Start with "Generation Kill" and how different it is from the book:
1. Colbert ("iceman") isn't a Jew, never says any such thing, for fuck's sake his last name is french-canadian
2. The negro-Injun isn't even a full recon marine in reality, they try to make him into a "leader" among the men
3.They try to make the one "racist" guy into dumb white trash, when in the book, Colbert is the biggest "racist" of all and refers to spanish as "filthy mud talk" constantly
I can see not explaining the negro isn't a full recon marine just for the sake of brevity. The real weird one is making Brad a Jew out of fucking nowhere. Wonder how the real guy felt about that. Saw the real guy interviewed a tong time ago and dude has a face ugly as sin.
Also, the rolling stone writer should have had a screenwriting credit since essentially most of it is just his dialogue copied direct from the book with no changes. Anyone else read the book and watched the series, and did it piss anyone else off?
Can we talk about series they changed from book for no good reason?
Other urls found in this thread:
why does that matter?
Nah I forgave it. Mainly because it’s the most real depiction of the corps instead of all the shill hero films out there.
>why does that matter?
But Why fucking put that in there, except torn brownie points with the jewish HBO bosses? It just comes out of nowhere and it's nuts, the Jew thing. Also, they let all the negroes hate "the white man" as much as they want, but you can't have an alpha character who calls the spics "muds." And the one constantly calling others "wiggers" is Christensen, who turned down a naval academy appointment. I just hate how they have to warp every reality to fit a hollywood narrative. No one who engages in racist banter can be a great marine like Colbert was. AND has to be a Jew for some reason.
>Mainly because it’s the most real depiction
In the book he also gives away the second in command, the Exuctiive Officer, and accuses him of blowing away civilians with his shotgun, since he was only one carrying a benelli shotgun.
And "The Coward of Cafji," The Master Sergeant, got arrest as a pedi years after the show. It's weird to watch the series know knowing that the highest enlisted is an IRL pedo.
I think they want the audience, largely liberal, to empathize with him more, so that the story is more powerful.
And the mythos of a multi-cultural America, where different people are united to defend a common ideal, is a strong and powerful one also.
I don't think it's for no reason.
You didn't exactly answer my question either. Why does it matter?
It's a story.
>Colbert ("iceman") isn't a Jew, never says any such thing, for fuck's sake his last name is french-canadian
user, are you sure you're not brain dead?
wtf..are you high? read the book and see him interviewed. He IS NOT a Jew, nor were his adopted parents. And Colbert is indeed a name with French roots, i.e., the posed talk-show host of age name. WTF is your point???
>You didn't exactly answer my question either. Why does it matter?
>It's a story.
If you're just writing fiction, then fine. If you're cutting out certain things for sake of brevity and to make it work on screen, I get it. But to just randomly add "x is a Jew" out of fucking nowhere, when he never says such a thing in the book or in interviews?
There's a big difference between "a story" and a book that is indeed true to the real story in most wats...save for some random non-PC shit the don't like, so just cut. THAT does fucking bother me.
No one said that he's a Jew you mong.
Why does it bother you?
You've only explained what it is that bothers you.
>No one said that he's a Jew you mong.
WTF? Have you seen the series chaim? When his driver makes fun of him being adopted, and he says: "That's right..I was raised in in a home with 2,000 years of Talmudic tradition.." And then when the negro priest comes over, the driver says: "sorry, told love to join your festive services, but my team leader is still a practicing Christ killer, so purely out of respect to him, I'm going to forgo it.."
they mention in the series 3-4 times, and it's NEVER in fucking books. fucking Jew, stick out like a sore thumb and can never accept the truth. although god forbid someone fells to mention in any bio, no matter how fake, that anyone who did something good a anything and IS a fucking Jew is always NAMED as a Jew.
Hysterically, there was a big fight at DC comics years back when superman comes back to to WW 2 to help the Jews fight the NAzis. They have on the Beanies and have names like "moshe," BUT, since the comic never explicitly says THEY ARE JEWS, the ADL started a big fucking thing and demanded an apology.
So, in other words, the other ay around is cause for you to wail and rend your garments with you, but in a REAL story, when a non-Jew is named as a Jew, that's fine, correct?
HBO have become mothfucker's, not a single fucking clip allowed on YT. But is the dickhead above seriously going to tell people who have seen the series that Colbert never tells people in the series that he is a Jew? When people with HBO Go can find it in 5-10 minutes??
Is the book worth a read? Seen the series
What the fuck are you on about? There are numerous Generation Kill videos on Youtube. I don't even know how to to explain Ray's comments during the Christ Lover visit. Any normal human being would understand the scene. Also, Colbert WAS adopted into a Jewish family you cockuscking homo.
lol so he actually is jewish?
jesus christ op
the absolute state of you
what is even the point of making masculine straight war kino if you're STILL going to find a way to get triggered by it?
>lso, Colbert WAS adopted into a Jewish family you cockuscking homo.
Don't buy it. only source for it is "kikeapedia," and when you go to the footnotes, everyone 404s. for fuck's sake, the name COLBERT is a Roman Catholic French name. It doesn't add up, any of it. And why didn't Rolling Stone add it into the book during exchanges with the priest and the rest? The fucking writers don't add even One additional piece of info that isn't in Evan Wright's book, but yet they somehow just happen to add this? Nope, not buying it.
I'll trash the down the dude's email, and ask him himself if it's true, just to settle it.
Here come the "tin foil hat" comments. "Wy, how could you POSSIBLY think wikipedia is manipulated for the purposes of better Hasbara for the Jews-- esp when the book "Stolen Valor" reveals Jews had the lowest enlistment rate, lowest death rate, and highest deferment rate of Any ethnic group?"
>lol so he actually is jewish?
HE IS NOT. He has a Catholic surname, there are 2 sources in wikipedia the use to claim it, and both 404. It's NEVER mentioned in the book, which is fucking 600 pages and literally documents their lives down to every mention of them taking a shit, but Wring doesn't mention this and the fucking interaction wit the priest?
it says
>Colbert was adopted into a Jewish family.
on wikipedia
I don't know why you're so sure that's a lie
hey OP, you're exactly the type of faggot those guys would make fun off.
I met exactly 1 Jew in the army....and he was a piece of shit.
Imagine that.
>Trying to get a non union boy a writing credit
Yeah, that's not happening
OP why do you fear the Jewish boogieman?
you sound like captain america
>And the mythos of a multi-cultural America, where different people are united to defend a common ideal, is a strong and powerful one also.
this remainds me The Right stuff. When they started hiring first astronoust they found out most of these guys were mid-west presbiterian white origin. Then when they started with second recruitment wave for space they had only twelf positions nut the only black guy who registered couldnt pass them. So they NASA increased it to thirteen to make Kennedy happy.
Oh nice. The XO was a real cunt so I’d love it if something came to that. It showed how absolutely incompetent leadership is in the marine corps. You have almost all of the intelligent and good men leave after their first contract. I think most stay for gibs after that or because they think they’ll make an impact.
GAY PORN
/pol/ rots the brain.
Not as much as Jew propaganda.
To be fair, yea they do. Like a number of times in the show.
I Don't know if he was actually Jewish or not. But user seems to think it's a change the show made?
Why comment in a thread if you don't know what's being discussed?