/got/

Visenya >>>>>> Rhaenys

Who the fucking cares?

A good ending doesn't depend on getting the better political system.

A good ending depends on making libtards crying the most.

I was expecting some progressive utopia shit that doesn't make any sense. By comparision this is diamonds.

Dracofucker got mad, that was a nice twist.

The rest is shit. But what do you expected?

>8000 years of feudalism
Burn them all. Burn them in their homes, burn them in their beds.

Which one was the one the guy fucked 10 times more?

Attached: 1557009402346.png (1920x1080, 111K)

Do boltons next

>"Which boy?"
>"Jon Snow. When my husband brought that baby home from the war, I couldn't bear to look at him. I didn't want to see those brown stranger's eyes staring up at me.
>So I prayed to the gods, take him away. Make him die. He got the pox. And I knew I was the worst woman who ever lived. A murderer. I'd condemned this poor, innocent child to a horrible death all because I was jealous of his mother. A woman he didn't even know. So I prayed to all seven gods, let the boy live. Let him live and I'll love him. I'll be a mother to him. I'll beg my husband to give him a true name, to call him Stark and be done with it, to make him one of us."
>"And he lived?"
>"And he lived. And I couldn't keep my promise. And everything that's happened since then all this horror that's come to my family it's all because I couldn't love a motherless child."

Fuck Cat "It should have been you" Littlefinger

Indeed the cutest
Cutest

Attached: 1561234616275.png (2048x1365, 3.58M)

>I was expecting some progressive utopia shit that doesn't make any sense. By comparision this is diamonds.
Did you watch the ending? A new king is elected for no reason by people who have no reason to elect him. The Unsullied peacefully leave Westeros. The Dothraki peacefully integrate into Westerosi culture. That makes sense to you?

>A good ending depends on making libtards crying the most.
7/10 bait almost got me, the Reddit spacing pushed It though

Attached: 1561828514094.jpg (1050x1236, 63K)

based as fuck

Attached: House-Baratheon-Main-Shield.PNG.png (400x480, 33K)

did they ever all fuck at the same time?

Attached: office-space-images-gary-5c7595d130e24.jpg (1024x776, 62K)

*surpasses kino*

Attached: tenor.gif (640x350, 2.81M)

I would've preferred an ending that makes libtards mad and was also b+rp

Attached: 1558030177808.jpg (609x1445, 566K)

So much in denial. Your tears taste sweet

If you get the opportunity, you should probably kill yourself.

Truly a based post.

Attached: emilia.jpg (2016x2685, 545K)

>A good ending depends on making libtards crying the most.
That is shit criteria and you literally said it's also a good ending as if besides the liberal butthurt you liked it. So you literally only think it's good because Daenerys died?. LMAO. Fuck out of here

Are you complaining of things making sense in a show about fire breathing dragons?

This is gold.

117381190
>confirmed baitposter
Fuck off. No (you) 4u

C'mon he got a point. Who is going to decide the king then?

Ending is a grey one. It ends with the tyrannical House Targaryen extinct, yet one of them is using the body of Bran Stark as a vessel. Lots of sequel potential from what I can see.

>"And he lived. And I couldn't keep my promise. And everything that's happened since then all this horror that's come to my family it's all because I couldn't love a motherless child."
Literally why didn't Ned say anything? How could Ned not see the the common fucking sense in telling his own fucking wife the deal?
Especially AFTER the dumbass decides to join the watch?

This dumb fuck thinks the show only got backlash AFTER Daenerys burned down King's Landing. People were downvoting episode 4 before it even aired solely because of how The Long Night was handled, but he thinks that people only started to complain after Dany burned down King's Landing.
The show and the books didn't gain traction just because of zombies or fire breathing dragons. They played a minimum role, for the most part, in the early season. People were drawn in by the characters and the politics.

You don't even know what you are talking about. You are stupid enough to be one of the writers with your moronic logic.

Sorry, that's all I got :(

Sansa

Attached: cq5dam.web.1200.675.0.jpg (1200x800, 99K)

Friendly reminder people were already jumping ship about the NK. They just had a little goodwill left from the past seasons to give the show the benefit of the doubt. Had you switch the events, the NK episode would likely have been absolutely destroyed once the goodwill was lost.

Attached: D7H6vmsVsAAmJuk.jpg large.jpg (1080x1080, 157K)

Do not reply to bait or baitposters. Ignore and hide baitposts

Bran was trying to be minister of propaganda and guide the new world order, but Jon fucked up his plan. He improvised a quick political solution with no long term viability to stall for time

>"It should have been you"
So she could watch Ned pout and watch over Jon's comatose body while muttering about muh family and honor as if Arya and Robb also wouldn't be there every chance they could?

It's impressive that they managed to get basically everyone to hate S8 by the end considering that, in general, 5-7 seem to be regarded as highly as the first 4 despite the massive quality drop.

Bravo Dabid. Seriously.

BIG backlash. People were complainig softly about the drop in quality, but the nerdrage...

It's actually nerdrage? Should it be s.oyrage?

It only really started after their white liberal Mary Sue turned out to be Kim Il Sung.

The fact you get so mad about this only proofs it. You cannot stand someone telling the truth. You would have been ok with the show if your liberal heroine would have done what you thought she was going to do. Be the yass queen of a liberal brown utopia.

>inb4 dinkledge wins another emmy for s8e6

A for effort, but you're pissing into the wind.

Because Jon realized he was a Stark and Branraven was bullshitting him. Bloodraven realized he was fucked because there was no male Targaryen living to continue the incel incest dynasty, so he literally made one up to get Dany ready for breeding, by presenting the "claim" that Jon Snow is a Targaryen born out of Rhaegar and Lyanna. The timeline all fit for Bloodraven's plans. In the sequel, Gendry and Davos will learn all of this after Davos breaks from the mind control and remembers he loves Stannis and so must protect his legacy.

It'll be kino.

Attached: 0e3a024474b348a60273d6989ee4aee5.jpg (1278x1920, 347K)

So critics were giving it a 92% positive in season 8?

And that's supposed to support your point?

There is no jumping ship just one episode before mad queen slayer, and saying that people were upset about the quality.

>muh family

Attached: 220px-Tywin_Lannister_Profile_Charles_Dance.jpg (220x315, 21K)

Because people were never mad about the quality.
Ok, episode 5 was mishandled, but the thing that made them mad was episode 5.

more like
>muh legacy

It's not a grey one at all, at least that's not what's being presented to you. It's grey because you listened to fan theories and have pieced together your own head canon by assuming the plot holes and inconsistencies are some sort of grander story telling technique by Dabid, like many S8 apologists.

A lot of the dialogue indicates D&D thought this was a happy ending and the wheel or whatever is broken. Everyone got the ending they wanted and the only person that really paid for it was Daenerys who they put all his comical Nazi imagery to like other movies/shows where there's comically evil bad guys.

The only thing I concede is that without siblings to fuck the Targaryen might go stinct.

But that can be said about most houses of GoT.

