Was this a bad line of dialogue?

Was this a bad line of dialogue?

Attached: 1535412920584.jpg (839x839, 99K)

In a vacuum, no.
In that situation, yes.

it's a terrible line coming from a terrible character. it's one of many moments where you just want to walk out of the theater right then and there.

maybe if she didn't just allow the first order to blast their otherwise nearly-impenetrable gate open and allow her comrades to get slaughtered

Not really. But it's the context that renders it dumb. Like how "no one is really gone" could be a really heartfelt line in tone with how they handle spirituality in the OT, but in the context of ep9 it's just a warning that they don't give a shit about anything meaninful and will just keep rehashing stuff and characters as long as its profitable.

Why did she save him when no one is ever really gone?

It's hypocritical liberal bullshit. They say shit like that while they blatantly hate white people, even going as far as making the Empire an allegory for white people.

Because that's not how they're gonna win.

TLJ is a movie full of things that work perfectly fine in a vacuum, but as a whole produce a clusterfuck. This movie is what script doctors are for.

MCU movies have some of the worst dialog I've ever heard

>"Mister..."
>"Doctor."
>"...Mister Doctor?"
>"It's Strange."
>"Maybe. Who am I to judge?"

She's just doing whatever a Sith needs to do. Wrecking the plans of the Rebels.

Attached: 1555224809904.png (913x2732, 2.82M)

Kinda. Wars are about killing people and breaking stuff. At least it is if you intend to win.

The Empire = Nazism, not white people you fucking mouth breathing "victim."

Is this the most Canadian line in history?

>that image
kek. thanks user/

this made no sense. you can still fight what you hate to save what you love

>Nazism
>not white people
What did he mean by this?

That's classic wordplay.

>kiss
>sparks go off
>except you realize the sparks are all your friends probably dying because of your actions

Attached: love.png (1000x1537, 1.96M)

What did you mean by that?

>Yes that's what I was doing you fat gook, now watch the space nazis blow up all my friends in the bunker

Anakin tried that and got like a 50% success rate. And that success was nullified by the sequel trilogy.

senseless libie mentality
a mouthful with void of meaning

>What is needs of the many, outweight the needs of the few
Clearly Rose and, by extension, Rian needs to learn a thing or two about life and death situations.

There literally hasn't been a good line of Star Wars dialogue in 20 years. Prove me wrong.

Maybe in the real world where you can enact policy changes when you're not engaged in a massive total war. But definitely not when you're down to like 20 schmucks facing numerical and technological disadvantage, and imminent destruction. What the fuck could you possibly save? It was sheer luck that the cave had a back entrance and that Rey was suddenly the strongest Jedi ever, otherwise they'd have all been slaughtered.

shes a bad character because shes fat and ugly imo

It was fucking fantastic, but not for the reasons they intended.

Why did Star Wars replaced all aliens with minorities? The main characters are still white, it's like saying anyone none white is an alien.

I thought it was a cute idea of subverting the >hero's sacrifice trope that was played straight in the beginning of the film with her sister's sacrifice. It worked for me.

It was empty dialog, since she had just expressed satisfaction in destroying some property of people who hadn't done anything to her beyond 'being complicit in the system'. Progressive morality is reduced to tit-for-tat pettiness.

Sacrificing yourself only brings your numbers down--when you need every soldier for the war, leaving people behind to martyr themselves doesn't make much sense.

>Great joke creating a relevant misunderstanding and using wordplay
>worst dialog you've ever heard.

When they drop shit like "My only curse is you.", you pick one of the better lines from the MCU to harp on.

That's even assuming 100% of the people at the Casino were slavers. Maybe some were just opera singers, or sold space cabbages.

it makes plenty of sense when the martyrs save more people than would be possible with any other strategy

her hair looks like a wig unnatural as fuck wtf

But in that scenario his sacrifice wouldn't have saved more people. He just would have died.

you should research more

its quite a reasonable thing to say - in fact very emotionally mature.

Yes.

>We will save everything that we love by compromising the safety of everything I love just because I want the BBC in my flappy Viet vagina.

One of the only good jokes from the only good MCU film.

I like to think all of the space dogs they freed died a week later from starvation and being hunted since they cannot fend for themselves out of captivity, the slaves had seven shades of shit beaten out of them for being incompetent, and the rampage killed a dozen scholars and foreign diplomats who would have changed the world for better.

Now it's worth it.

>Our house is being flooded. It's completely fucked so let just save our most valuable furniture so we can put in our new house.
It's a metaphor for the franchise.

It's an ok inspirational speech in most situation, just not the one presented in TLJ.

Yes, it's pathetically naive, it's exactly the sort of stupid, shallow, sentimental bullshit that women say and lack the intelligence to understand how stupid and inadequate of an idea it is.

The Empire wins because they have serious scientists, intellectuals, generals, officers, and yes footsoldiers to carry out orders precisely and efficiently.

The movies are, in the Enlightened view, a subtle commentary on the necessity of Order in a universe threatened by the chaos of unrefined intellect.

Not to mention, they're industrialists and super wealthy casino-goers. It's literally Space Monte Carlo. They'll all have insurance and the destruction will be fixed immediately, by droids and slaves.

His sacrifice would have stopped the laser that broke the door. They would have been safe inside. The magic invisible cave no one ever noticed for the last 50 years was just deus ex machina bad writing.

Aren't there only around 40 people left in the resistance? What is the fucking point now? There are hundreds of quadrillions of people in the galaxy. What the fuck are so few people going to do? It is not even like they are all some elite bounty hunters or jedis or supreme alien race or some shit. What could they possibly do?

even in a vacuum it's. stupid meaningless. fighting your enemies and saving your friends are not mutually exclusive, and sometimes saving your friends requires fighting your enemies.

That’s because there just so happened to be a magical cave and Luke with a vagina just so happened to find them.

Then Disney's writers and directors should've tried harder

Admiral Hodl had just fought what she hated

Yes.