Multiculturalism doesn't wor-

Is it really all about skin color, not culture?

sneed

It did become multicultural, right before its collapse.

>t. Brainlet

>no tolkein black guy

How so?
Roman wasn’t multicultural. Notably almost all peoples in the western empire assimilated into Latin culture. And most of the east assimilated into Greek culture. So at most you could claim it was bicultural

Multiculturalism between whites doesn't work either
Ever tried making a brit, a german and a frenchman work together?

>french engine
>german driver
>british driver
checkmate, tranny

Attached: redb_vett_silv_2011-31.jpg (1680x1120, 256K)

*british designer

But the Quest was completed successfully and the fellowship isn't officially dissolved by Aragorn until the very end when they all go back to their homes so it did work

The world is already 'multicultural' fucking retard.

Attached: 7CRHBX4ZU5g5Zk3jDmcL2w7oucD9nPKpTzVLv9Mj.png (792x658, 650K)

>>french engine
cringe

The roman army had been comprised of citizen soldiers but after a certain point the citizena got too soft and werent enlisting so the roman army starting conscripting non romans and foreign mecenaries who were not loyal to the roman people or the empire. The army became increasingly disloyal and mutinous as a result and the western roman empire was repeatedly invaded by itsbown army and collpased. Its all the dangers of multiculturalism made real and yet mouth breathers point to rome has a good example of the multicult because they are genuine NPCs.

-k

Attached: 1529652606591.jpg (300x188, 16K)

All Europeans. A single Orc would derail the fellowship, let alone multiple ones.

Meant to tag
as well

Middle earth is meant to be Europe, the Hobbits are English etc... the entire fellowship is European.

Only orcs, and Saurons other armies (from the south and east) can be considered completely different races.

>whites most diverse race on earth
>we need more diversity

Why didn't they try to adapt orc culture into their own?

Complain about it all you want. You’re gonna have to deal with multiculturalism whether you like it or not lol

The message is clear faggot, multiculturalism works only when there are no orcs around.

It made me laugh user don't worry

>make fantasy epic with all-white cast
>drives ticket sales to record-high never matched since
>spend every year since then trying to pander to subhuman demographics, or all demographics at once
>still get high highs but low lows offset this altogether
>lash out against whites for not committing to your cause and hating themselves
>still can't match that LotR high
Let whites have their own movies, jews.

Attached: untitled.png (700x500, 36K)

I haven't interacted or even been in the same room as someone of another culture or race in years.

Not leaving your mums basement doesn’t count senpai

My town is 99.7% white

>Non-humans
>Europeans

Attached: Brainlet.png (474x711, 90K)

>so the roman army starting conscripting non romans and foreign mecenaries who were not loyal to the roman people or the empire.
Employing foreign mercenaries does not mean your society is multicultural
>The army became increasingly disloyal and mutinous as a result and the western roman empire was repeatedly invaded by itsbown army and collpased.
Rome invaded by it's own army? I've never heard this before, give examples

>literally beat the Roman into your barbarian ass
>multicultural

Multiculturalism doesn't work. They all lived in monoracial societies.

With the likes of the lower half of Great Britain the soldiers stationed there were mostly comprised of people from modern day northern France, Netherlands and Belgium because they thought the Britons would take more kindly to people similar to them. You didn't get swarthy Italians trying to assimilate them.

TLOTR is meant to be a British mythology, Tolkien wasn't even a novelist, he was a scholar of ancient languages and european mythology, his writings were more of an experiment or hobby.
There are plenty of non-humans in european myth, like elves, dwarves, and hellenic gods.

>who is caesar

t. 0.3%-er

Attached: lord of the rings cast.jpg (1280x853, 258K)

I meant invaded by it's own army that was mutinous and full of foreign soldiers near the end of the empire like said

LOTR is proof that multiculturalism works....as long as everyone knows their place in society.

If black people would just stop committing crimes and being violent thugs and bullies I would not have a problem with them. Fact is, they are ignorant monkey creatures who do not care about their fellow man, educating themselves, higher ideals, or advancing the human race and I don't want my children to have to deal with them.