>Davos and Gendry journey beyond the damaged Wall to meet with Jon
>"I'm retired."
>"No Jon shut the fuck up, we have good news, you don't have to want it because you never had it."
>Jon stands up, picking up Longclaw and smiles a big grin, first time in his life since Ygritte.
>"Let's do this."

Attached: Cl_IXz9XEAA2b_V.jpg (1200x675, 38K)

>no lewds of Nymeria
trash it goes

Attached: 1430502435-got504-080714-hs-dsc-2832.jpg (2100x1398, 220K)

>BIG backlash. People were complainig softly about the drop in quality, but the nerdrage...
You're lying again. You are so blinded by your politics that you can't see the big picture. People complained about this show's drop in quality for FOUR FUCKING YEARS before The Long Night even aired. After that episode aired, the next episode--the one before Daenerys even burned down King's Landing--was preemptively downvoted.

You are so obsessed with Daenerys that you can't even understand why people would hate the show despite her.
>It only really started after their white liberal Mary Sue turned out to be Kim Il Sung.
What about the other female Mary Sue's who get everything they wanted? Or are you so obsessed with Dany that the other two don't count?
>The fact you get so mad about this only proofs it.
The fact that you are honestly trying to make an argument that the ONLY reason people hate season 8 is because of Dany's characterization, shows how butthurt and obsessed you are.
>You would have been ok with the show if your liberal heroine would have done what you thought she was going to do.
Lying and projecting. You have no idea when I started hating the show.
>Be the yass queen of a liberal brown utopia.
The show had the brown people--the ones you hate so much--peacefully integrating into Westeros. Did you watch the ending?

Dany kinda forgot was the big meme that everyone was mad about at first. Real niggas dropped the show after the night king died

Attached: 220px-The_Night_King_at_Hardhome.jpg (220x261, 21K)

>So critics were giving it a 92% positive in season 8?
For one episode. You are incapable of making an honest argument.

Hitler represented excessive order. She represented excessive chaos.

>Peole complaining four years
>Someone has just post the RT ratings of the show, 92% fresh
>Accuses others of lying
Son, I...

She deserved it considering she was evil since Season 1. Seasons 6-8 were fucking terrible, but a few parts were good that stood out. The based Tommen, High Sparrow, Kevan and Mace Tyrell scenes, the references to Stannis like showing his aesthetic banner. Euron Greyjoy was also pretty based, and unironically the first Chad we had on the show since Bobby B.
But the best part, the greatest part, is how D&D decided to pull through and reveal Dany for the villain that she was. Ours is the last laugh.

Attached: protect his smile.png (500x707, 896K)

Is this real? Seems like a good ending.

>reddit spacings
And do you know how to read, you fucking retard? NK episode got a 75%. It became one of the lower scoring episodes in series history considering the overall series is usually around 90%. After that, people had no more goodwill for this series and gave it the scores episode 3 would've gotten if people didn't still have just a little goodwill left.

That was from the first episode, not the entire season. You're lying again.

It's not me the one that is obsessed about Daenerys.

I didn't named my daughter after her like you stupid libruls!

How many people named her daughter Samsa?

Who even cares about that character or the other one?

None cares!

You pretend to care so you don't have to admit what a major fuckup this series was and how much a waste of time it was for you. You thought you were watching an empowered modern fantasy about diversity and inclusion and it turned out to be just a generic medieval fantasy and you cannot admit it and lie to yourself telling that it is still kosher.

It isn't peanuts doesn't make for the fact that your heroine turned out to be a genocidal maniac like all your socialist revolutionary heroes.

Yara Greyjoy is such a lewd fucking cunt! With that cheeky bong look and mean face. So horny! I want to be her slave.

Attached: yara.jpg (236x326, 15K)

>Euron
>Chad
>begged cersei for a crumb of pussy, got cucked by Jaime, realized it, fought for cersei anyway, got his fleet btfo, got washed by an old one handed Jaime lannister

It's storytelling basics 101.
If you build up hype about an antagonist you can't make him die like a punk with minimal screen time.

More fun. Just to put season 8 into perspective.

Attached: D7SPxVPX4AAwZLt.jpg large.jpg (1080x1080, 162K)

Excuse me 88% and 75%.
And you say I'm lying.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

I FUCKING SAID TO STOP REPLYING TO BAIT AND BAITPOSTERS.

NO MORE (YOU)S

Attached: gallery-1465217549-hbz-got-yara.png (768x423, 360K)

Even whith an awful episode like this still had 75% fresh rating? That's your point?

Sapochnik's episode, people were sure it'd be one of the highest scoring episodes of all time on television and it scored below average everywhere with respects to the rest of the series. Episode 3 had to have been shit for that to have happened.

Attached: 1433369224787.jpg (545x567, 56K)

>what could be sexier than that?

t. Tris Botley

94% fresh Season 6
93% fresh Season 7

>I-It's about the quality user!!

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!

How was she evil? If she betrayed Jon sure, but she never did anything to anyone, they betrayed her. So what she sacked a city in a war

Yes it is, retard, when the rest of the series was averaging about 94%. Are you proud to have 75% when most of your class averages out at about 94%. And also consider this, you only got 75% because your teacher felt empathetic towards you, not that you truly would've gotten it if they didn't.

>I will "liberate" all cities after this one
Much evil and murder. Communism bad!

It’s gonna be really lame 6 months from now when people start revisiting this episode and arguing that it could “never have lived up to the hype”.
Theres going to be a whole group of revisionists who will argue The Short Night was one of the GOAT episodes and people just couldn’t deal...probably just because Arya killed him.
Even if they’re only spreading that view because the networks have gone on break for Xmas and theres nothing to write about.

>We All Need to Give The Long Night Another Chance

So people were complaining about the drop in quality for years by giving it 94% fresh ratings?

Communism good.

Attached: 706_Dragons_Army_of_the_Dead.jpg (1920x1080, 340K)

What are you talking about, westeros is still in feudalism, communism doesn't exist yet, she's more like an absolutist monarch or an empress

Yes, I am still saying you are lying. You still haven't posted the score for the next episode. Dany didn't burn down King's Landing in that one either.

Come on, "Mr. 92%." What's the score for the next episode?

Stop freeing slaves

Attached: 971378BA-3BF5-4812-8A4C-BF07CBA83FE8.jpg (446x293, 21K)

Bargaining.

Then comes depression.

Attached: GRIS___Screen_10.png (1920x1080, 2.47M)

That's the very bad one of the undeads. But I wonder how many critics changed their previous critic after seeing murderqueen. Still it didn't spawned many articles in the media as killprog murder spree did.

The night king absolutely should have won. You can have the mad queen danaerys thing if you want it's fine, just have it happen before the long night

Attached: come-join-us-ight-king-our-grieving-continues-55906580.png (500x567, 158K)

>S1 rated so low

Attached: 1344802573990.png (353x399, 212K)

Who made the best Night King figure?

