Is it better to hire a fan, or someone who's never experienced the property before? think carefully

is it better to hire a fan, or someone who's never experienced the property before? think carefully

Attached: 1557786604561.gif (250x250, 282K)

Other urls found in this thread:

youtu.be/RBmoQSHfO2U
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

Both a gamble. You need someone who gets it though.

a fan
not a fanboy, just a normal fan

Attached: kevin-feige.jpg (760x718, 54K)

Wrath of Khan was made by a dude who had no real exposure to Trek beforehand and it's still the best movie in the series to date.

Sonic Mania was the brainchild of longtime fans. It's solid.

So a little from Columns A and B

Your question presupposes that only sequels and reboots and prequels exist, OP. You fool. You imbecile.

Being a fan or not has nothing to do with how skilled a person is. I find that in my work place, the best people tend to bubble up when things get tense and work is risky. That’s why the weak want to kill off crunch time in the video games industry.

can you be a deluded fan of your own work, then?

False Dichotomy. A fan could be a shitty writer/director, and a nobody could be a good writer/director. Or vice versa.

The key is finding a fan that is sane and knows what they like and why, which allows them to replicate it into future works.

Have both.
A professional who makes storries and shit and a fan who points out the greatest blunders to prevent bullshit from happening

Ian Maxtone-Graham never watched the Simpsons, but he still managed to write the masterpiece that is S11E05.

>Looked up the name
youtu.be/RBmoQSHfO2U

A fan. But not just any fan. Me. I can do it I wouldn't fuck it up and everyone would love it. Too bad they'll never give me a job.

pick unrelated?

This or you could have the professional be exposed to some stuff from the property to get them prepared.

It's better to hire someone who can adhere to their schedule and cares primarily about the craft itself first.

>Wrath of Khan
>and it's still the best movie in the series to date.
You misspelled Voyage Home

Either one could work, you need to hire somebody else to keep either from going full retard.

It's better to hire someone competent.

/thread.

If you pick "fan", there's a chance that your show will end up ZUKED.