So where is the Roman Empire now?

yer lookin at em prick

Attached: tumblr_l8vsfzgPnu1qavmb0o1_500.png (500x398, 341K)

and that's to stay in your own race's kingdoms and nations

>Enough with this meme

romans were multicultural...no idea how you can say otherwise, but im interested.

>almost all peoples in the western empire assimilated into Latin culture.

>educated romans spoke greek tho.
>Emporer head of Babylonian mystery cult of chaldea

define Latin culture, because even that is composed of lots of greek and celtic influence

>Middle earth is meant to be Europe

very eurocentric mindset you have there

Attached: 8r1xm0bfnd621.png (800x562, 561K)

You are actually clinically retarded, seek help.

>leader of rivendell elves product of racemixing

He isnt wrong, they started giving barbarians citizenship and german culture infiltrated the roman empire leading to its demise

THEY ARE ALL EUROPEAN THO

>Employing foreign mercenaries

they actively recruited foreigners into the legions by the 2nd century

>implying roman culture isnt multicultural from the very beginning as an amalgamation of greek, etruscan, celt, gallic, and iberian and eventually persian.

wew do anons really think rome was a singular entity and not a bottom up system from local tribes to chieftains and client kings who travelled freely?

>except when youre travelling from kingdom to kingdom on your quest whenever you feel like it

Doesnt your picture literally prove it? and this idea isn't even mine it is literally what Tolkien himself intended; Middle earth is Europe in the distant past.

>EUROPEAN

europe as an idea didnt exist

>gondor in Africa
>implying there arent lands beyond mordor

What’s the difference?

>Peadophiles and Slavers are the fact of multiculturalism
Hmm...

>fellowship of 9 people
>every one of them is white
this would never be allowed these days

>Live in Brazil
>Get violently murdered

>Middle earth is Europe in the distant past

Then why don't they look like this?

Attached: Cheddar.png (748x676, 436K)

Why were the orcs excluded? was it racism?

That statement was recanted soon after, the Cheddar man did not have dark skin.

Except it was JULIUS CAESAR who did that at the end of the Republic.

how the fuck is lotr multiculturalism? they live in separate countries and a small team works together to take down a common enemy. they don't all live in the same nation.

I can just imagine LOTR made today, what an absolute thematic tragedy that would have been

Europa doesnt exist r*tard

fuck you racist bigot

I wonder what Amazon are going to do.

Attached: lord of the rings amazon map4.jpg (1000x730, 194K)

Cope

>no orcs
Fuck you racist bigots

Yeah but you need an empire and not democracy to make it work

notice how there are no orcs in this image

>officially dissolved
Tee hee

>the Quest was completed successfully
Yes by 2 Hobbits

Have African American elves of course.

Even though OP is retarded, Gimli and Legolas' relationship was inarguably a tale of "different races can get along with each other and only petty shit actually divides us"

>various germanic tribes
>various celtic tribes
>various turkic tribes
>greeks
>egyptians
>even some negroids sprinkled here and there

>not multicultural

Attached: 1553427950683.png (1228x1150, 230K)

#notallharadrim

Tfw the allied forces of Sauron, comprising the white people of the Black Numenorian rebellions, the people of color from Harad, Rhun, Umbar, etc,, as well as the Orcs and Uruk-Hai and many other monstrous races and demons, all working together to slowly destroy the remnants of the Dunedain, nearly wiping out Arnor and slowly chipping away at Gondor for centuries on end.

>of course multiculturalism works, haven't you seen Lord of the Rings?

Attached: serveimage (2).jpg (1159x665, 91K)

Attached: lbj.jpg (850x400, 86K)

one loses their virginity late. the other never does :^)

Because most people the Romans conquered assimilated. The main exception being Greece
>they actively recruited foreigners into the legions by the 2nd century
And they assimilated until they were Romans

wrong, Christianity became the state religion then it collapsed. during Augustus' time it was successfully polytheistic, every creed was allowed.

Yeah, it just like only existed for a thousand years and then continued as the byzantine empire for a thousand more. Such a short time.

that is true, but that has nothing to do with multiculturalism.

>Roman Empire
>Turkic tribes

Based brainlet

Gimli is shopped here.