Attached: apiqhc4ec__88674.1548096845.jpg (1280x1114, 226K)

when bobby dies the ratings dropped

Still lying. Still moving goalposts. Still engaging in revisionist history. Plenty of people in these generals don't like Daenerys, but it takes a special kind of retard to claim, with a straight fucking face, that the backlash against the show in the final season was because of how Dany's arc was handled.

You threw out ALL the other logical inconsistencies, continuity errors, character assassinations, etc., to fit your narrative. Then, you try to tell other people that the ending is good because one character you do not like got a bad ending. And then you say that everybody who disagrees is a "librul."

Muh promise

That makes sense. Bobby B was larger than life.

Attached: ROBERT.jpg (1280x720, 382K)

The sisters slept in separate beds so probably not

hi

Fuck this stupid sappy speech, so out of character for her

You are wrong in the first part and mostly right in the second.

But I don't do it to fit a narrative. I do it because it's true.

YOU might be mad bacause all those other things. Or not. But that's not what drove most people mad, that's not the reason they asked to change THE LAST SEASON and only the last season.

They were not mad about the drop in quality before, hell Season 6 & 7 are better rated than 1. People disliked episode 4 because it was a rushed and etc, but what made them go mad about GoT was episode 5. Handled other way you would have not had not even half the fuss, people would have complained the drop in quality but critics would have given the series 88% and 75% as before. Hey maybe even 94% like the two previous seasons.

hey

So a council of white men took over the kingdom and deported all the brown people, what more did you want exactly?

That speech is show only right? She was such a bitch, I’m glad she died thinking Arya was dead too and that Sansa was getting dicked by the imp.

she wanted to bring order to the world

3, 5, and 6 are the unholy trinity of shitty got episodes

People are telling me they integrated.
Who is lying to me?

Attached: Who is jewing who.png (212x238, 12K)

>deported all the brown people
Not that user but Dothraki were never sent away, Grey Worm only took the Unsullied. That army of rapists who refuse to plow the field are still in Westeros.

Only the unsullied left who were never really a problem, the dothraki are out destroying and pillaging, westeros is going to shit in the future, who cares what color her army is she was keeping them in line

I disagree. Only 3 and 6 are bad. 5 is golden. It's a duopoly.

The Virgin Rhaenys
>no talents other than sucking cocks
>submissive and boring
>turboslut that fucked half of Westeros
>gave birth to beta Aenys
>rode a jobber dragon
>killed by Dorniggers

The Chad Visenya
>renowed warrior that wielded the greatest Valyrian Steel sword in history
>showed dominance to Aegon which is why he was scared of spending nights with her (probably pegged him)
>only diddled kids to take their kingdoms
>gave birth to alpha Maegor
>rode a huge ass dragon that lived all the way until the Dance of Dragons
>died of old age being her son's closest advisor

Attached: visenya conquers the vale.jpg (1366x768, 134K)

Just calibrate your tv bro its the long night not the bright night lmaoooo

People said me they integrated peacefully and that makes the show still progressive.

Did they lied to me?

They also said to me Samsa, not Daenerys, is the character librul white woman actually identify with.

5 is like a 80 minute slog, broken up by Cleganebowl fanservice (they ruined Cleganebowl somehow), goblin running around getting killed like 10 times but still surviving, absurd plot holes, hilariously bad stuff like Arya and the horse or Euron dying, it's worse than a transformers movie

Ned promised to keep jon safe, telling him the truth of his birth while he intends to throw his life away to the ((((noble)))) Nights Watch does not conflict with that.
Ned 'honor is all' Stark was a liar and a cunt who ruined Jons life for his own cowardice the second he refused to confront Jon/Tywin/Robert over the murder Targ kids

>5 is golden
>Jaime goes back to Cersei
>Jaime fights Euron for no fucking reason
>Tyrion refuses to mention the secret entrance to the Red Keep to Jon or Daenerys
>but tells Davos to leave a boat there for Jaime to use to get away
>Tyrion still cares for Cersei despite everything she's done
>Arya turns back at the last possible minute and suffers no consequences for it or any of the violent murders she's committed
>Cleganebowl is shit
>Mountain suddenly cares about fighting Hound despite having met and been taunted by him at the dragonpit
>bells suddenly mean surrender and everyone knows it
>dozens of ballistas are suddenly useless
>Cersei continues doing nothing but staring out a window sipping wine
>show expects us to suddenly care about smallfolk who next episode no one really cares about and who are right back by the time Jon sails North
Fuck off

>I heard that you are getting the gang back together

Attached: robin-arryn-game-of-thrones-ftr.jpg (620x349, 119K)

I like some transformer movies user. I just fast forward Shia LaBeouf and watch the robot fights.

5 is dogshit and the writers can barely explain most of what even happened afterward. A number of characters literally drop their IQs to that of a potato in order to move the plot forward. There's no consistency with the scorpions with just the last episode. And while we're at it, episode 4 also went full retard in the second half and some of the first half.

No.

I don't watch transformers movies so my bad user just making a quick comparison, there's probably way more plot to a transformers movie per minutes screentime than in that episode

Lmao

Mfw no cut of Season 5 which removes the Dorne and Arya Plots

>YOU might be mad bacause all those other things. Or not. But that's not what drove most people mad, that's not the reason they asked to change THE LAST SEASON and only the last season.
You're lying AGAIN. I cannot fucking believe how delusional you are.
>They were not mad about the drop in quality before
Lying. Did you miss all those memes complaining about the drop in quality after season 4?
>People disliked episode 4 because it was a rushed and etc, but what made them go mad about GoT was episode 5.
People also disliked episode 3 because it was rushed and nonsensical. People downvoted episode 4 because episode 3 was so shit. All of this was before Daenerys burned down King's Landing.
>Handled other way you would have not had not even half the fuss, people would have complained the drop in quality but critics would have given the series 88% and 75% as before. Hey maybe even 94% like the two previous seasons.
Pure. Fucking. Conjecture. You also act like Dany's plot was the only thing that happened that episode. People didn't like how Cleganebowl, Jaime, Cersei, Arya, that fucking horse, etc., were handled, but you single out Daenerys because you hate Daenerys.

There are plenty of reasons to hate the final season outside of how Dany was handled. You are simply obsessed with her, so you created a fantasy land in your mind where all the normies were on board until Dany burnt down King's Landing. We can keep going back and forth until one of us gets bored, but I don't accept your narrative. You overdosed on whatever political pill you took, so you are incapable of looking at the series as an actual fan of the series.

Bran too. Oh wait he wasn't even in that season at all because his story had nothing going on.

Arya plot didn't become shit until S6

Dude, people are posting the RT ratings. Stop being delusional.

I really shouldn't answer to obvious trolls like the user before advised.

Mfw no cut of season 6 and 7 which removes the Sam plot

Don't forget Littlefinger sending his waifu to get raped just so we could have le edgy rape scene

How am I being delusional? The RT scores got worse and worse BEFORE Dany burned down King's Landing.

You might legitimately be retarded.

As far as Ned was concerned Bobby was the rightful king and Jon was better off never knowing that he was the rightful Targ heir.

Stop or you will end up with just the season 1 comercials.

