Is Two Face a good villain?

Is Two Face a good villain?

Attached: Two-Face.png (547x480, 259K)

50/50

He's sort of a toss up.

He's best when he's the real protagonist/focus of the stories he's in, otherwise he just comes off as either a generic lunatic that Batman pays lip-service to having once been a good man, or Joker with a duality gimmick who Batman treats no differently than any other villain.

I'm of the opinion they should have either let him become an anti-hero, or just killed the poor, miserable fuck off and let the concept of Two-Face be a legacy character.

Two-Face should ideally be more reserved and mysterious than Joker to set them apart. Two-Face's appearance, personality, and his habit of deciding people's fates make him come across as much more strange and sinister than the Joker. Not in a colorful, amusing way, but more in a creepy "intently watching you from the shadows in silence" sort of way. Tommy Lee Jones did it completely wrong, although I suspect that had more to do with the script he was given.

Yes and no.

Broken Harvey Dent, yes. Separate Personality, no.

He used to be more or less good but his best stories are Joker or Harley stories now

Imho while the execution wasn't perfect, the Telltale take was really cool where he became a tyrant.

This.
So many people don't get what he actually is, and why he's possibly Batman's deepest and most interesting villains. They need to read Eye of the Beholder.

It's kind of like Mr. Freeze, he's been developed into such a fantastic, memorable, tragic character, but due to inability to use restraint he gets used inappropriately, when he should only be used when you have a really good idea for him.