What the fuck was her problem?

Ned was a moron.
Like most starks.

Wouldn't Ned have no reason to keep Jon's lineage a secret once he swore his Night's Watch oath?

If the promise was to not tell anyone, it would make sense. Then again he did say "when we meet again, I will talk about your mother".

that was the plan but he got moved to kingslanding

Would Jon resent him for it? He got swindled out of his birthright

>Didn't trust his own wife
Haven't you watched the latest season? The moment he told Catelyn the whole realm would know in less than a minute.

>the dumb bitch who sent Ned to King's Land to die because her dumb bitch sister said something wacky was going on despite her being a dumb retard bitch
Perfect person to trust

season one

femcel cuck rage

That's a retarded promise to keep considering you're letting your nephew waste his life at the night's watch and potentially get himself killed. Lyanna was on her death bed she couldn't think it through

She assumed Ned wasn't the kind of man who would have a bastard and Jon existence was kind of a stain on their strong relationship. She kind of spells it out on that same scene.

She's in a setting that's 100% justified in being fearful of bastards.

Her husband's perceived disloyalty aside, bastards are a few murders away from moving up the social ladder or in this case usurping a lord paramount house. Even if Jon clearly loves his siblings the same couldn't be guaranteed about his descendants. The Starks will have to always watch out for claimants to their seat of power.

This was the stuff that spawned the civil war between house Targaryen and their bastard spawned cadet branch, the Blackfyres.

ned knew not to trust idiots like cat with information like that. she is a blabber mouth moron

Is having ONE bastard even that bad compared to everyone else Ned wold still be a saint.

Completely miscast. She's supposed to be a MILF with big floppy tits, instead they cast an old hag with a permanent stank face.

yeah but the Blackfyres were such a threat because they were all legitimized.

Ned raised him to not want it, part of the reason he was kept out of the spotlight and denied glory was because they feared his targaryen blood but ned did such a good job at raising him to be an honor autist that it countered the targaryen retard gene.
Unironically should have been the king or at least master of war. Or at least let him be king and abdicate and exile himself.

Attached: 1232336550.png (941x823, 330K)

Lyanna's fault for being a shank and putting this on our boy Ned

Which she is paranoid about that happening since Jon was brought to Winterfell to be raised alongside his 'half-siblings'. That raises a lot of redflags when you're suppose to just dump your bastard or remotely send them money or something.

but the blackfyres were right though, fuck daeron, and aegon the 4th was based

The only person who can legitimize a Bastard is a King. It's pretty unlikely Ned would ever ask Robert to legitimize Jon. Though once Robb had plans to her concerns were justified.

>but the blackfyres were right
Nah, cringe and bluepilled the lot of them.

Attached: Bloodraven (1).jpg (300x420, 45K)

>bow faggot
gigacringe

Look at what happened when Jon told a woman his secret

Lord Stark's only problem was that the woman bearing his children were not my sister

Attached: 1557876383593.png (723x944, 570K)

Blackfyre rebellion spin-off when?

Attached: GcQDMUI.jpg (1280x828, 346K)

Found the Frenchfag. Still butthurt over Agincourt?

MILF.
MILFF.
MILFFF!

Sansa kept her promise for a full 30 minutes, imagine what a full Tully would do

>Would Jon resent him for it?
Would Jon resent being protected from Bobby B's Warhammer? Cause Bobby finds out it's Rhaegar's kid with Lyanna Jon is gonna wish a Bolton was the one torturing him

Attached: GODSTRIDENT.jpg (862x1200, 344K)

bowfags ruin everything in fiction like paris and legolas

after more shitty whitewalker shit

>Spinoff about some fag Targshit rebellion
>Instead of the Chad Robert's rebellion
Found the dragonspawn

Attached: 1558281685224.jpg (800x450, 70K)

why is Bloodraven standing with Bittersteele and Aegon?

>Ned does this to trick Jon into joining an organisation where you forfeit your heritage and possible titles
>he tells Jon that he’ll tell him about his mother when he’s back from KL, by which time job will have taken his vows
>this ensures that once Jon knows his lineage he can’t do anything about it and won’t threaten the realm’s stability
Ned was a based schemer this whole time

Attached: 3DAA80A8-9A4B-4CA2-A2A3-FC7D4FCABAB5.jpg (1280x720, 62K)

Ned knew he couldn't trust Cat. Rightfully so.
Dumb cunt pulled some dumb fucking stunts because "muh feelings" that ended up getting people killed.

that's daemon and they are the biggest players involved with the first blackfyre rebellion

>says the 10% dragon spawn

This, the superior genes were wasted.

and bran saw the plan through

Cat is the ultimate Stacy. Brandon Stark was a cruel, violent, short-tempered jackass. So of course she would love someone like him.

she didn't really have a choice in the matter it was an arranged marriage. i don't know if she ever says she loved brandon, she barely even knew him.

Jon was a lesson in how upbringing can overcome birth, yet paradoxically also how much birth to a house defines you and is inescapable. Jon was raised as a Stark and is almost more of Ned's son than Robb given how Jon appears likely to put duty ahead of love in the books. Cat was entirely in her right to be suspicious and ambivalent towards Jon, but

Good lord what a handsome bloke. Thought that was that Targ shit Rhaegar for a moment for how aesthetic he is.

His wife would have told her sister, her sister would have told little finger, little finger would have let it be known to spread chaos.
>Ned Stark is raising a Targerian so he can claim the throne.
If Ned couldn't keep his mouth shut, then Cat most definitely wouldn't be able to. For the sake of his whore sister, he kept it a secret.

Jon was overcompensating as a bastard. He had to be more Stark than a Stark.

He dudin wan it.

Renly wanted to kidnap all of Cersei's children and imprison them the moment Robert B died. Ned said no "it's not honorable" and then he was beheaded. Ned was basically retarded

Like me she's mad there was no Lady Stoneheart. When they cut her I knew this show was gonna start to suck.

Brandon wasn't cruel nor violent. He was just a chad that loved fighting like Robert and was raised to be lord.
He was pretty merciful in his duel against Littlefinger.

In the books, Robb is comforted by Westerling as he's in a depressive state considering he thinks both of his brothers area dead, there's no word of Arya, Sansa is still booked up in King's Landing, and his biggest emotional support, his mother, is grief-stricken. The capital was sacked by Theon Greyjoy, who he considered a brother.

There isn't any irony, you're just sticking up for some brooding lad, which is fine, but let's not stretch out some dumb shit over it.