>Winter is coming

It was a nice catchphrase

>Not liking the Randyll Tarly dinner scene

>They also said to me Samsa, not Daenerys, is the character librul white woman actually identify with.
They identify with both. If not for Sansa, the ratings would've been even lower.

The Dothraki kinda forgot that they were murdering rapist pillagers, they were for the battle in Ep 5 but then they decided they were just gonna be peaceful after their khal got murdered when last time they descended into anarchy. They have one cheeky shot of them just walking along the docks like tourists in the last episode. They're literally Mongol warlords lmao.

>Did you miss all those memes complaining about the drop in quality after season 4?
Season 5 - 93% fresh
Season 6 - 94% fresh
Season 7 - 93% fresh

Wow. Are you stupid or a troll?

Tyrells did nothing wrong

Attached: 1561364225631.png (472x624, 94K)

The RT ratings don't help your argument, retard-kun. The only reason the show hadn't cratered at episode 3 on RT was because people spent 10 years watching this shit and hoped the showrunners could perhaps recover, so they weren't being as honest as they could've been. If they were truly honest, that shit would've gotten a score in the 50s but only because it had fuck huge battle.

You want to show brown foreigners as blood thirsty rapists in a 2019 show?

Rhaenys was hotter, so she wins.

They supported Renly's non-existent claim and then Joffrey's

Yeah. Did the show include the it should have been you when jon went to say good bye to bran?

>She was such a bitch
wow rude user

She only ruined the life a child she had nothing to do with despite literally everyone acknowledging the bastard as just that with no claim, started the war of the 5 kings based exclusively on the word of Petyr 'remember how you let chad suck your toes veronica?' Belish, Did literally nothing while her sister (who helped start the war/encouraged Ned to go south) sat by and let her entire family get slaughtered by lannisters, and then traded Jamie 'Never once broke an Oath or slew his king' Lannister with a single guard for Sansa and Arya (who no one has seen alive since Ned, her HUSBAND, WAS MURDERED) in direct conflict with her king's orders.

But at least she promised the marriage of the King of the Norf/Vale/Riverlands to a Frey for the sake of 1 (one) bridge.

COME WITH ME AND TAKE THIS REALM

Attached: game-of-thrones-white-walker-king.0.jpg (1200x800, 128K)

She won getting raped by a thousand dornigger dicks

I suppose that's why as much women named her adopted black daughter Samsa as daenerys.

You wouldn't lie to me. Would you user?

So they actually peacefully integrated or they went full rapist? You are confusing me.

No, she just tells him to get out.

citation needed

I'm not going to get in this side argument with you. The last season was rated worse and worse OVERALL (not just by RT critics scores) before episode 5 came out. Your narrative doesn't work. Oh, and those violent brown people you hate so much? They integrated into Westeros without a hitch, as per the finale.

That was just one bad episode. As you say if Daenerys wasn't gone full Guevara on a faggot's club, people would have gave 75% or more no matter how bad.

>She only ruined the life a child she had nothing to do with despite literally everyone acknowledging the bastard as just that with no claim
Worst part is that her hatred for Jon was fueled by a completely retarded headcanon of Ned loving Jon's mom more than her because that's the only reason she could think of to why he would do the honorable thing and raise "his child" as his child

They integrated peacefully, here they are after they apparently decided to just start living in Westeros. They also couldn't resist have a cringe moment where Davos suggests the dickless Unsullied start their own house in the Reach on the land that's now empty after all the white people died.

Attached: dothraki.jpg (1366x768, 82K)

You look sick. It's contagious?

>Ned was concerned Bobby was the rightful king
He literally wasn't, Ned could have taken the Throne if he wanted/encouraged to but refused for muh norf and the disgust with Jon for advocating the marriage of lannister to Robert "I just see dragonspawn Ned xD" baratheon.

>Jon was better off never knowing that he was the rightful Targ heir.
>My bastard son who has lived his entire life trying to be a good son to me and a brother to all his siblings, even the ones who hate him, doesn't deserve to know that his mother wasn't just some whore I fucked and was killed during the rebellion, despite going off to pledge himself to an organization that forces him to give up all claims.
Eddard 'A good man' Stark

At first I thought Ned was just being autistic by not telling Cat the truth, but if you look back at her character she's clearly very untrustworthy. Sucks for Ned

>Are you complaining of things making sense in a show about fire breathing dragons?
This is literally the dumbest line of argument in all of sci-fi and fantasy. The fact that your story includes fanciful elements does not give you free rein to have it make no sense and obey no internal rules of logic.

I'm not going to get in this side argument with you.
Because you call me lier and I proved you are the only lier. You were the one that brought this point and suddendly you don't want to speak about it.

Where did they get their clothes from?

Attached: WW-fight.jpg (1536x864, 172K)

>Look at Chilly thinking he is hot stuff for leading a pointless suicide mission. We didn't even give him any armor

Attached: Night King.jpg (1200x800, 163K)

>Jon tells Sansa
>Stupid Tully thot immediately exposes the secret that Ned kept for decades that literally ruined Jon's life and made Cat hate him
I agree with you, but you never know with Crazy Cat. She started a civil war on an impulse.

anyone else looking forward to the ASOIAF mods for Bannerlord?

They killed millions

Attached: Catelyn-Stark-and-Lysa-Arryn-catelyn-tully-stark-24450786-1753-1068.jpg (1753x1068, 165K)

Ned still pretended that Bobby's claim was true according to all laws and gods for the rest of history which is why he supported Stannis

Only the occasional gang rape I suppose. Ttotally worth it for all the doctors and scientists they are going to provide Westeros. They will pay Westerosi pensions too.

Attached: moro-posa3.jpg (600x634, 77K)

>That was just one bad episode.
The last four episodes were bad episodes. You are so obsessed with Daenerys that you can't even comprehend why people would dislike the last season regardless of her.
You cannot comprehend the English language. I didn't bring up the RT score first, but I will point out a bullshit artist who tries to claim that everybody loved the last season up until Dany burned down King's Landing, and then points to the first THREE (not FOUR) episodes' RT ratings as proof.

Just because you are obsessed with Daenerys doesn't mean that people weren't mad about how everything else was handled this season. Cope and go back to your politics board. This thread is about Game of Thrones and A Song of Ice & Fire.

>to all his siblings, even the ones who hate him
You mean Sansa?

>You mean Sansa?
Yes. I recall something with bran/rickon pre-direwolves, and then Theon 'also a stark' as well

Cringe

Attached: Untitled96.png (932x657, 79K)

>White Walkers got better action in a 20 minute sequence in an episode about a one sided massacre than in the 90 minute episode dedicated exclusively to ending the White Walker threat.

She didn't hate him she was just rude

>I didn't bring up the RT score first
Why are you such a liar?
>Did you miss all those memes complaining about the drop in quality after season 4?

Lie, lies and more lies.

Who Milisandre best girl?

Attached: Old Melisandre.jpg (3451x2100, 2.59M)

>So they actually peacefully integrated or they went full rapist?
Did you watch the last episode? The Dothraki were seen on the docks of King's Landing peacefully going about their business. There was no hint that they left Westeros and there was no hint that they caused any trouble.