Attached: 1546770818476.jpg (476x477, 22K)

>various germanic tribes
They became Latinized
>various celtic tribes
Became Latinized
>various turkic tribes
Which ones are you referring to?
>greeks
The one notable exception
>egyptians
Became hellenized
>even some negroids sprinkled here and there
Became Latinized

It’s not multicultural if everyone is assimilating into the dominate culture

So like the Fremen from Arrakis? Olive skin and glowing blue eyes, I think that was the description of the Fremen, who were based on Middle Eastern and Native American peoples, but mostly Middle Eastern and Islamic cultures.

The Byzantines never called themselves Byzantines, they called themselves Romans. I think some white academic guy descended from Germans called the East Romans Byzantines.

It didn’t immediately collapse when it became Christian you brainlet

cope

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turkic_peoples
>what are scythians, parthians, etc.

I honestly wouldn't mind multiculturalism as much if the non whites we brought over were less brown. Japs, Koreans, Slavs, etc.

Brazil isn't multicultural according to

what did the romans ever do to us?

Scythians and Parthians were both Iranian people, not Turkic

Istari are Maiar, but not all Maiar are Istari
Wizard is correct

>what are scythians, parthians, etc.

Not turkic

why is it orange

Then you can call them multiethnic. And it's not like they completely gave up their cultures when they became assimilated. Also, after the Western Roman Empire collapsed, Greek became the dominant language since Latin was dying out due to Aryan Barbarians (Germans and Slavs) pushing their way into Roman territories and displacing or killing many of the Romans who spoke Latin all the while Constantinople and the Eastern Empire had their hands full with the Persian armies making inroads into Roman territories from the West.

>I honestly wouldn't mind multiculturalism as much if the non whites we brought over were less brown. Japs, Koreans, Slavs, etc.

Attached: 23108720-AC5C-4311-8196-1C836AE10F8F.gif (800x371, 125K)

No TV, no internet, no radio, no schools and vast lands and you want me to believe that somehow they managed to get everyone to have the same culture? Fuck off.

>You need modern technology to get people to assimilate
Single digit IQ post

if you think this is an argument for multiculturalism, you're a hopeless fool

So? The point is that if youre going to blame it on the typical shit everyone on /pol/ does (sexual degeneracy, idol worship, multiculturalism, etc) then the next counter is "it became Christian much closer to its collapse than any of those things."

Pointing at cultural mores for the reason why Rome collapsed is retarded, but when those mores were common even under the Republic it's REALLY retarded.

Go on and tell us how exactly they managed to make people in all those places have the same exact culture. Even today you have countries like India where this happens.

Attached: a.png (720x845, 49K)

>Then you can call them multiethnic.
Yes I would, but there’s a significant difference between ethnicity and culture
>And it's not like they completely gave up their cultures when they became assimilated.
Yes, but they assimilated enough for themselves and others to consider them Roman
>Also, after the Western Roman Empire collapsed, Greek became the dominant language since Latin was dying out due to Aryan Barbarians (Germans and Slavs) pushing their way into Roman territories and displacing or killing many of the Romans who spoke Latin
What the fuck are you talking about? Latin remained the most widely spoken language in the west after the empire fell. All the barbarian tribes who formed their own kingdoms began to speak Latin.

The Romans were able to spread their architecture and laws to much of the lands they conquered. Also, the Romans had a habit of settling their people into various parts of the Empire while those who weren't originally from Rome could travel across the Empire.

It's a Marxist argument, and a damn good one that's been observed by politicians and thinkers at least since antebellum times.

Just look at the historical evidence man, why do you think people in Spain and France still speak variants of Latin? It’s a fact that they got those native celts to assimilate until they were Romans

against multiculturalism, yes
injecting diversity is capitalism playing divide and conquer

/pol/tards only see modern concepts of race and retroactively apply them. The idea that ancient peoples cared more about which city you held citizenship in and your accent than what your skin color was literally does not compute. Your pic to the average person itt is just different types of brown.

>post is memeing that multiculturism works
>everyone is white
What did he mean by this

So, where's the Roman empire now?

race isn't culture

"What the fuck are you talking about? Latin remained the most widely spoken language in the west after the empire fell. All the barbarian tribes who formed their own kingdoms began to speak Latin."
- Read Charles Oman's "The Byzantine Empire." gutenberg.org/ebooks/37756

"Yes, but they assimilated enough for themselves and others to consider them Roman"
- One of the Roman Emperors decided to declare all those who were living within the Roman Empire to be Roman Citizens, that way he could tax them. As long as they remained part of the Empire and didn't cause any problems and followed Roman law, they were good to go.

