RIP Cyclops

This Moira's 10th life, not her 11th.

No, a clone is a clone. A copy. X-Men runs on sci-fi lingo, not soul/religious themes. If they are ripping Dune with gholas with same memories, the soul thing not stick.

But he’s not circumcised anymore and his tattoo if Logan is gone

Then they become their own person.

X-Men has had multiple stories dealing with demons and shit. They even had one where they went to heaven to bring back Kurt.

Why in Bruce Wayne Beyond in this photo?

I mean Spider-Man sold his marriage to the devil. So when his soul got erased by Otto, he went to hell, too.

I’m glad he is dead. Finally that faggot is dead.

And Tony has died and been replaced at least three times. And he was adopted.

This is exactly what a clone would say, also new clones are all virgins

This user is right if they're using the Clone Conspiracy interpretation. It was also clarified in Ben Reilly's comic. When someone dies their soul goes off if that person is resurrected then their soul comes back to their body. Ben died and was resurrected so many times his soul got messed up. In Spencer's ASM it was confirmed that Connors' son is the same because he has the same soul as his original son.

Don't forget teleportation technology that takes you apart in one place and puts you together somewhere else. Lots of soulless not-originals out there.

The only one I can think of who’s actually acknowledging it is Tony Stark and he’s being an idiot about it

Which still raises so many questions about the clones of people who were still alive from that same event like Hobbie and that one Parker Industries worker

the comic literally refers to the animus and the soul being placed in the body

It was shit and PAD and Spencer had to fix Slott's mess. At least Spencer used it for good, I didn't like Curt killing his son.

Not a retcon. He was just brainwashed to think he was. Then killed off so that Marvel could parade Kobik's abomination as the real Cap.

I thought history was rewritten by Red Skull with the cube.

Reminder that it's still canon that Secret Wars destroyed the 616 and killed almost everyone in it and outside of the handful of people in Reed and The Maker's raft, Doom and Doctor Strange, everyone we've seen since then has just been an almost-perfect copy made by Franklin Richards.

>hating the return of the endless summer

bitch made

Why does everyone keep ignoring that House of X and Powers of X take place in timelines before our current 616 came to be? Are they just retarded and have no reading comprehension or do they just create these threads as a form of mental excercise?

>Why does everyone keep ignoring that House of X and Powers of X take place in timelines before our current 616 came to be?
Prove it.

They should have used Secret Wars to do their own New 52

Pretty sure he can't. It's obviously not 100% true, but I imagine Hickman has coordinated things at an editorial level so that no other comics currently coming out can disprove House of X isn't happening right now in 616. Only notable difference is the number of dead in the Genosha attack, but that may have just been a fuck up by Hickman. Still, all the story beats point towards what he said being true, what with all the "you may have one more life if you make the right choices" Moira thing and Moira being absent from all of the events in House of X.

So how bad is Hickman going to fuck up Magik? Unlike these non-mystical plebs her soul explicitly does not instantly return to her body until she reclaims it.

What part of
"A body protects you from the after-life" do you not understand?
What part of
"Growing up means preparing while you are protected for when your protection cracks away like an egg shell"
do you not understand?
When a person does they famously see their life flash beforehand eyes and biological explanations for this are meaningless when you are discussing a supernatural soul.
When Doc Ock dies, his soul escapes his body, his body that had Peter's memories burned in and had Dock Ock's memories either erased or surpressed.
But when Dock Ock dies he as a ghost should remember his entire life with clarity but not Peter's life because those memories were artificially imposed on his brain.

Apply this to Xavier's current resurrection processes.

Yes and no. It was a recursive loop. It was altered, but in the new reality, at the end of WWII, the allies used the cosmic cube to change things back with the altered timeline's Captain America being the only survivor. So it wasn't just Cap's memories being altered, since Captain Hydra actually experienced that reality, but that reality was erased.

>X-Men runs on sci-fi lingo, not soul/religious themes
Nightcrawler is RIGHT THERE.

Magik, Jean Grey , Nightcrawler and Wolverine all have memories that make this entire resurrection scheme dubious and those memories are probably getting edited out by Xavier.
Remember this is an Xavier that exists inside Moore's mind. In her _th life CHARLES and Moore decide to break all the rules.

Cassandra Nova could be written as a manifestation of Moira Mactaggard.

If they were still alive then the clone develops a new soul, just like what happened with Peter Parker and Ben Reilly/Kaine. Ben and Kaine have souls, their own unique souls, because Peter was still alive when they were made.

This is the kind of post that seems to define "soul" as "value".

>references Ghoula without understanding how they work
lel. If it were ghoula that would still be the real scott once he activates and accesses his genetic memories.