The narrative that the "liberul feminist with brown people fails" falls apart completely when one realizes that she got the brown people to come to Westeros, and there is no mention of them causing trouble.

Seriously, did Lysa get no fucking comeuppance for letting for family get murdered/taken hostage by Lannisters? Even after the Red Wedding? I mean how fucking long was Riverrun undersiege by Freyshits until Jamie rolled up?
And for what? The delusion that she/Robyn would be ignored/treated fairly after the war ends by the same people who MURDERED THE REST OF HER FAMILY?
A fucking disgrace, at best robyn would be stuff with a lanny broodmare if not outright replaced.

It's better to ignore sansafags if you want to keep your sanity

See:
>Dude, people are posting the RT ratings. Stop being delusional.

D&D said they leave, that's why they're on the docks

It's magic just like dragons.

Bran always loved Jon
>Bran saw his father’s face change, saw the other men exchange glances. He loved Jon with all his heart at that moment.

Rickon is irrelevant

Theon ain't a Stark but he disliked Jon for being a grumpy bastard

Why are you presuming they all remained. Just because there a re a couple in the docks in one scene?

>Seriously, did Lysa get no fucking comeuppance for letting for family get murdered/taken hostage by Lannisters?
She didn't fly so good.

>rewatching the entire show
>coming up to season 5 finale

SOON STANNIS WILL AARGH

Attached: 1558911172012.png (640x354, 218K)

What evidence was given that they left? At all? The Unsullied left. Where is the evidence that The Dothraki left? Is the audience supposed to just assume that they left?

>Dothraki refuse to cross poison water unless following strong leaders like Drogo or Dany cause of her dragon
>will sail back to Essos somehow despite no one in Westeros speaking their language, and them not believing in money to pay anyone to sail them, fleets having been burned by Dany or Euron, Yara having very few ships and no reason to ferry people out of the kindness of her heart, and numbers in the 10s of thousands if episode 4 is correct in saying they lost half their men
No

Literally the villains of the series. Imagine killing your own husband for the dick of a lowborn incel who never even liked you, then not helping your sister after you got her husband killed and started a war. Why are the Tullys so autistic? Apparently Aegon thought they were worthy of getting control of the Riverlands. Even Hoster and Brynden had an autistic rivalry and Brynden refused to marry for no reason.

>Brynden refused to marry for no reason.
Blackfish is gay

At least Cat had good intentions behind her dumb actions. Lysa went full retard and let her entire family die just to get the dick of a guy that called her sister's name when they fucked.

Can't he just be a MGTOW?

That's the joke, they're the "Muh Family" house words nobles but they have done tons of evil shit completely opposite of family or honor starting with Hoster forcing Lysa to have abortion so she could fuck 80 year old Jon Aryyn.

No, definitely gay

And the Tullys rule Westeros by the end. Guess I forgot to laugh.

Are you confusing the fact that you used complains about previous seasons as a justification that the dislike for the show was previous to episode 8 with me pointing you out the ratings to prove you were wrong?

This is not about the ratings, I used the ratings to prove you were lying when you said people were complaining about the quality of the show in previous seasons. When I proved you they were not suddenly you didn't wanted to speak about it and claimed I had brought the point with the ratings, but it was you the one claiming people were complaining in previous seasons.

So you bullshit and change goalpostost as it suits you and when get caught you say you don't want to speak about it or that i actually brought the point.

What a shame.

Attached: Night_King_Fire_S8_Ep3.jpg (2100x1181, 567K)

And why you presume most of them remained and lived peacefully?
Doesn't seem a stretch? Weren't you the one complaining about realism?

But he never diddled Jaime, Robb or LF despite having opporunities to do it

>good intentions
Dude just release the only hostage of value you have because I said so without any proof your kids are even alive or that the deal will be honored
just look at these bones how could they be anyone but neds?

>This is not about the ratings, I used the ratings to prove you were lying when you said people were complaining about the quality of the show in previous seasons
Except the RT critic ratings do not encompass everybody's opinion of the show, you dumb, English-as-a-second-language faggot.

Why was it such a big deal that Lysa couldn't get a good marriage for being a non-virgin when Cersei was allowed to marry the fucking king despite getting already fucked hundreds of times by Jaime?

Why the fuck would Jon share his Targ heritage with Sansa when he was always closer to Arya?

I mean logically the only fear if I was Jon is Arya "nothing personal" Dany without his consent to press Jon's claim, but I think she'd respect Jon enough to keep his secret at least until Dany went full tyrant.

Are there any philosophers in Westeros?

I don't mean people in a room sipping wine and saying profound things; I mean "professional" philosophers. Maesters writing treatises on formal logic, septons making rigorous arguments about necessary or contingent properties of the Heptinity , some guy walking around King's Landing asking people questions about the true nature of justice, that kind of stuff.

It does seem like the maesters achieved that stage where scholarship is divided into different fields and subjects, instead of being one big mishmash as before Aristotle in our world. But it seems they don't have a chain link for philosophy, or any non-applied science for that matter.

Attached: chain.png (1000x1390, 1M)

That was Lysa's fault for being so desperate to kill him that she immediately gave Tyrion a rigged trial that Tyrion counter-rigged by demanding a trial by combat.

>And why you presume most of them remained and lived peacefully?
Because that's what the show lead the audience to believe.
>Doesn't seem a stretch?
Most of season 8 is a stretch. Why is this the hill you die on in regards to realism?

No one knew about the affair and I could see Tywin using bribes and threats to have a septa or silent sister claim Cersei is a virgin during a hymen test.

Complaining about language? That's all you have got?

You have been utterly destroyed and all you can say is that some autist in internet didn't actually liked it?

That's your defense?

>diddling public figures including your nephew or a snake like LF
He knows better. He's a confirmed bachelor despite being a war hero, skilled warrior and at one point being Hoster's heir

Reminder that at least Stannis died to a respectable character

They could have killed him off with those 2 no name bolton lads just before he aarghs

Attached: 1558349860972.jpg (976x1105, 611K)

You ignored the other part of my argument, dumb faggot.

Keep pretending that the CRITICS rating on Rotten Tomatoes is the sole indicator of a show's reception. Ignore every other metric or website and focus on the CRITICS rating on Rotten Tomatoes, because the entire fanbase falls in line with the opinions of the critics.

Objectively better than game of thrones!

Attached: 34nu9q.jpg (558x462, 98K)

>respectable character
>thinks that Renly had any sort of claim to the throne just because he was nice to her once

They're clearly talking about the Jamie for Sansa&Arya trade LF brokered.

Why are you fleeing that hill?
You were defending the others.

Attached: image.png (1920x1079, 1.3M)

So you got nothing. When proved wrong you just pretend reality doesn't exist.
Retarded and delusional. I guess you are a prog.

I didn't flee any hill. I am making the claim that the Dothraki integrated into Westerosi culture. Where is the evidence to the contrary?

That Daenerys heel turn really hurt.

