choose Yea Forums
Atlantis vs Treasure Planet
Adrian Smith
Aiden Nelson
Treasure Planet has pathos, Atlantis is generic action adventure. Also the animation in Treasure Planet is much better
Ayden Bennett
The Black Cauldron
Robert King
This belongs on
Parker Morgan
You belong on Yea Forums
Jaxon Russell
treasure planet, hands down
drink bleach you stupid cunt. slit your wrists.
Ayden King
Treasure Planet is the objectively correct answer.
Bentley Perry
Austin Myers
No u
Brandon Ross
i stick to my kidself, i watched Atlantis only for the sea monster (although my cousin wasn't eager to watch the rest) and i went into two cinema viewings for Treasure planet.
Julian Taylor
Live Action Treasure Planet When? It's just Star Wars mixed with Pirates of the Caribbean.
Liam Morris
FPBP
Ian Moore
Landon Ortiz
I vote Titan AE.
Isaac Campbell
Treasure Planet, absolutely no question about it.
Noah Powell
Treasure Planet
>AND IIIII WANT A MOMENT TO BE REAL
Jackson Cooper
Underrated film desu
Wyatt Lewis
Treasure Planet. It has lot more emotional weight than Atlantis.
Both have similar story beats. However Atlantis has 5 different characters the main character bonds with, while Jim has 1. Jim and his relationship with Long John Silver gets explored a lot better and it makes his eventual betrayal heartbreaking. By contrast you don’t care as much about his multiple friends all betraying him.
Cameron Russell
i want her to beat me up :3
Nicholas Reed
I’m surprised that Treasure Planet doesn’t get the praise it deserves, it’s genuinely amazing.
John Roberts
Also with Jim and Silver, you find out early on that Silver is the bad guy, which creates tension because you're wondering "Is he really going to go through with it? What's going to happen between them?" Whereas in Atlantis it's just used as a cheap plot twist
Joshua Harris
Atlantis: Shrugged
Caleb Fisher
It was sent out to die in the theatres and heralded the end of Disney's traditional animation studio. They sabotaged it because they wanted to transition to 3D full time and Treasure Planet was costly enough for them to justify their actions. It's honestly really sad considering it was a passion project of the two directors.
Aaron Diaz
>it’s genuinely amazing.
It's an OK adaptation of a literary classic that has better adaptations.
Did you fucking people really not read Treasure Island as kids?
Jose Garcia
Atlantis
Matthew Bailey
neither
Joshua Miller
neither
Daniel Watson
I have read the book, but only once and I was maybe 10 at the time. I've seen Treasure Planet, the 1950 Disney version, and Muppet Treasure Island. Of the three, Planet is my favorite.
Brayden Cooper
Based Bakshiposter, but OP’s movies are both quality as well
Dylan Williams
Treasure Planet is technically amazing, seamlessly utilizing 3 different animation techniques: traditional, CG and Deep Canvas. It was costly as hell but was made with care. It's got great fucking actors and a wonderfully original visual style, retro physics sci-fi Age of Sail fantasy was incredibly realized.
Jackson Campbell
Eli Long
Henry Ward
>Not Alantits
You had one fucking job.
Luke James
hands down atlantis, i'd rather jerk off to treasure planet though with generic goo goo dolls remake in the background. We can all agree, titan AE is a nigger with knockoff googoo dolls.
Andrew Thompson
I even as a young kid I understood her too well
Brayden Moore
I love Treasure Planet but the OST is fucking awful
Carter Flores
I NEED THE NAME
Landon Powell
This nigga.
Dominic Perry
Canela Skin
Noah Martinez
>all these wrong answers.
The only true champion film.
Leo Cooper