Is there any argument AGAINST a mutant ethnostate Yea Forums? Because as long as the land is obtained legally and everyone migrated willingly it seems like the right idea. Mutants are best suited to police one another, especially those born with dangerous powers and need time to control them.
It’s essentially expanding on the X-men’s mutants-only school concept so I’m not sure exactly why they are so opposed to Genosha/Asteroid M.
Go to bed, Magneto.
Gas all muggers
Dr Xavier and Magneto utilize their powers to unify mutants for their respective causes.
The former wants to bridge the gap of trust between mutants and the rest of humanity by training his kin to be a protective force. The best environment for him to do so would be one in which thinking and interacting are indispensible (a school).
The latter wants to give himself and his kin sovereignty on the basis of genetic differences from the rest of humanity. The best environment for him to do so would be one that is easily fortifiable and controllable (an island fortress).
They're different approaches to and perspectives of the same conflict.
The X-men school isn't mutants only. They've had depowered mutants there and they once had a completely normal human student.
The issue is normal humans generally don't apply because the place is a fucking death trap and because fuck muties.
Then the rest of the world realizes that all of the world's mutants joining together as a single nation makes that nation ridiculously powerful.
Normal humans will end up hating and fearing the mutants even more. And any mutants who stay in their birth countries will be seen as potential saboteurs on behalf of Genosha.
Governments and people will fear you because of the potential. Mutants are so expansive in individual skillsets that it's never possible to defend yourself if they decide they want all humans dead. It's like having a couple of nukes with different functions. Paranoia will set in. Having an enthnostate also bring the ideas of militarism, more so than Xavier's school. Xavier's school, while having gotten big over the years, is still way smaller and it's image as a "school" has always been good part in letting people see it in a positive light. Humans in Marvel now are retarded anyway. They hate mutants too much now and this wasn't always the issue. Humans also used to hate any superpowered being but on a lower intensity, which made the hate on mutants more tolerable.
>as long as the land is obtained legally
That's impossible. What country is going to voluntarily give up territory?
Magneto could just make an island out of scrap metal in international waters
palestine