>So you got nothing.
You just ignored my argument again, you room temperature IQ faggot.

How disrepectful of her character.

Bros... I miss him

Attached: BBV5gx8.jpg (624x351, 16K)

Where is the evidence in favor? Two guys walking in a dock. Seems very weak or nonexistent.

But I guess you have to cope somehow.

Would it have killed them to give those cucks proper armor? The fucking soft leather shit just looks awful.

Attached: 421576_476405779073213_545188317_n1.jpg (403x403, 52K)

There was a 17% drop before her heel turn. First of all, why do you think Dany's heel turn is the reason for the drop in the ratings of episode 5 instead of all the other reasons? Second, why are you ignoring the decline in ratings before the heel turn?

So we're all in agreement that Visenya was the best sister-wife right?
>tfw you'll never fuck your onee-san queen

>Where is the evidence in favor?
Where is the evidence against the Dothraki leaving?

The Dothraki were in Westeros--true or false?
The Dothraki were shown leaving Westeros--true or false?

BRIENNE: “Do you have any last words?”

Stannis considers.

STANNIS: “Do you believe in the life to come?”

Brienne nods.

STANNIS: “I don’t. But if I’m wrong, and you’re right… tell Renly I’m sorry when you get there. I don’t imagine I’ll see him wherever I’m going. (beat) And my daughter. Tell her… tell her…”

“Sorry” doesn’t begin to cover what he feels about Shireen. The thought of it brings tears to his eyes, and he’s not going to die weeping in front of a woman he doesn’t know. Stannis stares up at her.

STANNIS: “Go on. Do your duty.”

Brienne raises her sword and brings it down with a mighty swing.

This was how it was originally written. It was just cringe revenge for Renly cause D&D love him for some reason. Brienne has no right to pretend to be honorable when she backed a dude who had no honor himself.

>at least she promised the marriage of the King of the Norf/Vale/Riverlands to a Frey for the sake of 1 (one) bridge.

This still makes me so fucking mad. Arya is one thing but Robb and Arya fucking both?
As if the fucking Frey of all people couldn't see the value of a Norf/Reach or Norf/Dorne allaince in a war vs only the Lannisters & "Baratheons"

Fuck Cat

There is no argument, idiot. You have absolutely nothing. That argument only exists in your delusional head.

I have pointed you the RT ratings, the change.org campaings, the press articles, and all you got is some weak claim that some people in internet didn't liked it.

You have nothing retard, zero, less than zero, you have only weak whimperings trying weakly to pass as a point. The best you can do is to scurry back to your doritos and sob.

>traitor plotting to kill his brother and three kids he believes are his nephews and niece went to Heaven
Why the fuck do D&D love Renly so much?

They have magic fighting powers by cutting their dicks. They don't need it.

Bran
>journeyed beyond the Wall
>learned magic from a wizard
>travelled through time

Sansa
>watched a guy choke to death once
>watched a guy die in a dungeon once
>was told Littlefinger is a liar by psychic brother

I suspect many critics saw the next episode in advance that's what dropped the ratings. Seriously, was 4 worse than 3?

I don't know when they spent most of S3 shitting on him for thinking that he could be king just because he dressed nice.

Maestars are STEM. Philosophy comes from the bards, seers and Patchfaces

I don't think it sunk in how bad the long night was for people until later

How was Cersei able to cuckold Robert so easily for so long without anyone finding out? Was the Red Keep and Robert's procession so packed with Lannister men that no one had any incentive to report anything to him? but then quite a few servants and guards would know, so what gives? Took Jon Arryn and Stannis over a decade to suspect and find out.

You don't see the characters taking a dump. That doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

You haven't answered why do you presume they were pacific.

The Dothraki are violent or not?
Were is the evidence the Dothraki suddenly turned pacifistic Westerosi citicens?

4 was a good episode, except for Euron's hidden armada and being able to shoot sideways around mountains.

>I have pointed you the RT ratings
Which declined before Daenerys went bad and aren't an indicator of the fanbase's opinion of the series as a whole.
>the change.org campaings
Not a single mention of Daenerys was made in the petition. Why are you singling her out as the only reason why the petition was made?
>the press articles
There are plenty of press articles that pointed out why season 8 was shit besides going into Daenerys. What is your point?
>and all you got is some weak claim that some people in internet didn't liked it.
Millions of people on the internet didn't like it, you retard. Look at the petition you cited. And if you are trying to claim that everybody loved the series up until the second to last episode, that shit wouldn't even fly on this fucking website.

Plot armor, Bobby being shitfaced 24/7 and Jaime being allowed to be with the queen all the time because Kingsguard.

I also think many critics made their critics about episode 4 after seeing episode 5. That's what dropped the ratings. But that's just my guess. After all journalists didn't started to write articles about how bad was GoT end season until episode 5.

>Here are your options, Lady Catelyn.
>First we have Margaery Tyrell, one of the most beautiful women in the Seven Kingdoms along with an alliance with the most powerful kingdom and depriving the Lannisters of their strongest ally. All Mace wants is his daughter as queen, surely the brilliant and honorable Robb would be better than the psychotic Joffrey?
>Second we have the incredibly attractive Arianne Martell, who brings with her an alliance with Dorne, another of the strongest kingdoms. Surely her father, who hates the Lannisters for killing his sister, would accept.
>Finally we have Walder Frey, an untrustworthy asshole who never helps in wars despite already being sworn to the Tullys. He is bound to follow you, even without a betrothal. His daughters are mean and ugly, and all he gives you is a bridge.
Cat: Option C! Option C!

Seems like that would more be the purview of the septons

That's my point, it's obvious 3 is much worse. So why the sudden drop for 4?

>magic fighting powers by cutting this dicks
This just raises further questions.

No, they started disliking it from episode 4 because they could see the mad queenbowl building up from there

>"professional" philosophers

Has this ever been a thing? Lol
Most of Westeros’ attitudes about things like moral philosophy and justice derive from the honor meme. Even their cardinal sins and taboos like Kinslaying and Kingslaying are wrapped up in that meme. It’s the true religion of Westeros.

>there is no mention of them causing trouble.

Attached: not trouble.jpg (3733x1960, 481K)

because Starks are mary sues and not dumb & dumber being retarded
Also lannisters are the main characters

>I suspect many critics saw the next episode in advance that's what dropped the ratings.
People downvoted episode 4 on IMDB before they actually saw it. Whether it was better or not is irrelevant, because the damage was already done.
You are equating a huge, presumably hostile foreign army peacefully departing Westeros to taking a dump. If you think those two hold the same narrative significance, you are an idiot.
>You haven't answered why do you presume they were pacific.
There was zero indication to the contrary. I will just assume you mean "pacifistic."
>The Dothraki are violent or not?
They were violent until Daenerys died. Then they chilled out.
>Were is the evidence the Dothraki suddenly turned pacifistic Westerosi citicens?
The ending of the show, where they didn't do a single goddamn thing after Daenerys died except hang out.

