention that in Her the prostitute is entirely meaningless in the act itself, while in BR2049 all it's a very character involving scene for all three characters, not just literally but in narrative terms also.
It's a physical manifestation of K's character development.

In short, Spike Jonze didn't know how to approach the concept of a man falling in love with a computer in a serious way so he had to make it extremely quirky to have an excuse for most scenes, while in BR2049 it's executed completely direct and tasteful with zero pretense at all.

Attached: Blade.Runner.2049.01_26_57.jpg (3840x1600, 2.24M)

A comfy future of desk jobs, AI and betas?
In what timeline do you live?
The future will be more like Children of Men.

Fuck! Do you have to ask? Her, of course.

BR2049 obviously, kino of the century

Her was reddit the film

Ye, Her felt kinda generic,
Too normie, afraid to show real losers, real loners and real ideas of interactions with virtual sentient women.
It was basically, AI people>singularity... and its over sooner than you realize, yet somehow still was a full lenght movie.

The romance in Blade Runner 2049 was completely unnecessary and non-essential to the plot.

br 2049 is reddit. fuck that blank canvas farthouse piece of shit. i could have written a better script in a week. please visit collative learning dot com for more info on br 2049 and your favorite movies.

2049
I don't want to watch a love movie about divorce

Her did the sex surrogate thing way better.

Her was an actual romance, BR2049 was one sided with canned responses.

>shilling your trash blog this shamelessly

"comfy"

The world is completely globalized, humans are isolated and alienated from the rest of society, widespread depression, divorce and breakups everywhere, escapism through technology, etc. Just because Her is more realistic and grounded in its depiction of the future doesn't make it sterile or generic, because the future of liberal democratic society will be exactly that, sterile and lifeless.

2049

t. female

I disagree. Joi was a physical extension of K's character development. What K yearned for, she expressed.
This was not used as a mere love story, but to further explore the nature of programming and the replicant condition, extending the relation from human-replicant from the first one to replicant-AI in the sequel.

No I have read people on here talking about the same experience when either film gets discussed. 2049 is also very lengthy.

Her, hit more close to home, AI waifus aren't as advanced as BR2049 ones

Her was an absolutely beautiful movie

The weird thing about Her is that it never goes into any sort of questions about how real the AI are. The movie just takes for granted that everyone treats them like a real person and excepts the audience to do the same. That makes it kind of boring because there's no tension that you couldn't get from any other romance story.

They could've done a lot more world building and show that not only are the characters lonely, but they're going against something that society would disapprove of. Ask questions about just how real the AI is. Then deal with the complexities of having a lover who doesn't have a body, then the AI could realize how limited humans are as romantic partners and go off to be sluts together.

the one that wasn't made by a major studio, has no cast members who were A-listers at the time, and featured actual discussion of AI instead of just a load of entry level wank.

Attached: ex machina.jpg (770x443, 95K)

um..are you baiting?

Based and Alitapilled

No. Her sort of dabbles in metaphysical questions, but I don't think it tried hard enough.

that's not a "weird thing" it's because Her isn't about AI. it's an allegory for how the internet and computers have replaced relationships.

Based
I was enjoying this movie until the dance scene, at which point I realised that I was watching true AIKino

You’re missing the point. The entire focus of the movie is that being in love with an AI isn’t taboo in that society. Nobody is bothered or perplexed by it, they actively encourage it even though it’s visibly damaging

>They could've done a lot more world building and show that not only are the characters lonely, but they're going against something that society would disapprove of
The tries to take an intimate look at their main characters, worldbuilding and the general future are only hinted at in the background, because it's all about the actual people and their relationships, thats why his ex wife is the only one who disapproves of him dating an AI, because they have an emotional history which compels her to do so. the future is painted in a positive light and other people are generally helpful or at least neutral, everyone seems to be rather well off and the real difficulties in life stem from his inability to mature and deal with his own relationship hangups, its all about that.
complex questions of metaphysical realities are just enough hinted at to not get in the way of telling their relationship story, which is completely fine imho because the film never aimed to answer those questions in the first place