I watched these in the theater forever ago. Was thinking of a rewatch. Do the extended editions add anything meaningful? Or is it just fluff that only hardocre ring nerds would get?
I watched these in the theater forever ago. Was thinking of a rewatch. Do the extended editions add anything meaningful...
Ayden Peterson
Other urls found in this thread:
thesun.co.uk
twitter.com
Matthew Ortiz
Watch the extended editions. Right off the top of my head I can't think what it adds to the second one but the first and third improve even more from it.
Andrew Martin
it was a war crime
Nathan Parker
they add about 45 mins of extra stuff per movie. The extra scenes add some nice layering but it really throws off the fast pace feeling of the first 2, and it makes the 3rd one more tiresome than it needs to be.
Isaiah Baker
They're worth watching. Fellowship especially since it adds a bunch of scenes for Boromir.
Landon Sanchez
Lol, whut?
Jeremiah Bell
Extended editions are nice and comfy and add just that little bit extra to make true fans of the trilogy ultimately satisfied. I probably do a full re-watch once a year, takes almost a whole day but it's so much fun.
Andrew Gray
More Sean Bean is always good.
Daniel Adams
Your post just reminded me. The flashback for him in the two towers was much needed.
William Cruz
Alright sounds like it's worth marathoning at least once.
Sebastian Kelly
I like watching the extra scenes of arwyn and eowyn in tight, sheer shalls licking each other while the elves leave middle earth in the background
Xavier Harris
the extended editions are overall better. They add some great scenes sometimes and they add some so-so scenes sometimes.
In the last film they add the death of an important character, more Witch King, and the Mouth of Sauron. Which are all great scenes.
In the second film they add more treebeard stuff which is kind of lame, but they add more Boromir and Faramir which are great scenes that give the character more depth.
The action scenes pretty much remain the same extended or not, but the added scenes really polish the characters.
Adrian Roberts
Hey, don't lewd them, okay?
Julian Anderson
Josiah Campbell
This. They're worth watching even if you're not a mega ring nerd, but the ring nerds appreciate them even more
Owen Johnson
The theatrical versions are superior in every way possible.
Only plot point mental midgets disagree.
Easton Martin
>40
>still hasn't hit the wall
Best girl
Henry Johnson
Thanks, for the comprehensive answer, rare for this board.
Just looked on amazon, I am assuming the 15 disc 2012 one is the one to get?
Wyatt Parker
It sucks that these movies haven't been remastered with Dolby Atmos yet
Adrian Thomas
Don't watch the extended editions they all have dogshit filters over them, even more than the theatrical versions.
Austin Harris
You're thinking of the Bluray version. The original DVD box set of the Extended is the best-looking one.
Christopher Lewis
No, the Bluray of the theatrical version is the best-looking one.
Have fun with your 480p garbage.
Nicholas Sanchez
that's because she was born inside the wall.