They already crossed the poison water, it makes sense they'd be willing to go back home now that they've made the trip already. Regardless, this is what D&D said, so it doesn't matter anyway

>Mace: No, because I want my grandson to be king of the seven kingdoms not of ONE frozen shithole

>Doran: No, because I'm pretending to offer Arianne to disgusting old men so you don't realize that I'm planning on restoring the Targs many years from now because I love the family that cucked my sister and used her as a hostage until the very end so we would stay loyal to them

Even a betrothal to Asha would have made more sense since the North didn’t have a fleet. Plus there were merchant-states in essos that could have bankrolled them financially

>No, they started disliking it from episode 4
No, they didn't. A significant portion of the fanbase were put off by episode 3. Episode 4 preemptively received downvotes as a result. Then, when episode 4 came out and everybody saw how rushed and illogical it was, the ratings got even worse.

Littlefinger and Varys definitely knew, lots of other people probably too.

People were in denial after Episode 3. A massive schism emerged between show loyalists and people seeing what the show had become. A lot of the yaas queen twitter crowd thought stark girl do badass thing means the episode was good and that prophecy is for dumb nerds. Then they immediately lost the twitter crowd when it was obvious they were gonna do mad queen with the contrived Missandei and Rhaegal deaths.

They only crossed because of Dany and her dragons promising to tear shit up, and before that Drogo also planning to tear shit up. Who's leading them now to tear shit up when as Dany already said in her speech there's plenty of shit to tear up in Westeros still? And they're already there, and there shouldn't be enough ships to take all of them at this point after so many fleets being destroyed

>this is what D&D said
It still doesn't make any sense. Holy fuck I hate those faggots

>tfw I unironically defended episode 1 when it first came out

Attached: download.png (211x239, 4K)

The ratings are the ONLY indicator. You are just refusing to acept the facts.

The petition was started just after episode 5, I remember well because I heard it in the news. Damm, the hell turn of Daenerys was in the news all that week, with journalists pointing out how much it had pissed some fans (The libtards). That was the spark of the petiton.

cosmopolitan.com/entertainment/tv/a27479648/game-of-thrones-season-8-remake-writers-fans-angry-petition-change/

decider.com/2019/05/16/game-of-thrones-changeorg-petition/

iheart.com/content/2019-05-15-game-of-thrones-fans-petition-hbo-to-remake-season-8-after-the-bells/

But keep being delusional and lying to yourself and others.

Cutting your dick always rises questions.

>He is bound to follow you, even without a betrothal.
Really butters my biscut that even if Robb was late and Edmure was dead, the riverlands would defacto fall to either Blackfish or the eldest son of Hooters eldest daughter (Robb) making the marriage irrelevant in the grand scheme.

Did no one stop to say how retarded it was to sell out the hand of the king to the LATE LORD for the honor of crossing a bridge to save that lords fucking liege?
Did anyone bother to mention that Walder was clearly an untrustworthy traitor from the get-go?

Did anyone bring this up or bring up what a retard Cat is for making this deal?

I feel like Im taking crazy pills here

Visenya's cold demeanor and prowess with the blade make her more attractive to me

I feel like I've seen your style of arguing before. Are you by any chance a member of the Hebrew religious community?

You have a point.
Nah, it was about crazy queen

Lol the same people who scream "QUEEN IN THE NORTH" are the ones who loved Jon over her.

Walder threatened to not let them pass and ally himself with Tywin if he didn't get two marriages, two wards, a squire, plus tip

Hoster should have had him hanged for being an oathbreaker after the rebellion

>They were violent until Daenerys died. Then they chilled out.
And you call others idiots. This is so low effort.

Attached: Lol wat.jpg (1920x1080, 240K)

They would have been crushed by Tywin if they didn't have that bridge. Cat did lots of retarded shit at other points, but in this case she did nothing wrong.

Right, I see. So this proves my point of the backlash against GoT being purely ideological. I center it in Daenerys because it is the most visible part, but it's actually about going against the prog religion.

When the authors went that route the authors commited blasphemy.

>The ratings are the ONLY indicator.
First of all, that's just plain false. Second, the ratings where?
>You are just refusing to acept the facts.
No, I refuse to accept your narrative.
>The petition was started just after episode 5, I remember well because I heard it in the news. Damm, the hell turn of Daenerys was in the news all that week, with journalists pointing out how much it had pissed some fans (The libtards). That was the spark of the petiton.
So your exposure to the fanbase is the fucking news. Thank you. We finally got to the bottom of it. You weren't around when people called season 5 shit. You weren't around when people called season 6 shit. You weren't around when people called season 7 shit. You weren't around when people called the first two episodes of season 8 filler or boring. You weren't around when people trashed the shit out of episode 3 for numerous reasons. You weren't around when people bashed episode 4 for how rushed and nonsensical it was.

You heard in the news that feminist liberals cried about episode 5, so you came to the conclusion that Dany's characterization was the ONLY reason why ALL people hated that episode.

You need to get help. The 24 hour news cycle does nobody any good.

The petition was started before the 5th episode, I know it had 300k sigs by the 4th but can't remember if it was started after the long night or the 4th one

Don't confuse trashing your ass dialectically with being a j00.

Know the difference, it could save your life.

It was after the "Long" Night

*ahem*

Season 8 is objectively okay, it certainly has flaws, and also some good moments, as with all the seasons
Most "outrage" is repeated screaming from the same crowd (see: redditors), which is half the time useless nitpicks

Are there glaring flaws? Of course, however it is still enjoyable to watch overall

Attached: 1557070716699.jpg (1816x922, 733K)

There was zero indication whatsoever that the Dothraki left or caused trouble. I am merely stating the narrative failure that was depicted on screen.

Oh no, walder is gonna invade the norf with his whopping 20 sons and 80 daughters, the war is lost

Plus i don’t think she agreed to it. She just carried the offer to Robb who agreed

They needed to get to Riverrun which was under siege by Jaime at the moment and unfortunately the only way rod between Riverrun and Winterfell goes through the Twins.

>Most "outrage" is repeated screaming from the same crowd
Nigga, take a look at this board. Are you actually retarded? Do you honestly believe the myriad of inconsistencies in lore, characterization, logic and continuity are only pointed out by redditors?

I hate this boogeyman bullshit the people on here pull. Form an actual argument.

Please see user is baiting cause he's hungry for (you)s and is probably trying to get discussion to be so shit and repetitive that these threads get banned

>They would have been crushed by Tywin if they didn't have that bridge
How? You mean to tell me that the entirety of the northern forces couldn't make a temporary raft to cross before Harrenhall?
Or that worst case they couldn't hold tywin at the crossing while letting men sneak past towards riverrun?

Why did normies ever even like this show?

I have never said it was the only reason. Some people complained about the drop in quality

But hey, lets look at IMDB:

Season 1 lowest rated episode 8,7
Season 2 lowest rated episode 8,9
Season 3 lowest rated episode 8,7
Season 4 lowest rated episode 8,8
Season 5 lowest rated episode 8,1
Season 6 lowest rated episode 8,5
Season 7 lowest rated episode 8,7
Season 8 lowest rated episode 4,2

Well, maybe not.