Don't even know how to adequately react to how stupid you are. LBJ was bemoaning the fact that the working class fails to coalesce in America because they're too concerned with racial infighting. You take it one step further to imply he meant that it's therefore bad for more than one race to occupy a country. That's you extrapolating based on your own worldview.

Attached: 237e1ca6-44ff-4326-a5fb-9d4bea32eb4e.png (970x546, 590K)

******ians ruined it

back to discord, tranny

>One of the Roman Emperors decided to declare all those who were living within the Roman Empire to be Roman Citizens, that way he could tax them. As long as they remained part of the Empire and didn't cause any problems and followed Roman law, they were good to go.
Nothing to do with what I’m talking
About

Upvoted

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_people_in_Ancient_Roman_history

multiculturalism is why the Empire fell, (You) stupid fucking bastard

Prove it

>everyone is assimilating into the dominate culture

>the upper caste is everyone.

>multiculturalism is why the Empire fell

actually its why it survived as long as it did. 3rd century was a flustercuck

>assassinates JFK
>conspires with Israel to attack the USS Liberty
LBJ is the worst president

There are 4 races there: Elf, human, dwarf and hobbit
Also: do Russians have the same culture of Irish people?

Really? You sure it wasn't the Aryan Barbarians from the North of Europe forcing their way into the Roman Empire while the Persians or Seleucid Empires were trying to start was in the Eastern Half of the Empire? I've watched some History programs and read some history books(actually e-books) that told me that those Romans you admire didn't really like the Germanic tribes that were forcing their way into the Roman Empire. Sound familiar? Only now it is people of Aryan descent who are angry that non-whites are trying to get into Europe, mostly due to wars or instability in their homelands. I guess the French were right to be angry at us Americans and pour fake blood over their miniature replicas of the Statue of Liberty while our armies were bringing down an oppressive regime in countries like Iraq.

Also, because of the Romans, African DNA has made it's way into the European gene pool.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_people_in_Ancient_Roman_history

theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/aug/12/black-people-presence-in-british-history-for-centuries

But it wasn’t just the upper caste

The empire continued as the byzantine empire for +1000 years

Attached: byzantine.jpg (676x338, 207K)

>didn't really like the Germanic tribes

Yeah Caesar said this about them:
>Caesar described the cultural differences between the Germanic tribesmen, the Romans, and the Gauls in his book Commentarii de Bello Gallico

>He describes them at length at the beginning of Book IV and the middle of Book VI. He states that the Gauls, although warlike, had a functional society and could be civilized, but that the Germanic tribesmen were far more savage and were a threat to Roman Gaul and Rome itself.

>Caesar said the Germanic tribes were nomadic, with no notable settlements and a primitive culture. He used this as one of his justifications for why they had to be conquered.

I forgot to add: have you ever read Ralph Ellison's novel, "Invisible Man?"

>There are 4 races there: Elf, human, dwarf and hobbit

You forgot Angel (Gandalf) and Human/Elf mutt (Aragorn)

bruh the romans didn't even consider people from sardinia and northern italy to be proper romans

give proof that it was always like that

You really have to stop trying to view this in the modern lens of nationality. The people of Rome (the city) viewed people born in Rome as *true* Romans, yes. But that's not to say they were on the whole against people living in Rome with them, and by the time the Empire came around citizenship was granted to large swaths of people--effectively killing the exclusivity of the title. Never forget that Caesar was a plebeian.

In the prologue to the Lord of the Rings it says that the lands themselves changed. So yes Middle Earth is Europe a long long time ago.

newscientist.com/article/2161867-ancient-dark-skinned-briton-cheddar-man-find-may-not-be-true/

>You can interpret some vague passage one way
>Therefore that's the correct way to interpret it

I bet you're a protestant too, huh?

sprinkle some orcs and nazgul there and lets see how it goes

Dwarfs are Jews thi

so civilised europeans then

He's right though

>non-democratic
>slavery
Probably the best argument against multiculturalism

>may