You can only pick one.
You can only pick one
Thomas Walker
Other urls found in this thread:
Kevin Howard
I don't own a vcr.
Jaxson Walker
We can help with that
Joseph Anderson
I choose Wizard of Oz because it had a big close-up of Ashanti's bare feet.
Juan Martinez
Christmas Carol by a long shot. Treasure Island is great but Christmas Carol is a better adaptation of the source material while still keeping the Muppet humor intact.
Also
Christmas Carol = Muppet Movie > 2011 > Great Muppet Caper > Treasure Island > Manhattan > Most Wanted = From Space
Colton Harris
That's what thrift stores are for.
Jeremiah Phillips
This guy has got the right idea.
Charles Russell
>robot gonzo where they play with his radio dial nipples
i have to go with christmas carol
Anthony Rogers
Post-Jim Muppets started off pretty good. But then it all went wrong with From Space. Why?
William Sanders
I'll choose both and you can't do a damn thing to stop me.
Leo Taylor
I forgot that even existed, and you should too.
Zachary Brooks
>walt disney pictures
Michael Martin
Muppet Christmas Carol, but only if it's the VHS version because every other home release of the movie omits "The Love is Gone" scene.
Bentley Roberts
Unironically Sony.
Fucked around with From Space and Grouchland too much and they both bombed, no one would touch Jim Henson Productions til Disney bought the Muppets, and even then aside from 2011, all they've done is fuck everything up.
Some of the DVDs have it if you watch in Fullscreen
Benjamin Wright
what? i have it on dvd and that song is in there
Juan Perez
Muppet Wizard of Oz is also the most accurate to the book.
Jackson Wood
Treasure Island because Scrooged and Mickey's Christmas Carol exist.
Austin Phillips
I watch one of these once a year.
Maybe if there was a pirate holiday, Treasure Island would have a chance.
Nicholas Wood
Treasure Island so I can use the $10 coupon.
Ryder Morris
I can see why they axed it, it's a weird tonal departure, that plot never really resolves, and all the rest of my family hate the song.
I like it though.
Julian Wright
WHEN YOUR A PROFESSIONAL PIRATE
you dont even have a choice
Carson Young
I'll just go the the store and buy them on a DVD/BluRay/Digital combo pack.
Chase Jones
Christmas Carol blu ray is missing one of the songs. Treasure Island has Great Muppet Caper on it for free
Daniel Rodriguez
Christmas Carol is great but I wouldn't put it equal to the original. The Muppet Movie is still the best one.
Parker Brown
Which Muppet movies are actually canon to Kermit's life, and which ones are just stage productions he happens to star in-universe?
John Diaz
Muppet Christmas Carol is my favorite Christmas movie. There's nothing more cozy than being wrapped up in a blanket with a big mug of hot chocolate, turning the tree lights on and singing along to Marley and Marley
Samuel Rivera
I'd have to say Treasure Island.
You can watch it all year round, plus there are tons of other Christmas Carol movies to choose from.
Ian Jackson
As cheesy as it is I like when the Ghost of Christmas Yet to come literally bends reality into a dark void through which to traverse time
Dylan Ortiz
Only one of those movies has Tim Curry in it, the choice is simple.
Andrew Hill
When this is a top choice Carol adaptation there is no choice
James Hernandez
treasure island dickens a shit
Parker Morales
Shimber my timbers shimber my bones
Logan Edwards
On one hand, I think Christmas Carol is the better Muppet movie
But if this is a "wipe one from existence" situation, other posters raise the point that there aren't that many comedy adaptations o Treasure Island, especially on par with the Muppet one