So again I have given proof after proof and you have provided nothing.

Retard.

Attached: Proof.gif (176x172, 1.86M)

Do I see /got/ screaming about how S8=BAD all the time?

>They needed to get to Riverrun which was under siege by Jaime
>if Robb was late and Edmure was dead, the riverlands would defacto fall to either Blackfish or the eldest son of Hooters eldest daughter (Robb) making the marriage irrelevant in the grand scheme.

Because the Riverlanders would absolutely support Tywin for the 2nd Rape of the Riverlands or the Freys who were either late or Lannister dogs.

THE SEED IS STRONG

The Sansa rape episode didn't get flooded with 1s?

Bolton whore

>Why did normies ever even like this show?
They liked it because it was shocking and edgy. They then began to be hooked on the shock factor and began to judge every episode based on how nihilistic it was.
You have given proof of what? What is your argument? What is your premise? What is your evidence? What is your conclusion?

Have you frequented /got/ or any ASOIAF boards before season 8? Serious question.

*Lannister Whore
Her marriage to Tyrion was never annulled

Well, they did after the RW

>Do I see /got/ screaming about how S8=BAD all the time?
Yes. And season 7. And season 6. And season 5. The people here having been bashing the show's quality for several years.

It's the worst rated episode outside of S8

Date:
15/05/2019
Episode 5 aired 12/05/2019

So, just after episode 5.

The maesters' methods had to have come from somewhere. I know the Feynman quote about science and philosophy of science, but I still find it hard to believe nobody in the Citadel ever had a debate about the fundamentals of mathematics or scientific methodology.

They sure seem to know how to preach, but do they have their own equivalent of Thomas Aquinas? The Seven-Pointed Star seems to be a document of history and prophecy, not argument-based apologetics.

Hence the mock quotes.
I just mean people who are described as "philosopher" by Wikipedia. So Plato, Locke and Arendt - sure; Newton and Shakespeare - not so much.

/got/ shat a lot on S2, S3 and S4 as well

My conclusion is that you are an idiot that has been completely gangraped.

>How? You mean to tell me that the entirety of the northern forces couldn't make a temporary raft to cross before Harrenhall?
Not in time before Riverrun would have fallen and/or Tywin would have caught them.

>After Walder Frey breaks the most sacred oath in westeros and explictly allies with lannisters & boltons
>the same as before robb walks 15 ft over 1 bridge immediately falling Neds public Murder
Big brain alert

If not for episode 05S08 progs would have called this serie a "masterpiece of modern storytelling". Just look at what happened to Black Panther.

May 10th actually. I could swear it was around earlier but maybe got taken down and put back up

Exactly.
Nigga, you are on a board that has been bashing this show for years, and you are trying to honestly claim that people started to hate it after the second to last episode aired. You are retarded.

Sure, let's just ignore how D&D ruined the mystery and lore. Sure, let's ignore how the show managed to be rushed and full of filler simultaneously. Sure, let's ignore the blatant continuity errors in each episode. Sure, let's ignore the plot contrivances. Sure, let's ignore the logical inconsistencies. Sure, let's ignore the widespread character assassinations.

The fanbase of this show started hating it because Daenerys Targaryen--already a contentious character to begin with--became a tyrant in the second-to-last episode. None of the other stuff mattered. The execution also didn't matter. People only hate the ending because it runs their liberal fantasy.

That is your moronic argument.

Yeah sure. I'm going by the wiki.

So no. It was that specific episode. So much for the
>I-it's about the q-quality of the show user!
No complains in IMDB until the episode before, when the heel turn began.

I suspect some people here confuse Yea Forums arguments with the general opinion.

The average viewer of GoT is a prog that cares heavily about the politics of the real world to be portrayed on the show.

>The petition was before that episode!
No. It wasn't.

You can complain about drops in quality as much as you want but what really pissed of people was their wish fullfilment prog fantasy shattered.

>The average viewer of GoT is a prog that cares heavily about the politics of the real world to be portrayed on the show.
You literally just made that up.

Google dates the page to may 10th

If Robb doesn't cross the bridge then Tywin's entire army takes Riverrun, occupies the Riverlands and starts destroying it while Robb either loses men and time trying to storm the Twins or loses time going the long way.

As for Walder he couldn't give a rat's ass if the entire Riverlands get destroyed and all the living Riverlords curse him for the rest of his life as long as Tywin offers him some marriages for his ugly ass children.

Cat could have definitely made a better deal giving Walder some of Robb's bannermen instead of two of Ned's children including his heir because there is no way that Tywin was ever going to give Jaime to Walder.

Idiot, you are confusing this board for the general viewership?

I know you are a complete idiot that can't even recognize an obvious troll when it's in front of him but I can tell you that I know this show and his viewership better than you and I haven't even watched this show. That's how stupid you are.

And now I'm out. I got all the laughs I wanted at the expense of the retarded viewership of this stupid shit.

Imagine your some Bolton fuck, and you've just said whays gonna happen to Reek when Ramsay finds out he helped Sansa escape, only to get interrupted by a people on horses and your final words are "its a bloody woman!" Before being cut down by her

Attached: tumblr_msc9csz4wJ1sh28k6o1_500.gif (500x240, 1001K)

>I suspect some people here confuse Yea Forums arguments with the general opinion.
Have you even read what the petition says?

All you managed to do was come across as politics-obsessed faggot.
>I spent as much time on an argument as you! TROLLED!

There is no May 10.

Attached: twas merely an act.jpg (390x960, 118K)

twitter.com/GameOfThrones/status/1122881222500179968
Look at the replies, even the twitter fanbase was already split the day after Arya nonsensically killied the Night King.

>I made myself look retarded on an anonymous image board! I sure showed them.

New thread before I piss me self

The amount of coping from Aryafags was glorious.
>B-bu-but my non-existent foreshadowing.
>But her training was better than everybody else's.
>But she hid in the trees.
>But she under dead bodies.
>But she snuck right in front of the White Walker's faces.
>But she ran very fast and gave them no time to react.

>how else would you rather the NK go out? inexplicably lose a 1v1 to Jon? Arya caught him at the moment where he was the most off guard focused on his one true goal which was Bran and he still had the ability to catch her. he went out like a beast
LOL. Jon beat two White Walkers before The Long Night. Arya never saw a wight before then. Jon beating The Night King 1v1 is more illogical than Arya teleporting behind him and killing him to some people.

Ah, to still be in denial about the show's quality again.

B-but what about muh what do we say to the god of death?
>Retcons a vague prophecy that clearly only meant she would kill a lot of people, which retroactively ruins Mel's entire character

>this line from season one proves that Arya was supposed to kill the night king
>it doesn't matter that the night king was a show invention and that book lines don't apply!

...

>Mel did not deserve to get to act like a smug bitch that knew Arya would kill the Night King years ago when she already told 3 different people they were Azor Ahai, killing at least 1 of them
"Brown eyes, blue eyes, green eyes. Eyes you'll shut forever." Season 3, and blue eyes aren't emphasized like in Season 8