What does Yea Forums thinks of David Lynch's Dune?
What does Yea Forums thinks of David Lynch's Dune?
Samuel Young
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
youtube.com
twitter.com
Ryan Ramirez
probably the same thing the guy on youtube told them to think
Levi Foster
unreadable book
unwatchable movie
Nathan Reyes
(OP)
It's the best version and anyone who disagrees or is confused by is a genetic defect.
Carter Brown
not a good adaptation of the book. the things it invented weren't great. the things it adapted were hit or miss. I enjoy it but I love the book and view it as mostly unrelated.
Leo Cox
Why does it add "OP" when I edit? I am not OP.
>unreadable book
>unwatchable movie
>identifies as a literal mongrel dumbass
Checks out.
William Moore
Bad adaptation in many respects but still kino, the Baron is great and Paul is perfectly cast, and that's not even getting into the Lady Jessica
Jeremiah Kelly
its fucking awful
lynch tries to blame the studio for it but its his fucking fault
Nolan Hughes
Only dumb people don't "get" the plot or are offended by the internal monologue. Based Lynch made THE NPC movie filters for the ages.
Jeremiah Campbell
unwatchable
Kayden Brown
tryhard magnet, an excellent way to distinguish between a poser and a true connoisseur
Nathaniel Diaz
internal dialogue, the movie
Matthew Morales
*blocks your path*
Logan Long
Wasn't the internal monologue something Lynch was against and they added it during final cut, once he no longer had control?
Landon Campbell
David Lynch seems to hate it but I think there’s a lot of redeeming qualities.
Eli Wood
>its suppose to be bad
no, fuck off
Parker Williams
Lady Jessica a cute
Connor Flores
>I'm a brainlet but havent realized yet
Anthony Taylor
the 3 hour cut is kino, the theatrical version is horrible.
Dylan Morgan
I always loved Dune. But it was released when critics had more power than they deserved. It would probably be well received if it was released now. And if you slapped a marvel or Star Wars logo on it’d be a hit.
It’s only flaw was bad affects.
Dominic King
I doubt it since he signs off on the rights for Dune 1984 time and time again. He just disowns the TV version. I prefer the TV version, but his condensed version is OK too.
Yyyyyyyyyy-ikes! *explodes a soiboi somewhere*
Parker Fisher
The miniseries was god awful. People just pretend it’s good because critics told them the lunch movie was bad.
Tyler Jenkins
got the atmosphere right
something that villeneuve has no hope to achieve
Owen Clark
the soundtrack was amazing, Brian Eno is kino.
Leo Moore
Visually interesting but narratively broken. They tried to stuff too much into a single movie.
Christopher Walker
Faggot! Aids Carrying Swine!
Aaron Williams
it's ok but the sci-fi channel miniseries remains the best adaptation despite the now dated CGI
this guy knows what's up based
Cameron Martinez
>t. guy whose never watched it
Thomas Cooper
The soundtrack alone made this film
youtube.com
Aaron Edwards
i love it, but it's a mess.
Thomas Brown
Garbage adaption of the book. Probably the most experimental blockbuster of all time. If I wasnt such a fan of the book I would of had no fucking clue what was going on
Zachary Rogers
Lynch should have gone and adapted God Emperor of Dune instead. One of the weirdest sci-fi novels ever written, adapted by one of the weirdest film-makers.
It would have been pure arthouse.
Adam Williams
ITT: literal morons who can't appreciate a masterpiece because the inner monologue interferes with their phoneposting
Julian Jackson
Everything by Lynch is shit.
Lincoln Lewis
Kino
James Morris
f(x)=x^3 where x is your rating of Dune between 0-10 and f(x) is your IQ
Carter Martinez
Great casting
Great costumes
Patchy at best SFX
Interesting music
Bad pacing
Landon Powell
Westwood studios has made the only good Dune adaptions. They even got John Malkovich to play a role.
Josiah Wright
based grid user
Thomas Russell
5 star post
Liam Bennett
I literally watched it last week. Hurt is phoning it in, the sets look like a kids tv show, the CGI is bad even for the sci-fi channel, the only good things are the performances of the baron and Alia.
Children of Dune was a bit better but way too condensed.
Alexander Gutierrez
Yea Forums will think that it's either complete shit or utter genius, as with anything else.
I think it's an enjoyable movie that tries a lot of stuff, with some hits and plenty of misses.
It's never going to be your favorite movie, but I recommend you at least give it a go.