>Saw this when it aired
>thought it was a good show, nothing special
>it was just like your average anime
>people rave about it now like it's the best cartoon ever
Why?
>Saw this when it aired
>thought it was a good show, nothing special
>it was just like your average anime
>people rave about it now like it's the best cartoon ever
Why?
Because you're not the target age group anymore. Yea Forums loves to wank this show as the best western cartoon of all time, but the show's various flaws and problems are lost through the nostalgia goggles.
>why
there isnt enough journey cartoons anymore. segaway cartoons that werent completely a comedy yet has serious moments at times is no where to be found in the endless see of slice of life " x is the joke of the week " shows.
People hate animation and want it to be like anime aka Japanese soap opera levels of writing and nothing that makes good use of animation
That’s why they latch onto an anime-like series
It's better than any anime out there, get serious dude
there aren't a lot of good examples of action cartoons
I wouldn't consider it better than the anime at the time like FMA:Brotherhood, Death Note, or Season 1 of Darker than Black
ATLA is not the best cartoon ever. Here is the best.
>anime at the time like FMA:Brotherhood
FMA:B only started after A:TLA ended. The contemporary anime would've been FMA, which it was definitely superior to.
>it was just like your average anime
>people rave about it now like it's the best cartoon ever
>Why?
You answered your own question
The incest.
still better than animes in general.
had a way better story going than any of those 2010 cartoons.
Neon Genesis Evangelion? Cowboy Bebop? Lupin III? Even stuff like Captain Tsubasa has better depicted rivalries and villain-turned-reluctant-good-guy than Avatar.
I like Avatar, but is is underwhelming in some aspects, and certainly not western's "best animation".
It was a good action cartoon and there aren't enough of those.
I don't know what anime you're talking about but it's not the anime I've spent the last twenty years watching.
Death Note is fucking trash m8
Because everything else is dogshit
Does nobody on this godforsaken board have more than a single goddamn image of ATLA to use for their shit threads?
They all be on me udder HD.
I know people who watched the show as adults who genuinely love it. It's in the top ten on IMDB iirc, that doesn't just happen through nostalgia.
can water benders make high psi water-jet cutters and cut people to pieces. also can they control waters density and make super dense ice to use as projectiles.
Realistically no, fantastically yes.
atlas like the fma:b of Western animation
>It's better than any anime out there,
cope
It happens exactly through nostalgia. It's a public voting system made by any schmuck with an account.
I don't see why brotherhood is held in so much higher regard. They're roughly the same halfway through and brotherhood gets too shonen with it's cliches and final battle. 2003 crumbles once it tries coming up with its own ending while missing key elements of the manga, but desu what it does up till then isn't bad and at some points better than its counterpart
You literally already made a thread with this exact question and this exact image.
The most of the titles with >7 rating on myanimelist are the same or better than A:tLA.
Because during it's airing in the mid to late 2000s there was not a single other cartoon on tv even remotely as good as it except for maybe the one exception of teen titans. Even the first season which is acknowledged by everyone to be pretty boring took a fat diarrhea dump on everything else in 2005-06.
Even if it would have been remembered as an average show if it appeared on toonami in 2000 the fact it came on nick and in 2005-08 immortalized it
It's one of the best of its genre yeah, albeit rather vanilla. Idk what would be the best one, but it's still good.
I'm not sure I'd spend energy to find the "best" show.
I don't get it either, OP. I tried watching it at the time and was put off by how annoying the characters were, how boring the show itself was and how the main antagonist is the most generic villain you could possibly imagine.
>one exception of teen titans
Teen Titans is fucking garbage.
based
I dunno, look at what we have here in the west. Avatar was a high effort show with a story that actively tried to improve on itself.
Hell, even Korra is the same tier as Avatar and Boondocks, both shows are incredibly well animated and almost no short cuts were taken.
The reason why we don't have more is because only a select amount of animators can actually draw in that style and make it look good and realistic
In 05 and 06 cartoon network didnt have anything else that was as good. It was the only reason anyone watched maguzi
I always thought that it was a show that was always worth a watch and when it was good, it was goddamned great, but I wouldn't call it the best cartoon ever even back then
I think a lot of it has to do with weebs who wouldn't watch a cartoon before this thinking "finally, cartoons are like my precious animoo"
And ATLA is perfumes garbage. Still comparable