Is he the greatest director in history?
Is he the greatest director in history?
Other urls found in this thread:
theguardian.com
twitter.com
yes, and since the industry is basically closed off at this point, full of talentless hacks and committees, I doubt we'll ever get a truly creative director making big budget films ever again. this medium is dead for now. everything feels so derivative and processed, and shitty indie flicks can't quite capture the magic.
Clearly one of the greatest, but the greatest? Tough bar.
Not even close
Yes
Yes, anyone who thinks otherwise is just some retard jerking off their favorite french new wave director.
its close between him and Leone
Not even top 100. Get some taste, amerinigger
He has one of the coolest looks possible. The huge dark eye bags, the hair, just looks like a total mad man in the best way imaginable.
>Not even top 100.
kys retard
except that he was a manlet
yep
i'd say hes the most consistently good western director. best is very subjective
No, watch more films.
Yes.
No, that would be David Lynch
That's not my man Mike BAY
yes
no that would be Friedberg & Seltzer, the directing duo of such classics as "Disaster Movie" and "Epic Movie"
/thread
>babby's first director
For me, it's Ingmar Bergman
based
Yes
Greatest? Probably not. Most autistic? Definitely
hard to dispute, but Kubrick is an acceptable alternative
Who's better?
He's great at what he does, but wouldn't best ever have a wider skillset?
Kubrick might be the goat, as weird as that is. I think his movies can be strangely inhuman, but even admitting that, who else comes close?
>implying you can't be the GOAT and popular
Let's say that some of these are on the same level, some may even be better.
Tarkovsky, Bresson, Antonioni, Visconti, Angelopoulos, Tarr, Ozu, Yang, Tsai Ming Liang, Hou Hsiao-hsien, Murnau, Eisenstein, Griffith, Wilder, Kurosawa, Mizoguchi, Bergman, Dreyer, Vlacil, Capra, Lang, Rivette, Lubitsch, Ophuls.
Bresson is the greatest film artist of all time, followed by Tarkovsky and Dreyer.
confident enough not to be wearing 8" lifts like tom cruise and keet
Yes.
Based.
only ones you listed who come close to Big Stan:
tarkovsky, kurosawa, bergman, dreyer
No. All of them are close to him. Tarkovsky, Bergman, Angelopoulos, Mizoguchi, Wilder, Kurosawa, Dreyer, Ozu are arguably better than him.
Also Bresson, i forgot about him.
>Ozu is better than Kubrick
ozu is a good storyteller but has no visual taste. "herp derp lets put the camera on the floor and never move it." he shouldve been a novelist tbqh imho.
mizoguchi has exactly 3 good films, only 1 is great. hes not even on the level of naruse.
ill grant you wilder.
angelopoulos im admittedly not familiar with.
Tarkovsky is on his level. Bergman is better. All the rest are memes.
Yes
I’d say Nolan is closest we get these days. Even tho he gets shit ok here, he makes original blockbusters.
Yorgos Lanthimos has potential but he’s a little too weird.
That's a style too, very sparse but it's a style nonetheless.
Mizoguchi has several great films. Sansho, Ugetsu, Oharu, The Story of the Last Chrysanthemum, Crucified Lovers.
Naruse, i forgot about him you can add him too.
No, they are not memes.
Ozu is a total meme. No film of his comes close to Barry Lyndon, 2001, Paths of Glory or A Clockwork Orange.
BASED AND CHADPILLED
Well that's subjective. Tokyo Story, Late Spring, The Only Son, An Autumn Afternoon are great. It's true that he basically made the same film over and over.
No but he's one of the most interesting directors
You've never watched a Lang film if you believe that
nolan is more like today's hitchcock desu
he revolutionized the blockbuster game by making an actual effort into producing good stuff only for the MCU to drag it all to the mud
>must have big set pieces in muh movies
die brainlet
Among other things. Otherwise, what's the point? I could do a bullshit movie myself.
link your screenplay
Ozu is a hack – a literary man working in a visual medium.
*blocks your path*
i bet you couldnt defend putting 70% of these directors above kubrick and im not even a kubrick fanboy and i think hes a bit overrated
Learn to read. I said same level and some of them are higher. I can explain why i like them as much as Kubrick and why i like some of them more.
Doesn’t even look like 300lbs. There are women who can deadlift way more than that.